Wani mutum daga cikin Ahl Al-Suffah ya rasu, aka samu Dinari a cikin tufafinsa (zanen dake kugu); Manzon Allah ﷺ ya ce: "Za a kone shi", sai wani kuma ya rasu, aka samu Dinari biyu a jikinsa, Manzon Allah ﷺ ya ce: "Za a kone shi sau biyu", kuma wannan yana nufin an haramta tarawar zinari da azurfa gaba daya, ko da kuwa Dinari biyu ne ko ma daya kacal, muddin ana tarawa, wato ajiye dukiya ba tare da bukatar a kashe ta ba. Manzon Allah ﷺ ya fadi haka game da mutanen nan biyu saboda sun kasance daga cikin wadanda ke rayuwa da sadaka, duk da haka suna dauke da zinari, don haka ya ce: "Za a kone shi" da "Za a kone shi sau biyu", yana ishara zuwa ga fadin Allah (SWT): "Ranar da za a rura shi a cikin wutar Jahannama, sai a yi kaba da shi goshinsu, da gefen jikinsu, da bayansu." (TMQ 9:35), wanda yana cikin ayoyin tarawa; wato yana ishara zuwa ayoyin da suka shafi tarawa. Wannan hujja ce ta haramcin tarawa gaba daya, cikakke, ba tare da la'akari da ko ta kai adadin da ake biyan Zakka a kansa ba ko a'a, kuma ba tare da la'akari da ko an biya Zakka a kansa ba ko a'a; don haka duk wani tara dukiya haramun ne. Na uku: Haɗin kalma (wa) a fadin Allah (SWT): "Kada su kashe shi a hanyar Allah (SWT)." (TMQ 9:34) yana bambanta da fadin Allah (SWT): "Wadanda ke tara zinari da azurfa." (TMQ 9:34), don haka yana nuna cewa ayar ta kunshi dokoki biyu: na farko shi ne tara dukiya, na biyu kuwa rashin kashe ta a hanyar Allah (SWT). Ma'anar ayar tana nuna gargadin azaba mai tsanani da ke da alaka da wadannan abubuwa biyu, wato: ga wadanda ke tara zinari da azurfa kuma ba sa kashe su a hanyar Allah (SWT), to ka basu labarin azaba mai tsanani. Saboda haka, a bayyane yake cewa wanda ba ya tara dukiya, amma ba ya kashewa a hanyar Allah (SWT), yana cikin barazanar, haka kuma wanda yake kashewa a hanyar Allah (SWT) amma yana tara dukiya shi ma yana cikin barazanar. Al-Qurtubi ya ce: "Duk wanda ba ya tara dukiya, amma ya hana kashewa a hanyar Allah (SWT), dole ne ya zama daidai da shi". Abin da ake nufi da kalmomin: "a hanyar Allah (SWT)" a cikin ayar shi ne Jihadi, tun da an ambace shi tare da kashewa. Idan aka haɗa kalmomin: "a hanyar Allah (SWT)" da kashewa, to ma'anarsu ita ce Jihadi, sai dai idan an sami alama da ta kawar da su daga wannan ma'ana. Saboda haka, kalmomin: "kuma ba sa kashe shi" ba su dace su zama hujja ba cewa idan sun tara dukiya sai su kashe daga cikinta a hanyar Allah (SWT) ba sa cikin azaba, domin ma'anar ayar ba ita ce: "duk wanda ya tara dukiya ta hanyar ba ya kashe ta a hanyar Allah (SWT), to ka yi musu bushara da azaba mai tsanani" ba, inda haɗin kalmar ke bayani, don haka idan an kashe dukiyar da aka tara a hanyar Allah (SWT), mai tarawar ba zai sha azaba ba. A'a, ma'anar ayar ita ce: duk wanda ya tara, to ka yi musu bushara da azaba, kuma duk wanda ba ya kashewa a hanyar Allah (SWT), to ka yi musu bushara da azaba. Haɗin kalmar haɗin bambanci ne, ba na bayani ba. Saboda haka, haramcin tara dukiya ba shi da iyaka, ko an kashe wani ɓangare a hanyar Allah (SWT) ko ba a kashe ba, kuma batun haramcin tara dukiya wani batu ne daban da batun haramcin rashin kashewa a hanyar Allah (SWT). Don haka, a bayyane yake cewa ayar ta haramta tara dukiya ko da an biya zakka a kanta, kuma ko da an kashe wani ɓangare a hanyar Allah (SWT).
“A man from the Ahl Al-Suffah died, and a Dinar was found in his garments (waist-wrap); the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) said: “he will be burnt”, then another died and two Dinars were found on him, and the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) said: “he will be burnt twice””, and this means that it is completely forbidden to hoard gold and silver, even if it was only two or even just one Dinar, as long as it is being hoarded, in other words, the storage of wealth without a need that it would be spent on. And the Messenger (saw) said that in respect to these two men because they were from those who used to live on charity and yet they had gold on them, and so he said: “he will be burnt” and: “he will be burnt twice”, alluding to His (swt) words: “The Day when it will be heated in the fire of Hell and seared therewith will be their foreheads, their flanks, and their backs.” (TMQ 9:35), which is part of the verses of hoarding; in other words, he was alluding to the verses regarding hoarding. This is an evidence for the complete, comprehensive forbiddance of hoarding irrespective of whether it amounted to the value which Zakah should be paid upon or not, and irrespective of whether Zakah was paid upon it or not; so any hoarding is prohibited. Third: The conjunction in His (swt) words: “And spend it not in the way of Allah (swt).” (TMQ 9:34) contrasts with His (swt) words: “And those who hoard gold and silver.” (TMQ 9:34) and thus indicating accordingly that the verse covers two rules: the first being the hoarding of wealth and the second the lack of spending in the path of Allah (swt). The text of the verse indicates the threat of a severe punishment connected to these two issues - in other words, for those who hoard gold and silver and those who do not spend them in the path of Allah (swt), then announce to them a severe punishment. Therefore, it becomes clear that he who does not hoard, but does not spend in the path of Allah (swt), is encompassed by the threat, and likewise the one who spends in the path of Allah (swt) and yet he hoards wealth is also encompassed by the threat. Al-Qurtubi said: “Whoever does not hoard, and withholds spending in the path of Allah (swt), must also be the same”. The intention of the words: “in the way of Allah (swt)” in the verse is Jihad, since it is mentioned alongside spending. When the words: “in the way of Allah (swt)” are connected to spending, then their meaning is Jihad, unless there is an indication found which takes it away from that meaning. Accordingly, the words: “and spend it not” are not suitable as an evidence that if they hoard wealth and spend from it in the path of Allah (swt) they are not included in the punishment, since the meaning of the verse is not, and whoever hoards wealth in that they do not spend it in the path of Allah (swt) then announce to them a severe punishment, with the conjunction being explanatory and so, therefore, if the hoarded wealth was spent in the path of Allah (swt), the hoarder would not be punished. Rather, the meaning of the verse is that whoever hoards then announce to them a punishment and whoever does not spend in the path of Allah (swt) then announce to them a punishment. The conjunction is a conjunction of dissimilarity and not explanatory. Therefore, the forbiddance of hoarding is unrestricted, irrespective of whether some of it was spent in the path of Allah (swt) or not, and the issue of the forbiddance of hoarding is a different issue than the forbiddance of not spending in the path of Allah (swt). Accordingly, it is clearly seen that the verse forbids hoarding wealth even if Zakah had been paid upon it and even if some had been spent in the path of Allah (swt).