Mataki na 136
Article 136
Duk wanda ya mallaki fili yana da wajibi ya yi amfani da shi, kuma duk wanda ke buƙatar taimakon kuɗi ana ba shi kuɗi daga Baitul Mali domin ya samu damar yin amfani da filinsa. Duk wanda ya yi watsi da amfani da filin tsawon shekara uku a jere, ana karɓe shi daga hannunsa a ba wani.
Everyone that owns land is compelled to use it, and those that require financial help are given money from the Bayt Al-Mal to enable them to utilise their land. If anyone neglects utilising the land for three years continuously, it is taken from them and given to someone else.
Hujjar da ake amfani da ita ita ce abin da Abu Yusuf ya ruwaito a cikin Al-Kharaj daga Salim b. ‘Abd Allah (swt), cewa Umar b. Al-Khattab (ra) ya ce daga kan mimbari: “duk wanda ya raya wata ƙasa matacciya, to tana tasa ce, kuma wanda ya shinge ta ba shi da wani haƙƙi a cikinta bayan shekara uku (idan ba a noma ta ba).” Umar (ra) ya faɗi haka a gaban sahabbai da cikakken jin su, babu ɗaya daga cikinsu da ya yi masa tsawa, saboda haka wannan ijma’i ne. Wannan hujja ce bayyananniya cewa idan mutum ya raya wata ƙasa matacciya, ko ya sanya duwatsu ko wani abu da ke nuna mallakarsa a kanta, to ya mallake ta. Sai dai idan bai amfana da ƙasar ba tsawon shekaru uku a jere, to ana kwace ta daga hannunsa. Wanda ya raya ta da wanda ya shinge ta suna daidai ta fuskar mallaka, da ta fuskar kwace ta daga hannunsu. Ba za a ce maganar mallaka an takaita ta ga mai rayarwa ba: “duk wanda ya raya”, kuma maganar kwace ta idan an yi sakaci an takaita ta ga wanda ya shinge ta, banda mai rayarwa: “wanda ya shinge ta ba shi da…”, bisa fahimtar cewa mallaka ta mai rayarwa ce, kwace kuma idan an yi sakaci ga wanda ya shinge ta kawai. Wannan saboda maganar an yi ta ne bisa salon ɓoye sashi a cikin magana (Hadhf), don haka wanda ya shinge ta ma yana cikin mallaka, mai rayarwa kuma yana cikin hukuncin kwacewa: kamar dai Umar (ra) ya ce: “duk wanda ya raya wata ƙasa matacciya to tasa ce, kuma ba shi da haƙƙi a kanta bayan shekara uku, kuma duk wanda ya shinge wata ƙasa matacciya to tasa ce kuma ba shi da haƙƙi a kanta bayan shekara uku”.
The evidence is what Abu Yusuf reported in Al-Kharaj from Salim b. ‘Abd Allah (swt) that Umar b. Al-Khattab (ra) said from the pulpit: “whoever revives a dead land, it belongs to him, and the one who fenced it off has no right in it after three years (if not cultivated).” Umar (ra) said this in the sight and full hearing of the companions, and none of them rebuked him and so it is a consensus. This is explicit evidence that if someone revives a dead land, or places stones or anything which shows his possession of it upon it, then he takes possession of it. However, if he does not utilise the land for a period of three consecutive years then it is taken from him. The one who revived it and the one who fenced it off are the same from the angle of ownership, and from the angle of it being taken away from them. It cannot be said that the issue of ownership is restricted to the one who revives: “whoever revives”, and that the issue of dispossessing it is restricted to the one who fenced it of: “and the one who fenced it off has no…”, with the understanding that ownership is for the reviver, and taking the land away if it was neglected is restricted to the one who fenced if off and excludes the reviver. This is because the wording is from the metaphorical style of deletion (Hadthf), and so the one who fenced also falls under ownership, and the reviver under the ruling of dispossession: as if Umar (ra) said: “whoever revived a dead land then it is for him, and he has no right to it after three years, and whoever fenced a dead land then it is for him and he has no right to it after three years”.
