"Alikuwa amelima ardhi. Mtume (rehema na amani zimshukie) alipita karibu naye alipokuwa akiinywesha. Basi akamuuliza: Zao ni la nani, na ardhi ni ya nani? Akajibu: Zao ni langu kwa mbegu yangu na kazi yangu. Nusu (ya zao) ni yangu, na nusu nyingine ni ya fulani. Akasema: Umefanya muamala wa riba. Rudisha ardhi kwa mwenyewe na chukua ujira wako na gharama zako." Mtume ﷺ ameeleza muamala huu kuwa ni riba, na riba ni haramu kwa maandiko yaliyo wazi. Zaidi ya hayo, Mtume ﷺ alimwomba Rafi' arudishe ardhi kwa mwenyewe, pamoja na chochote kilichokuwepo cha kilimo, na achukue gharama zake kutoka kwake; kwa maneno mengine, alimwomba abatilishe muamala huo. Hii inaonyesha kwamba katazo ni la uhakika, hivyo ni haramu. Kwa hiyo, hadithi hizi tatu - hadithi ya Jabir inayotaja tishio kwa anayeshiriki katika Mukhabarah, yaani kugawana mazao ya shamba, hadithi ya Al-Nasa'i yenye marudio na vizuizi, na hadithi ya Raafi' inayoeleza kukodisha ardhi kuwa ni riba na kubatilisha muamala - ni dalili thabiti kwamba katazo hilo ni la uhakika, jambo linaloonyesha uharamu wa kukodisha ardhi kwa ujumla. Kwa sababu ya yale yaliyotajwa waziwazi katika hadithi hizi, na yanayofahamika kutoka kwake, hakuna shaka hata kidogo kwamba ni haramu kukodisha ardhi kwa ujumla. Hata hivyo, baadhi ya wanazuoni wameonekana wakiruhusu kukodisha ardhi. Kwa hiyo tutaeleza pia dalili ambazo baadhi ya wanazuoni walizitumia kuruhusu kukodisha ardhi, si kwa lengo la kuzikosoa tu, bali ili kuonyesha ubatili wake. Wale wanaoruhusu kukodisha ardhi wanasema kwamba ardhi ni kitu ambacho manufaa yanaweza kupatikana kutoka kwake wakati inabaki hali yake, hivyo inaruhusiwa kuikodisha kwa bei au kitu kama hicho, kama kwa mzunguko wa mazao, na hukumu ya bidhaa ni sawa na hukumu ya bei. Ubatili wa maoni haya uko wazi sana, kwa kuwa ingawa ardhi ni kitu ambacho manufaa yake yanaweza kupatikana huku ardhi ikibaki yenyewe, kama kwa kupokezana mazao, bado maandiko yamekuja kubainisha waziwazi kwamba kukodisha ardhi ni Haramu. Hivyo, hata kama ufafanuzi wa kukodisha unaihusu, maandiko yamekuja na kuyakataza, na kwa sababu hiyo ni Haramu. Ushahidi wa kukodisha ni wa jumla unaojumuisha kila aina ya kukodisha, lakini kuna ushahidi ulioja kukataza kukodisha ardhi, ambao unalazimisha kikomo cha kukodisha kwa kitu kingine chochote isipokuwa ardhi. Hivyo kukodisha ardhi kumetolewa kama ubaguzi na kukatazwa. Ndiyo sababu ni Haramu. Sawa na haya ni kauli ya Allah (SWT):
“He had cultivated a land. The Prophet (peace be upon him) passed him when he was watering it. So he asked him: To whom does the crop belong, and to whom does the land belong? He replied: The crop is mine for my seed and labour. The half (of the crop) is mine and the half for so-and-so. He said: You conducted usurious transaction. Return the land to its owner and take your wages and cost.”. The Prophet described this transaction as being usury, and usury is Haram according to definite text. Additionally, the Messenger (pbuh) requested Rafi’ to return the land to its owner, with whatever was there in terms of agriculture, and to take his expenses from them; in other words, he requested him to void the transaction. This indicates that the prohibition is a decisive one and so it is Haram. Therefore, these three narrations - the narration of Jabir which mentions the threat for partaking in Mukhabarah, in other words, share-cropping, and the narration of Al-Nasa’i with the repetition and restriction, and the narration of Raafi’ which describes the renting of land as being usury and voiding the transaction - are a definite indication that the prohibition is decisive, which indicates the Tahrim of renting land generally. Due to what is mentioned explicitly in these narrations, and what is understood from them, there is not the slightest doubt that it is forbidden to rent land generally. Yet some of the scholars are found to have permitted the renting of land. So we will also explain the evidences that some of the scholars used to permit the renting of land, not simply to criticise those evidences but in order to show their invalidity. Those who permit the renting of land say that the land is an object that benefit can be derived from while it remains, and so it is permitted to rent it for a price or something similar, such as for a crop rotation, and the rule regarding goods is the same as the rule regarding prices. The invalidity of this opinion is extremely apparent, since even though land is an object which benefits could be taken from while the land remains such as through crop rotation, but the text came to explicitly state that renting land is Haram, so even if the definition of renting applies to it, the text came and forbade it, and for that reason it is Haram. So though the evidence for renting is general and encompasses any type of renting, however there is an evidence which came forbidding the renting of land which restricts it to renting anything other than land, and so the renting of land was made as an exception and it was forbidden. That is why it is Haram. Similar to this are the words of Allah (swt):