Lakini ikiwa mapato ya Bayt Al-Mal kutoka maeneo yaliyoainishwa na kiasi kilichowekwa hayatoshi kuendesha mambo ya raia, kwa kuwa inaweza kutokea kuna masuala yanayohitaji kusimamiwa na mapato ya Bayt Al-Mal yakawa tayari yametumika, basi je, katika hali hii inaruhusiwa kuweka kodi au la? Jibu ni kwamba yale ambayo Shari'ah imeiwajibisha Bayt Al-Mal yanajumuisha yale yaliyowajibishwa juu yake peke yake na si juu ya Waislamu, na yale yaliyowajibishwa juu ya Bayt Al-Mal na juu ya Waislamu wote. Haifai kwa Dola kuweka kodi kwa ajili ya yale yaliyowajibishwa juu ya Bayt Al-Mal peke yake na si juu ya Waislamu. Kwa hiyo, ikiwa kuna fedha zilizopatikana katika Bayt Al-Mal, hutumiwa, na ikiwa hakuna chochote, basi hucheleweshwa hadi watakapopata kiasi cha kutosha cha kutekeleza jambo hilo, na hakuna kodi yoyote inayowekwa juu ya Waislamu kwa ajili yake. Hii ni kwa sababu Shari'ah haikuwawajibisha Waislamu katika jambo hilo, na hivyo haifai kuweka kodi kwa ajili yake kwa kuwa kuchukua kodi katika hali hii kungezingatiwa kuwa dhulma ambayo ni haramu. Vilevile, hilo pia lingezingatiwa kama kufanya wajibu kitu ambacho Allah (swt) hakukifanya wajibu, ambacho ni kama kukataza jambo lililoruhusiwa, au kuruhusu jambo lililokatazwa, jambo ambalo ni uadui dhidi ya Shari'ah, na mtu anayelifanya anachukuliwa kuwa kafiri ikiwa aliliamini, na mwenye dhambi ikiwa hakuliamini. Kwa hiyo, haifai kwa Dola kuweka kodi juu ya Waislamu ambayo Shari'ah haikuifanya wajibu kutoka katika Qur'ani na Sunnah. Mifano ya hili ni kwa ajili ya mishahara ya wale wanaokusanya Zakah, na kuwapa watu ili kuwasogeza karibu na Uislamu/wale ambao nyoyo zao zinapaswa kutulizwa, na kuwapa watumwa ili kununua uhuru wao, na kwa wale waliokopa ili kulipa deni walilonalo. Na kama vile kujenga barabara mpya wakati kulikuwa na nyingine tayari, au kujenga bwawa wakati kulikuwa na maji ya mvua, au kuanzisha hospitali wakati kulikuwa na nyingine iliyokidhi haja, au chochote kingine cha namna hii, ambacho kutokuwepo kwake hakupelekei kuwepo kwa haramu, bali uwepo wake unapelekea maboresho na kukamilisha yaliyopo. Haijuzu kwa Dola kuwawekea Waislamu kodi kwa jambo kama hili ili kulitekeleza, kwa kuwa Shari'ah haikulilazimisha hilo. Wanazuoni wamesema kuhusu masuala kama haya kwamba haki yao katika Bayt al-Mal inazingatiwa kwa kanuni ya: "uwepo si kutokuwepo". Kwa hiyo, ikiwa kuna mali iliyopo, basi watastahiki kutumiwa kwao, na ikiwa haipo, basi kutokuwepo kwake kunaibatilisha haki yao.
However, if the income of the Bayt Al-Mal from the defined areas and fixed amounts were not sufficient to administer the affairs of the subjects, since it could occur that there are issues which require administering and the income of the Bayt Al-Mal had already been spent, then would it be permissible in this situation to impose taxes or not? The answer to that is that what the Shari’ah obligated upon the Bayt Al-Mal includes what was obligated upon it alone and not obligated upon the Muslims, and what was obligated upon both the Bayt Al-Mal and upon the Muslims. It is not permitted for the State to impose taxes for the sake of whatever was obligated upon the Bayt Al-Mal alone and not upon the Muslims, so if there is money found in the Bayt Al-Mal it is used and if there is nothing then it is delayed until they find enough to carry it out, and no taxes at all are imposed upon the Muslims for its sake. This is because the Shari’ah did not obligate that issue upon the Muslims, and so it is not permitted to impose taxes for it since taking taxes in this situation would be considered to be oppression which is forbidden (Haram). Likewise, it would also be considered as making obligatory something that Allah (swt) did not make obligatory, which is like forbidding something permitted, or permitting something forbidden, which is enmity against the Shari’ah and the one who does it is considered to be a disbeliever if he believed in it, and sinful if he did not, accordingly it is not permitted for the State to impose a tax upon the Muslims which the Shari’ah did not make obligatory from the Quran and the Sunnah. Examples of this would be for the sake of the salaries of those collecting the Zakah, and giving to people in order to bring them closer to Islam/those whose hearts are to be reconciled, and giving to slaves in order to purchase their freedom, and to those indebted in order to repay what they owe. And such as building a new road while there was another one present, or building a dam while there was rain water, or establishing a hospital while there was another one present which fulfilled the need, or anything else similar to these, where its absence does not lead to the existence of Haram, but rather its presence leads to betterment and is complementary to what exists. It is not permitted for the State to impose taxes upon the Muslims for anything like this in order to carry it out, since the Shari’ah did not obligate that. The jurists said regarding similar issues that their right upon the Bayt Al-Mal is considered according to: “presence not absence”, so if there was wealth present then they would deserve to have it spent upon them, and if it was absent then the absence voided their right.