Duk da cewa kalmomin Umar (ra) sun ambaci ƙasar matattu da ake mallakawa ta hanyar rayar da ita ko shinge, wato ta hanyar sanya hannu a kanta, kuma cewa idan mutum ya bar ta shekara uku to a karɓe ta daga hannunsa, akwai wasu rahotanni da ke magana kan ƙasar da ba a rayar da ita ba kuma ba a yi mata shinge ba, kuma ba matattu ba ce, sai dai wani ɓangare ne na ƙasar noma da aka ba mutane. An ruwaito daga Yahya b. Adam ta hanyar isnadin ‘Amru b. Shu’ayb, wanda ya ce:
Though Umar’s (ra) words mentioned dead land that is taken into an individual’s possession through reviving it or fencing it off, in other words, by placing his hand upon it, and that if he neglects it for three years then it is taken from his possession, there are other texts which are reported about land which is not revived and fenced, and not dead, rather as part of a cultivated land that was granted to people. It is reported from Yahya b. Adam through the chain of ‘Amru b. Shu’ayb who said:
. نَاساً مِنْ مُزْينََةِ أَوْ جُهَيْنَةِ أَرْضاً فَعَطَّلُوهَا، فَجَاءَ قَوْمٌ أَقْطَعَ رَسُولُ اللهِ « فَأَحْيَوْهَا، فَقَالَ عُمَرُ: لَوْ كَانَتْ قَطِيعَةً مِنِِّ أَوْ مِنْ أَبِِ بَكْرٍ لَرَدَدْتهَُا، وَلَكِنْ مِنْ رَسُولِ الله » .
. نَاساً مِنْ مُزْينََةِ أَوْ جُهَيْنَةِ أَرْضاً فَعَطَّلُوهَا، فَجَاءَ قَوْمٌ أَقْطَعَ رَسُولُ اللهِ « فَأَحْيَوْهَا، فَقَالَ عُمَرُ: لَوْ كَانَتْ قَطِيعَةً مِنِِّ أَوْ مِنْ أَبِِ بَكْرٍ لَرَدَدْتهَُا، وَلَكِنْ مِنْ رَسُولِ الله » .
Annabi ﷺ ya bai wa wasu mutane daga Muzaynah ko Juhaynah filin noma a matsayin iqta'i, amma suka yi sakaci da shi. Sai wasu mutane suka zo suka noma shi. Umar ya ce: Idan da ni ko Abu Bakr ne muka ba da filin, da na karbe shi daga hannunsu. Amma Manzon Allah ﷺ ne ya ba da shi.
“The Prophet assigned land to some people from Muzaynah or Juhaynah as a fief, and they neglected it. Other people came and cultivated it. Umar said: If the land was granted by me or by Abu Bakr, I would have taken it back from them. But it was granted by the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) ”.
Abin da ake nufi shi ne an shafe fiye da shekara uku, ko a wata ma'ana, idan da an bayar da shi tun zamanin Abu Bakr (ra), da shekara uku ba su cika ba tukuna, haka kuma idan da an bayar da shi a zamanin Umar (ra), to da Umar (ra) zai mayar da shi ga wanda aka bayar da shi gare shi. Sai dai Manzon Allah ﷺ ne ya bayar da shi, don haka shekara uku sun wuce, saboda haka ba zai yiwu a mayar da shi ba. Maimakon haka, Umar (ra) ya tabbatar da mallakar wannan fili ga waɗanda suka rayar da shi. Kuma a bayyane yake daga riwayar cewa hakan ya faru bayan fiye da shekara guda da Umar (ra) ya karɓi shugabanci, kuma fili ne da Manzon Allah ﷺ ya bayar tun a baya, wato an bayar da shi fiye da shekara uku kafin hakan, shi ya sa Umar (ra) bai mayar da shi ba. Haka kuma a bayyane yake cewa lamarin ya shafi fili ne da aka bayar kawai, ba fili da aka rayar ko aka shinge ba.
What is meant is that more than three years had passed, or in other words, if it had been granted from the time of Abu Bakr (ra), three years would not have passed yet, and similarly if it had been granted in the time of Umar (ra), and so Umar (ra) would have returned it to the one it had been granted to. However, it was the Prophet who granted it, and so more than three years had passed and so it was not possible to return it, rather Umar (ra) confirmed its ownership to the ones who had revived it. And it is apparent from the narration that it occurred more than a year after Umar (ra) took the leadership, and it was land granted from the time of the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) , in other words, it was granted more than three years earlier, and for that reason Umar (ra) did not return it; it is also clear that the event was regarding land that had been granted and was not revived or fenced land.
