Modda 146
Article 146
Musulmonlar Shariat ruxsat bergan soliqlarni to‘laydilar. Bu soliqlar Bayt al-Mol xarajatlarini qoplash uchun undiriladi, bunda soliq faqat shaxsning odatdagi ehtiyojidan ortiqcha bo‘lgan mol-mulkdan olinishi shart, va u Davlat ehtiyojlarini qoplashga yetarli bo‘lishi kerak.
Muslims pay the taxes that the Shari’ah has permitted to be levied upon them in order to cover the expenditure of the Bayt Al-Mal, on the condition that it is levied on that which is surplus to the individual’s needs according to what is normal, and has to be sufficient to cover the needs of the State.
Ushbu maqola uchta masalani o'z ichiga oladi: birinchidan, soliqlarni to'lash; ikkinchidan, bu soliqlar shariat me'yorlariga ko'ra shaxsiy ehtiyojlardan ortiqcha mol-mulk bo'lmasa olinmasligi; uchinchidan, ular faqat Bayt al-mol ehtiyojlarini qondirish uchun zarur bo'lgan miqdorda olinishi va undan ortiqcha olinmasligi.
This article includes three issues: firstly, the payment of taxes; secondly, that these taxes are not taken unless it is surplus wealth to personal needs according to the norms; thirdly, they are only taken as required to fulfil the needs of the Bayt Al-Mal and not beyond that.
Birinchi masalaga kelsak, "soliq" so'zi G'arb atamasi bo'lib, hokimiyat o'z fuqarolarining ishlarini boshqarish uchun ularga yuklaydigan narsani anglatadi. Savol shundan iboratki: Islom davlati musulmonlarning ishlarini boshqarish uchun ularga soliq solishi joizmi? Bunga javob shuki, Shariat Bayt al-Mol daromadlarini belgilab berdi va bu daromadni fuqarolarning ishlarini boshqarish uchun belgilab qo'ydi, fuqarolarning ishlarini boshqarish maqsadida soliqlar joriy etmadi. Bundan tashqari, Payg'ambar ﷺ fuqarolarning ishlarini ana shu daromadlar orqali boshqargan, va u zot odamlarga soliq solgani tasdiqlanmagan, bu haqda u zotdan hech narsa rivoyat qilinmagan. U zot davlat chegaralaridagi odamlarning yurtga kirayotgan mollardan soliq olayotganini bilganda, ularni bunday qilishdan qaytardi. ʿUqba ibn ʿOmir rivoyat qiladi: u Allahning Elchisi ﷺ shunday deganini eshitgan:
As for the first issue, the word: “tax” is a Western term, which means what the authority imposes upon the subjects in order to manage their affairs. The question is: Is it permitted for the Islamic State to impose taxes upon the Muslims in order to administer their affairs? The answer to this is that the Shari’ah defined the income of the Bayt Al-Mal and fixed this income to administer the affairs of the subjects, and did not legislate taxes in order to administer their affairs. Additionally, the Prophet used to administer the affairs of the subjects using these incomes, and it is not confirmed that he imposed a tax upon the people, and that has not been reported from him at all. When he learnt that the people on the borders of the State were taking taxes upon the goods that were entering the land, he forbade them from doing so; it is reported from ‘Uqbah Bin Aamir that he heard the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) say:
.» لا يَدْخُلُ الجَْنَّةَ صَاحِبُ مَكْسٍ «.
.» لا يَدْخُلُ الجَْنَّةَ صَاحِبُ مَكْسٍ «.
“Nohaq ravishda ortiqcha soliq (sohib maks) oladigan kishi jannatga kirmaydi”, deb rivoyat qilingan (Ahmad rivoyat qilgan, Al-Zayn va Al-Hokim sahihligini tasdiqlagan). Abu Xayr Ruvayfi‘ ibn Sobitdan eshitgan, u esa shunday degan: “Men Allohning Elchisi ﷺ shunday deganlarini eshitganman:
“One who wrongfully takes an extra tax (sahib maks) will not enter Paradise.” (reported by Ahmad and authenticated by Al-Zayn and Al-Hakim), and Abu Khayr heard from Ruwayfi’ b. Thabit who said: “I heard the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) say:
.» إِنَّ صَاحِبَ الْمَكْسِ فِي النَّارِ «.
