Na farko, nassin da ake ba da labari a kan wani takamaiman batu yana kama da nassin da yake amsa tambaya. Saboda haka wajibi ne a takaita shi ga batun tambayar ko lamarin, kuma ba daidai ba ne a mayar da shi gama-gari a dukkan al'amura, domin tambayar tana bayyana a cikin amsar, kuma saboda kalmomin suna cikin wani takamaiman batu, wajibi ne a takaita su ga wannan batu, tun da maganar Manzon Allah ﷺ tana da alaka da tambayar ko lamarin, don haka hukuncin yana da alaka da hakan. Wannan ya bambanta da idan Manzon Allah ﷺ ya faɗi hakan tun farko (ba don amsa wani lamari ba), a lokacin ne zai zama gama-gari yana da alaka da gaba ɗaya.
Amma idan maganarsa sharhi ce a kan wani takamaiman lamari, ko amsa ga wata takamaiman tambaya, to al'amarin ya bambanta. Idan nassi, wato maganar Allah (SWT) ko maganar Manzon Allah ﷺ, yana da alaka tabbatacciya da tambaya ko lamari, to hukuncin yana da alaka da hakan ba tare da wata shakka ba. Wannan yana dangane da batun da ya samo asali daga tambaya ko lamari. Kuma ba yana nufin mai tambayar ko wanda lamarin ya shafa ba ne, domin a cikin dukkan biyun ana duba gama-garin kalmomin ne ba takamaiman sanadin ba. Saboda haka akwai bambanci tsakanin sanadi da batu: ana duba gama-garin kalmomi ba takamaiman sanadin ba, domin kalmomin ba su da alaka da sanadin, don haka suna nan a kan gama-garinsu. Wannan ya bambanta da lamarin ko tambayar, wato batun da lamarin ya haɗa, ko batun da tambayar ta haɗa, domin kalmomin suna da alaka tabbatacciya da shi, babu shakka a cikin haka, tun da an bada labarin ne saboda shi ko kuma sakamakon shi, saboda haka yana takaita ga batun, ba gama-gari ba.
Saboda haka, wannan shi ne bayanin labarin.
Firstly, the text which is related in a specific subject is like the text which is an answer to a question, and so it is necessary to make it specific to the issue of the question or event, and it is not correct for it to be general in all issues, because the question is reflected in the answer, and because the words are in a specific subject it is necessary to limit them to that subject, since the word of the Messenger (pbuh) is connected to the question or event, and so the rule is connected to that. This is different than if the Messenger (pbuh) had said that initially (not in response to an event) in which case it would be general and connected to the generality. As for if his word is a comment upon a specific event, or an answer to a specific question, then the situation is different. If the text, in other words, the words of Allah (swt) or the words of the Messenger (pbuh) , were definitely connected to a question or event, then the rule is connected to that without any doubt. This is with respect to the subject that either came from a question or event. And it is not with respect to the questioner or whom the event occurred upon, since the consideration in both of them is given to the generality of the words and not to the specific cause. And this is why there is a difference made between the cause and the subject, so the consideration is to the generality of the words and not to the specific cause, since the words are not connected to the cause, and so they remain upon their generality. This is different to the event or question, in other words, different to the subject which was included by the event, or the subject which was included by the question, since the words are definitely connected to it, and there is no doubt in that, since the narration was only for its sake, or due to it, and due to this it is specific to the subject, and not general. Accordingly the narration.