Abu ‘Ubayd ya ruwaito a cikin littafin Al-Amwal daga Bilal Ibn Al-Harith Al-Muzni, cewa:
Abu ‘Ubayd reported in the book of Al-Amwal from Bilal Ibn Al-Harith Al-Muzni, that:
. أَقْطَعَهُ العَقِيقَ أَجَْْعَ، قَالَ: فَلَمَّا كَانَ زَمَانُ عُمَرَ قَالَ لِبِلاَلٍ: إِنَّ أَنَّ رَسُولَ اللهِ « لََْ يقُْطِعْكَ لِتَحْجُرَهُ عَلَى النَّاسِ، إِنَََّّا أَقْطَعَكَ لِتَعْمَلَ، فَخُذْ مِنْهَا مَا قَدِرْتَ رَسُولَ اللهِ » عَلَى عِمَارَتِهِ وَرُدَّ البَاقِي .
. أَقْطَعَهُ العَقِيقَ أَجَْْعَ، قَالَ: فَلَمَّا كَانَ زَمَانُ عُمَرَ قَالَ لِبِلاَلٍ: إِنَّ أَنَّ رَسُولَ اللهِ « لََْ يقُْطِعْكَ لِتَحْجُرَهُ عَلَى النَّاسِ، إِنَََّّا أَقْطَعَكَ لِتَعْمَلَ، فَخُذْ مِنْهَا مَا قَدِرْتَ رَسُولَ اللهِ » عَلَى عِمَارَتِهِ وَرُدَّ البَاقِي .
“Manzon Allah ﷺ ya ba shi dukan Al-Aqiq a matsayin iko. Ya ce a lokacin Umar, sai ya ce wa Bilal: ‘Manzon Allah ﷺ bai ba ka wurin ba don ka shinge shi daga mutane, sai dai don ka yi amfani da shi. Saboda haka, ka dauki daga cikinsa abin da za ka iya, sannan ka mayar da sauran.’ A bayyane yake daga wannan cewa, rashin amfani da filin saboda rashin iyawar yin amfani da shi dalili ne na karbe filin, kamar yadda Umar (RA) ya fahimta kuma ya aiwatar, kuma iyakar rashin amfani kafin wajabcin karbe filin shi ne shekara uku, kamar yadda aka ambata a cikin maganganun Umar (RA) da suka gabata.”
“The Messenger of Allah (pbuh) had assigned him all of Al- Aqiq as a fief. He said that during the time of Umar, he (Umar) said to Bilal, ‘The Messenger of Allah (pbuh) did not grant you the place to fence it away from the people but rather to use it. So take of it as much as you can afford and return the rest”. It is clear from this that neglect of the land due to the lack of capability to utilise it is a cause for taking the land away, as understood and acted upon by Umar (ra), and the limit of neglect before it is mandatory to take the land is three years as mentioned in the previous words of Umar (ra).
Ba za a ce wannan yana shafar ƙasar da aka bayar kawai ba, domin lamarin ba tambaya ba ce ko wani abu da ya faru wanda nassin ke nufi da shi, a'a yana da faɗi ne, kuma yana shafar dukkan ƙasar da aka mallaka. Saboda haka, dalilin karɓe mallakar ƙasa idan an yi watsi da ita ba shi ne cewa ƙasa ce da aka fara bayarwa ba, sai dai saboda an yi watsi da ita. Wannan kuma an tabbatar da shi ta maganar Umar (ra): "Duk wanda ya yi watsi da wata ƙasa shekara uku bai gina a kanta ba, sannan wani ya zo ya gina a kanta, to tana nasa ne" (Yahya b. Adam ya ruwaito a cikin Al-Kharaj, da Ibn Zanjawaih a cikin Al-Amwal daga 'Amr b. Shu'ayb), kuma maganarsa: "wata ƙasa" kalma ce mai faɗi ba tare da takura ba, wadda ta hada dukkan nau'ikan ƙasar da aka mallaka, ko ta kasance ƙasa marar amfani da aka mallaka daga baya ta hanyar farfado da ita da shinge, ko ta kasance wadda aka gina a kanta aka mallake ta ta hanyar bayarwa ko gado ko saye ko kyauta... hukuncin yana shafarta: ana karɓe ta idan ba a amfani da ita tsawon shekara uku.