.» إِنَّ صَاحِبَ الْمَكْسِ فِي النَّارِ «.
“Soliq solishni kuchaytirgan kishi do‘zaxdadir” deb Abu ‘Ubayd “Al-Amvol” kitobida rivoyat qilgan, Ahmad ham rivoyat qilgan va Al-Zayn uni sahih deb tasdiqlagan. U aytdi: “Bu al-‘Oshir degani”, al-‘Oshir esa tashqi savdodan o‘ndan bir oluvchidir. Bu G‘arbiy ma’nodagi soliqlarni joriy etishning harom ekanligini ko‘rsatadi. Payg‘ambar ﷺ Abu Bakra orqali kelgan, ittifoq qilingan rivoyatda shunday degan:
“One in charge of imposing extra tax is in Hellfire”” reported by Abu ‘Ubayd in Al-Amwal, and it was reported by Ahmad and authenticated by Al-Zayn. And he said: “It means Al- ‘Ashir”, and Al-‘Ashir is the one who takes a tenth from the foreign trade. This indicates the forbiddance of imposing taxes according to the Western meaning of the word. The Messenger (pbuh) said in an agreed upon narration from Abu Bakra:
. إِنَّ دِمَاءكَُمْ وَأَمْوَالَكُمْ وَأَعْ رَاضَكُمْ عَلَيْكُمْ حَرَامٌ كَحُرْمَةِ يوَْمِكُمْ هَذَا فِي بلََدِكُمْ هَذَا « »... فِي شَهْرِكُمْ هَذَا .
. إِنَّ دِمَاءكَُمْ وَأَمْوَالَكُمْ وَأَعْ رَاضَكُمْ عَلَيْكُمْ حَرَامٌ كَحُرْمَةِ يوَْمِكُمْ هَذَا فِي بلََدِكُمْ هَذَا « »... فِي شَهْرِكُمْ هَذَا .
“Albatta, sizning qoningiz, molingiz va obro'yingiz xuddi shu kuningizning, shu shahringizning va shu oyingizning muqaddasligi kabi muqaddas va daxlsizdir”, bu umumiy bo'lib, Davlatni ham o'z ichiga oladi; soliq olish esa musulmonning roziligisiz uning molini olishdir, bu esa uni olishning harom ekanligini bildiradi.
“Verily your blood, your property and your honour are as sacred and inviolable as the sanctity of this day of yours, in this town of yours, and in this month of yours”, which is general and encompasses everybody including the State, and taking taxes is taking the wealth of the Muslim without his agreement, which indicates the impermissibility of taking it.