It cannot be said that this is only regarding land that has been granted, since the issue was not a question nor an event that occurred which the text was specific to, rather it is general, and is general for all possessed land. Therefore, the cause for taking away the possession of land if it was neglected is not because it was land that was originally granted but rather because it was neglected. This is confirmed by the words of Umar (ra): “whoever neglected a land for three years and did not build upon it, and then someone else came and built upon it then it is theirs” (reported by Yayha b. Adam in Al-Kharaj and Ibn Zanjawi in Al-Amwal from ‘Amr b. Shu’ayb), and his word: “a land” is an unrestricted term which encompasses all types of possessed land, irrespective of whether it was dead and then taken into ownership through revival and fencing, or if it was built upon and taken into ownership by being granted or inheritance or buying or a gift…the rule is applied to it – it is taken if it is not used for three years.
Wannan yana nuna cewa filin da mutum ya mallaka, ko ta hanyar rayar da ƙasa, ko shinge, ko bayarwa, ko saye, ana ƙwace shi daga hannun mai shi idan ya bar shi ba tare da noma ba tsawon shekara uku a jere, kamar yadda aikin Umar (ra) ya nuna a lamarin Amr bin Shu'aib, da kuma maganarsa: "Duk wanda ya yi sakaci da wata ƙasa", da kuma lamarin Bilal. Ba a san cewa wani daga cikin sahabbai ya tsawata masa a kan haka ba, duk da cewa yana daga cikin abubuwan da ake tsawatarwa a kansu, domin karɓar filin noma daga hannun mai shi da ƙarfi ba tare da bayar da wani abu a musanya ba, kuma wanda ya karɓa shi ne Khalifa. Saboda haka wannan ijma'in sahabbai ne. Wannan kuwa saboda ijma'i na sukuti (ijma'in shiru/yarda) shi ne idan wani daga cikin sahabbai ya yi wani aiki wanda da an saba tsawata masa a kansa a gaban rukuni daga cikinsu, sai babu ɗaya daga cikinsu da ya tsawata masa, to wannan hujja ce ta Shari'a. Bisa wannan, filin noma da mutum ya mallaka, ana ƙwace shi daga hannunsa da tilas ba tare da musanya ba idan ya bar shi ba a noma ba tsawon shekara uku a jere.
This indicates that the land which was possessed by an individual, irrespective of whether that was by revival, fencing, granting, or purchasing is taken away from the owner if he left it unutilised for three consecutive years, as was indicated by the action of Umar (ra) in the incident withAmrf Bin Shu’ayb and by his words: “whoever neglected a land”, and by the incident of Bilal, and it is not known that any of the companions rebuked him over that even though it is from the things that are rebukable, because it is forcefully taking a cultivated land from its owner without giving anything in exchange, and the one taking it is the Khalifah; it is accordingly Ijma’ of the companions. This is because the Ijma’ Sukuti (silent Ijma’/Ijma’ of consent) is when one of the companions does an action that would normally be rebuked in front of a group of them, and none of them rebuke it, and so it is a Shari’ah evidence. Based upon this the cultivated land that is owned by an individual, is taken from them by compulsion without exchange if they left it uncultivated for a period of three consecutive years.
Daga wannan, a bayyane yake cewa hukuncin ya shafi dukkan ƙasa, ko an mallake ta ta hanyar rayarwa, ko kyauta, ko gado, ko siyayya, ko kuma wata hanya. Duk ƙasar da aka yi watsi da ita tsawon shekara uku, Gwamnati na karɓe ta daga hannun mai ita dole ba tare da wani diyya ba.
From this, it is clear that the rule encompasses all land, regardless of whether it was possessed through revival, grant, inheritance, purchase or anything else – every land which is neglected for three years is compulsorily taken back by the State from its owner without any compensation.
Ana fahimtar da cewa shekaru uku a jere ne daga cikin nassin, wanda ya shafi daukar filin da kuma barin sa tsawon shekaru uku. Ya ce: "Duk wanda ya bar wata kasa tsawon shekaru uku", don haka batun barin kasa yana aiki ne bayan shekaru uku, kuma ana fahimtar daga wannan cewa shekaru ukun na jere ne. Wannan ya tabbata ba tare da wata shubuha ba ta maganarsa ﷺ: "kuma wanda ya shinge ta ba shi da wani hakki a kanta bayan shekaru uku", don haka kore hakki yana aiki: "bayan shekaru uku", kuma ba a ce "bayan uku" ba idan ba a jere suke ba; ana amfani da shi ne kawai idan sun kasance a jere, daya bayan daya.
The issue of being three consecutive years is understood from the text, which applied to taking the land and to its neglect for three years. He said: “Whoever neglected a land for three years”, and so the issue of neglect applies after three years, and it is understood from this that the three years are consecutive. This is confirmed without any lack of clarity by his words: “and the one who fenced it off has no right to it after three years”, and so the negation applies: “after three years”, and it is not said: “after three” if they were not consecutive, and would only be used if they were consecutive following one after the other.
Dangane da ba manoma taimako daga Bayt Al-Mal (baitul-mali) domin su iya noma filayensu, hujjarsa ita ce abin da Umar (ra) ya yi a Iraki. Lokacin da ya ci Iraki, ya bar ƙasar a hannun mazaunanta, bai raba ta tsakanin mayaƙa ba duk da cewa tana cikin ganima. Ya ba manoman kuɗi daga Bayt Al-Mal (baitul-mali) domin ya ƙarfafa su su noma ƙasarsu, duk da cewa ba su riga sun karɓi Musulunci ba, kuma duk da cewa manoma, bisa ga halinsu na manoma, ba sa cikin waɗanda suka cancanci wani abu daga Bayt Al-Mal (baitul-mali), domin muddin suna mallakar ƙasa ba za a ɗauke su a matsayin matalauta ba. Duk wani abu mai kama da waɗannan batutuwa biyu da ya faru, da an yi tsawatarwa a kansa saboda sabanin sa da ƙa'idojin ganimar yaƙi da ƙa'idojin Bayt Al-Mal (baitul-mali). Game da batu na farko, wato barin ƙasar da aka karɓa a matsayin ganima a hannun waɗanda suka noma ta, ba a raba ta tsakanin mayaƙa ba, akwai sahabbai da suka tsawatar wa Umar (ra), kuma an yi muhawara tsakaninsu. Game da batu na biyu, wato ba manoman Iraki kuɗi daga Bayt Al-Mal (baitul-mali) domin su noma ƙasarsu, babu ɗaya daga cikin sahabbai da ya tsawatar wa Umar (ra), saboda haka akwai ijma'i (yarjejeniya) a kan halascin ba manoma abin da ake buƙata daga Bayt Al-Mal (baitul-mali) domin su iya noma ƙasarsu.
As for giving the farmers help from Bayt Al-Mal (treasury) to enable them to cultivate their land, its evidence is what Umar (ra) did in Iraq. When he conquered Iraq he left the land in the hands of its inhabitants, and did not divide it amongst the fighters even though it was part of the booty. He gave the farmers money from the Bayt Al-Mal (treasury) in order to strengthen them to cultivate their land even though they had not yet embraced Islam, even though farmers in their characteristic as farmers are not from those who deserve anything from Bayt Al-Mal (treasury) since as long as they own land they cannot be counted as being poor. Anything similar to these two issues would normally be rebuked due to their contradiction with the rules regarding war booty and the rules regarding Bayt Al-Mal (treasury). As for the first issue which is leaving the land which was taken as booty with those who cultivated it, and not dividing it amongst the fighters, there were companions who rebuked Umar (ra), and a discussion took place between them. As for the second issue, which was giving the farmers in Iraq money from the Bayt Al-Mal (treasury) in order for them to cultivate their land, none of the companions rebuked Umar (ra), and so it is an Ijma’ (consensus) upon the permission of giving farmers what is required from Bayt Al-Mal (treasury) to enable them to cultivate their land.
Duk hujjojin da ke cikin wannan maƙala ke nan.
These are all the evidences for this article.