Agar Bayt al-Mol daromadi belgilangan manbalardan va belgilangan miqdorlardan olinganda rayyatning ishlarini boshqarishga yetmasa, chunki boshqarilishi kerak bo‘lgan masalalar bo‘lishi mumkin va Bayt al-Mol daromadi allaqachon sarflab bo‘lingan bo‘lsa, bunday holatda soliq solish joizmi yoki yo‘qmi? Bunga javob shuki, Shari‘at Bayt al-Molga yuklagan narsalar ichida faqat Bayt al-Molga yuklatilgan, musulmonlarga yuklatilmagan narsalar ham, Bayt al-Mol va musulmonlarga birgalikda yuklatilgan narsalar ham bor. Faqat Bayt al-Molga yuklatilgan, musulmonlarga yuklatilmagan narsalar uchun davlatning soliq solishi joiz emas. Shunday ekan, Bayt al-Molda mablag‘ topilsa, u ishlatiladi, agar hech narsa bo‘lmasa, uni amalga oshirish uchun yetarli mablag‘ topilguncha kechiktiriladi va bu uchun musulmonlarga hech qanday soliq solinmaydi. Chunki Shari‘at bu masalani musulmonlarga yuklamagan, shuning uchun uning uchun soliq solish joiz emas, chunki bunday holatda soliq olish zulm hisoblanadi, zulm esa haramdir. Xuddi shuningdek, bu Alloh (subhanahu va taolo) farz qilmagan narsani farz qilish bo‘lib hisoblanadi, bu esa ruxsat etilgan narsani man qilish yoki man etilgan narsaga ruxsat berish kabidir, bu Shari‘atga dushmanlikdir, uni e’tiqod qilgan kishi kofir hisoblanadi, e’tiqod qilmagan bo‘lsa, gunohkor bo‘ladi. Shunga ko‘ra, Qur’on va Sunnatda Shari‘at farz qilmagan soliqni musulmonlardan olish davlat uchun joiz emas. Bunga misollar: zakot yig‘uvchilarning maoshi, qalblari Islomga yaqinlashtirilishi lozim bo‘lgan kishilarga berish, qullarni ozod qilish uchun ularga berish va qarzdorlarning qarzini to‘lash uchun berishdir. Shunga o‘xshash ishlar: mavjud bo‘lgan boshqa yo‘l bor paytda yangi yo‘l qurish, yomg‘ir suvi bor paytda to‘g‘on qurish, yoki ehtiyojni qondiradigan boshqa kasalxona mavjud bo‘lganda yangi kasalxona tashkil etish, yoki bularga o‘xshash boshqa har qanday ish. Bunday hollarda uning yo‘qligi harom mavjud bo‘lishiga olib kelmaydi, balki uning mavjudligi yaxshilikka olib keladi va mavjud narsani to‘ldiradi. Davlatning bunday ishni amalga oshirish uchun musulmonlardan soliq solishi joiz emas, chunki Shariat buni majburiy qilmagan. Fuqaholar shunga o‘xshash masalalar haqida, ularning Bayt al-mol'dagi haqqi "mavjudlik, yo‘qlik emas" qoidasi bo‘yicha belgilanadi, deganlar: agar mol-mulk mavjud bo‘lsa, ular unga sarflanishga haqli bo‘ladilar, agar u yo‘q bo‘lsa, yo‘qlik ularning haqqini bekor qiladi.
However, if the income of the Bayt Al-Mal from the defined areas and fixed amounts were not sufficient to administer the affairs of the subjects, since it could occur that there are issues which require administering and the income of the Bayt Al-Mal had already been spent, then would it be permissible in this situation to impose taxes or not? The answer to that is that what the Shari’ah obligated upon the Bayt Al-Mal includes what was obligated upon it alone and not obligated upon the Muslims, and what was obligated upon both the Bayt Al-Mal and upon the Muslims. It is not permitted for the State to impose taxes for the sake of whatever was obligated upon the Bayt Al-Mal alone and not upon the Muslims, so if there is money found in the Bayt Al-Mal it is used and if there is nothing then it is delayed until they find enough to carry it out, and no taxes at all are imposed upon the Muslims for its sake. This is because the Shari’ah did not obligate that issue upon the Muslims, and so it is not permitted to impose taxes for it since taking taxes in this situation would be considered to be oppression which is forbidden (Haram). Likewise, it would also be considered as making obligatory something that Allah (swt) did not make obligatory, which is like forbidding something permitted, or permitting something forbidden, which is enmity against the Shari’ah and the one who does it is considered to be a disbeliever if he believed in it, and sinful if he did not, accordingly it is not permitted for the State to impose a tax upon the Muslims which the Shari’ah did not make obligatory from the Quran and the Sunnah. Examples of this would be for the sake of the salaries of those collecting the Zakah, and giving to people in order to bring them closer to Islam/those whose hearts are to be reconciled, and giving to slaves in order to purchase their freedom, and to those indebted in order to repay what they owe. And such as building a new road while there was another one present, or building a dam while there was rain water, or establishing a hospital while there was another one present which fulfilled the need, or anything else similar to these, where its absence does not lead to the existence of Haram, but rather its presence leads to betterment and is complementary to what exists. It is not permitted for the State to impose taxes upon the Muslims for anything like this in order to carry it out, since the Shari’ah did not obligate that. The jurists said regarding similar issues that their right upon the Bayt Al-Mal is considered according to: “presence not absence”, so if there was wealth present then they would deserve to have it spent upon them, and if it was absent then the absence voided their right.
Shariat bayt al-mol va musulmonlar zimmasiga yuklagan majburiyatlarga kelsak, agar bayt al-molda mol-mulk topilmasa yoki uning mol-mulki tugagan bo'lsa, bu holatda davlat shariat ularning ikkisi zimmasiga yuklagan ishlarni amalga oshirish uchun musulmonlarga soliq solishi mumkin.
As for what the Shari’ah obligated upon both the Bayt Al- Mal and the Muslims, then if there was no wealth to be found in the Bayt Al-Mal, or its wealth was finished, then in this situation the State could impose taxes upon the Muslims in order to carry out the affairs which the Shari’ah obligated upon both them and the Bayt Al-Mal.
Bu, Alloh (swt) bu narsani ularga farz qilganini va imomni ularning ustidan mas'ul qilganini matn tasdiqlagani uchundir. Shuning uchun u bu boylikni ulardan yig'adi va uni manfaatlarga sarflaydi, masalan, kambag'allar, muhtojlar va yo'lovchilarga zarur bo'lgan xarajatlarga. Zakot daromadi va boshqa manbalardan Bayt al-Mol'da ularga sarflash uchun yetarli mablag' bo'lmagan. Chunki kambag'allarni boqish musulmonlar zimmasidagi farzdir, chunonchi u aytgan:
This is because it is confirmed by text that Allah (swt) obligated that upon them, and made the Imam responsible over them, so he is the one who collects this wealth from them and spends it upon the interests, such as the necessary expenditure upon the poor, the needy and the wayfarers, and there was not enough in the Bayt Al-Mal from the income of Zakah and everything else to spend upon them. This is since feeding the poor is obligatory upon the Muslims, as he said:
. » وَأَ يََا أَهْلُ عَرْصَةٍ أَصْبَحَ فِيهِمْ امْرُؤٌ جَائِعٌ فَقَدْ بَرِئَتْ مِنْهُ مْ ذِمَّةُ اللَّهِ تَعَالَى « .
. » وَأَ يََا أَهْلُ عَرْصَةٍ أَصْبَحَ فِيهِمْ امْرُؤٌ جَائِعٌ فَقَدْ بَرِئَتْ مِنْهُ مْ ذِمَّةُ اللَّهِ تَعَالَى « .
“Qachonki bir hudud ahli och odam bilan tong otsa, Allohning (swt) ahdi va himoyasi ulardan olib tashlanadi”, (Ahmad Ibn Umardan rivoyat qilgan, al-Hokim esa uni sahih deb topgan). Shuningdek, agar Bayt al-Molda askarlarga va urushga qilinadigan zaruriy xarajatlar hamda harbiy tayyorgarlik uchun zarur bo‘lgan barcha narsalarga yetarli mablag‘ bo‘lmasa, unda Allohning (swt) quyidagi so‘zlariga binoan musulmonlarga soliq solinadi, shu yo‘l bilan bu ishlar amalga oshiriladi:
“Whenever the people of an area wake up with a hungry person amongst them, then Allah (swt)’s covenant and protection to them is absolved.” (reported by Ahmad from Ibn Umar and authenticated by Al-Hakim). Also, if there is not enough in the Bayt Al-Mal for the necessary expenditure upon the soldiers and war, and everything that is required for military preparedness, then a tax is imposed upon the Muslims in order for it to be carried out due to His (swt) words:
“Va Allohning yo‘lida mol-mulkingiz va joningiz bilan jihod qiling.” (TMQ 9:41) va “Allohning yo‘lida mol-mulki va joni bilan jihod qiluvchi mujohidlar [o‘tirib qolganlardan ustun].” (TMQ 4:95). Anas roviyligida xabar qilinadi: Allohning Elchisi ﷺ aytdilar:
“And strive with your wealth and your lives in the cause of Allah (swt).” (TMQ 9:41) and: “And the Mujahideen, [who strive and fight] in the cause of Allah (swt) with their wealth and their lives.” (TMQ 4:95), and it is reported from Anas who said: The Messenger of Allah (pbuh) said:
. » جَاهِدُوا الْمُشْرِكِيَ بِأَمْوَالِكُمْ وَأَيْدِيكُمْ وَأَلْسِنَتِكُمْ « .
. » جَاهِدُوا الْمُشْرِكِيَ بِأَمْوَالِكُمْ وَأَيْدِيكُمْ وَأَلْسِنَتِكُمْ « .
“Mushriklarga qarshi mol-mulkingiz, qo‘lingiz va tilingiz bilan jihod qiling.” (Ahmad va an-Nasoiy rivoyat qilgan; al-Hokim uni sahih deb hisoblagan, az-Zahabiy ham unga qo‘shilgan.) Xuddi shunday, agar uni amalga oshirmaslik musulmonlarga zarar keltiradigan har qanday ish, masalan, boshqa yo‘li bo‘lmagan joyda yo‘l ochish, zaruriy kasalxona ochish va boshqa shunga o‘xshash, foyda va xizmat nuqtai nazaridan xarajati, boshqa alternativasi bo‘lmagan holda, zarurat hisoblanadigan va uning yo‘qligi ummatga zarar yetkazadigan ishlar uchun musulmonlardan soliqlar undiriladi, chunki zararni bartaraf etish musulmonlarning zimmasidagi vojibdir. Nabiy ﷺ shunday degan:
“Strive against the idolators (Mushrikin) with your wealth, your hands and your tongues.” (reported by Ahmad and Al-Nisa’i and Al-Nisa’i and Al-Hakim authenticated it and Al- Dhahabi agreed). And in the same manner everything which if it were not undertaken would cause a harm to the Muslims, such as opening a route where there was no alternative, and opening a hospital whose opening was a necessity, and anything else similar whose expenditure would be deserved from the angle of interest and service without an alternative, and being a necessity from the necessities, and that the Ummah would be afflicted with a harm if it was not present, then taxes are imposed upon the Muslims in order to carry it out because the removal of harm is obligatory upon the Muslims; the Prophet said:
. » لا ضَرَرَ وَلا ضِرَارَ « .
. » لا ضَرَرَ وَلا ضِرَارَ « .
"Zarar ham, zarar bilan javob berish ham bo'lmasligi kerak" (Ahmad Ibn Abbosdan, Hakim esa Abu Said al-Xudriydan rivoyat qilgan; u uni sahih deb topgan, Zahabiy ham unga qo'shilgan). Shuningdek, qo'shin, sudyalar va o'qituvchilarga maosh to'lash ham shunday: bular Shariat musulmonlar zimmasiga yuklagan masalalardandir, chunki ularga ilm o'rganish farz qilingan, sud tashkil etish va jihod ham farz qilingan, bu aniq matnlar bilan dalillangan. Shuning uchun davlatga, Bayt al-Mol bilan birga, Shariat musulmonlar zimmasiga yuklagan bu ishlarni amalga oshirish uchun soliq joriy qilish ruxsat etiladi, chunki matnlar ularning musulmonlar zimmasidagi majburiyatini aniq bayon etadi. Bu maqolaning birinchi masalasining dalilidir.
“There should be neither harming nor reciprocating harm” (reported by Ahmad from Ibn ‘Abbas, and Al-Hakim from Abu Sa’id Al-Khudri, and he authenticated it and Al-Dhahabi agreed). Likewise paying salaries for the army, judges and teachers, since these are from the issues that the Shari’ah obligated upon the Muslims, since learning has been made obligatory upon them, and so has establishing the courts and Jihad, as has been indicated by explicit texts. Therefore, the State is permitted to impose taxes in order to carry out these issues which the Shari’ah obligated upon the Muslims alongside the Bayt Al-Mal, since the texts are explicit in their obligation upon the Muslims. This is the evidence for the first issue of the article.
Ikkinchi masalaning dalili Rasululloh ﷺ ning so'zlaridir:
As for the second issue, its evidence is the words of the Messenger (pbuh) :
. » أفضلُ الصَّدَقَةِ مَا كَانَ عَنْ ظَهْرِ غِنًً « .
. » أفضلُ الصَّدَقَةِ مَا كَانَ عَنْ ظَهْرِ غِنًً « .
“eng yaxshi sadaqa – ortiqcha bo‘lganidan berilgan sadaqadir” (Hakim ibn Hizom va Abu Hurayra rivoyatida, muttafaqun alayh). Al-G‘ino esa – inson o‘z ehtiyojlarini qondirish uchun zarur bo‘lgan narsani olgandan keyin qolgan, ortig‘i bilan kifoyalanishidir. Jobirdan rivoyat qilinadi: Allohning Elchisi ﷺ shunday degan: «Eng afzal sadaqa – boy bo‘lganidan keyin berilgan sadaqadir. Yuqoridagi qo‘l pastdagi qo‘ldan yaxshidir. Avval o‘zing boqishga majbur bo‘lganlardan boshla».
“and the best Sadaqah is that which given out of surplus.” (agreed upon from Hakim Bin Hizam and Abu Hurayrah), and Al-Ghina is what the person did without, after taking what was necessary to fulfil his needs. It is reported from Jabir that the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) said: . أَفْضَلُ الصَّدَقَةِ مَا كَانَ عَنْ ظَهْرِ غِنًً، وَالْيَدُ الْعُلْيَا خَيْرٌ مِنْ الْيَدِ ال سفْلَى، وَابْدَأْ بِِنَْ « » تَعُولُ .
“Eng afzal sadaqa — ortiqchasidan berilgan sadaqadir; yuqori qo‘l quyi qo‘ldan yaxshiroqdir va sadaqani o‘z oila a’zolaridan boshlang” (muttafaqun alayh). Muslim rivoyat qilgan boshqa bir rivoyatda Jobirdan:
“The best of Sadaqah is that which given out of surplus; and the upper hand is better than the lower hand, and begin with the members of your household” (agreed upon). And in another narration in Muslim from Jabir:
.» ابْدَأْ بِنَفْسِكَ فَتَصَدَّقْ عَلَيْهَا فَإِنْ فَضَلَ شَيْءٌ فَلأَهْلِكَ «.
.» ابْدَأْ بِنَفْسِكَ فَتَصَدَّقْ عَلَيْهَا فَإِنْ فَضَلَ شَيْءٌ فَلأَهْلِكَ «.
“Avval o‘zingizga sadaqa qiling, agar ortiqcha bo‘lsa, oilangiz uchun”. Shunday qilib, u nafaqasi vojib bo‘lgan kishini ta’minlashni o‘zini ta’minlashdan keyingi o‘ringa qo‘ydi va zakot ham shunga o‘xshaydi, chunki u nafaqa va sadaqaga o‘xshaydi. Alloh (SWT) esa aytdi:
“Start by giving Sadaqah to yourself, and if anything is surplus, then for your family”. So he made providing for the person whom it is obligatory to support secondary to providing for oneself, and the tax is similar to that because it is like support and Sadaqah. And Allah (swt) said:
“Ular sizdan nimani infoq qilishni so‘raydilar. Ayting: ortiqcha narsani”. (TMQ 2:219) Ya’ni, sarflash qiyin bo‘lmagan narsani, bu esa ortiqcha narsani anglatadi. Bu shuni ko‘rsatadiki, musulmonga mol-mulki borasida majburiy bo‘lgan narsa – u zakot bo‘lsin, yoki nafaqa bo‘lsin – faqat me’yorlarga ko‘ra uning ehtiyojidan ortib qolgan narsadan olinadi. Soliq ham shunga o‘xshaydi, shuning uchun musulmondan faqat unda ortiqcha bo‘lgan va o‘xshash shaxsning ehtiyojlarini qondirish uchun kerak bo‘ladigan narsadan oshgan qismidan olinadi, ya’ni o‘zi, xotinlari uchun ovqat, kiyim, boshpana va yordam berish uchun kerak bo‘lgan narsalardan ortiqcha, hamda o‘z ehtiyojlarini qondirish va o‘z holatidagi kishi uchun shunga o‘xshash narsalarga sarflaydigan mablag‘dan ortiqcha. Chunki bu Payg‘ambar ﷺning “ortiqchadan berilgan” degan so‘zlarining ma’nosidir.
“And they ask you as to what they should spend. Say: what you can spare.” (TMQ 2:219), in other words, that which would not be difficult to spend, which would mean that which is extra. This indicates that what is obligatory upon the Muslim as far as their wealth is concerned, irrespective of whether that was Zakah or maintenance, is only taken from whatever he has that is extra over what he needs according to the norms. Similar to that is the tax, so it is not taken from the Muslim except from that which is extra and above what someone like him would require to fulfil their needs, or in other words, what is extra to what he needs to feed, cloth, shelter and provide help for himself and his wives, and what he spends to fulfil his needs and whatever is similar for someone in his position, because this is the meaning of the Messenger (pbuh)’s words: “what is given out of surplus”.
Uchinchi masalaning dalili shuki, Shariat majburiy bo'lmagan narsani olishni man etgan, ehtiyojdan ortiqcha bo'lgan narsa esa musulmonga majburiy emas, shuning uchun uni olish harom qilingan. Shu sababli Bayt al-Mol uchun olinadigan miqdor faqat zarur bo'lgan miqdor bo'lib, undan ortig'i olinmaydi. 'Ali (r.a.) Umar ibn al-Xattob (r.a.)ga, Bayt al-Molda hech narsa qolmasligi kerakligini taklif qilib, unga shunday degan: "Har yili olgan molingizni taqsimlang va undan hech narsani o'zingizda saqlamang" (Ibn Sa'd Al-Voqidiydan rivoyat qilgan). Shuningdek, rivoyat qilinadiki, "Ali Bayt al-Moldagi barcha narsani sarflar edi, hatto uni supurib, so'ng u yerga o'tirar edi" (Ibn Abd al-Barr "Al-Istidkor" kitobida Anas ibn Sirindan rivoyat qilgan). Xalifalar daromadning soliqdan boshqa turlariga nisbatan shunday qilar edilar. Unda soliq daromadiga nisbatan ular qanday yondashgan bo'lar edilar? Yanada kuchli mulohaza bilan aytganda, Bayt al-Molda hech narsa qolmasligi kerak, shuning uchun zarur bo'lganidan ortiq hech narsa olinmaydi.
As for the third issue, its evidence is the forbiddance of the Shari’ah from taking what is not obligatory, and whatever is additional to the needs is not obligatory upon the Muslim, and so it is forbidden to take it, and for this reason the amount taken is what is required for the Bayt Al-Mal and nothing more. ‘Ali (ra) suggested to Umar Bin Al-Khattab (ra) that there should be nothing remaining in the Bayt Al-Mal saying to him: “Divide whatever wealth you receive every year, and do not hold onto anything from it” (reported by Ibn Sa’d from Al-Waqidi), and it is reported: “that Ali used to spend everything in Bayt Al-Mal to the point that he would sweep it and then sits it in” (reported by Ibn ‘Abd alBarr in Al-Istidhkar from Anas b. Sirin). The Khulafaa’ used to do this with respect to the income other than taxes, so how would they have treated the income from taxes? By greater reasoning there should remain nothing in the Bayt Al-Mal, and so nothing more than what is necessary is taken.
Bu maqolaning uchta masalasi uchun dalillar.
This is the evidence for the three issues of this article.