14.3 Udanganyifu wa Jinai
14.3 Criminal Fraud
Udanganyifu, kwa maana ya lugha, ni hila. Kwa hiyo, inaposemwa kwamba alimdanganya katika kuuza na kununua, maana yake ni kwamba alimhadaa na kumshinda. Kudanganya bei maana yake ni kuuza kitu kwa bei ya juu au ya chini kuliko thamani yake. Udanganyifu wa jinai umekatazwa katika Shari'a kwa sababu imethibitishwa katika Hadith sahihi kwamba udanganyifu umekatazwa kwa uthabiti. Bukhari alisimulia kutoka kwa 'Abdullah bin 'Umar kwamba mtu mmoja alimweleza Mtume ﷺ kwamba yeye hudanganya katika biashara. Mjumbe wa Allah ﷺ akasema: "Ukiingia katika biashara, sema: hakuna udanganyifu (khilaba)." Ahmad bin Hanbal alisimulia kutoka kwa Anas kwamba mtu mmoja wakati wa Mtume ﷺ alikuwa akifanya biashara ilhali alikuwa dhaifu wa akili. Jamaa zake walimwendea Mtume ﷺ wakasema: "Ee Nabii wa Allah ﷺ, tangaza kwamba mtu fulani hana uwezo wa kisheria (yaani, zuia asiweze kutoa maamuzi ya mali) kwa sababu anafanya biashara ilhali ni dhaifu wa akili." Basi Mtume ﷺ wa Allah (SWT) alimwita mtu huyo na kumkataza kuuza. Yeye akasema: "Ee Nabii wa Allah ﷺ, siwezi kuvumilia kutofanya biashara." Mjumbe wa Allah ﷺ akasema: "Ikiwa hutaacha kufanya biashara, sema: angalia hiki na angalia kile, hakuna udanganyifu." Al-Bazzar alisimulia kutoka kwa Anas kwamba Mjumbe wa Allah ﷺ "alikataza kuuza wanyama ambao hawajakamuliwa maziwa" (kama udanganyifu).
Fraud, linguistically means deceit, so if it is said that He defrauded Him in selling and buying, it means that He deceived him, and subdued him. Deceiving in the price means to sell something for more or less than it’s worth. Criminal fraud is prohibited in Shar’a because it was confirmed in the authentic Hadith that deception is forbidden decisively. Bukhari narrated from ’Abdullah ibn ’Umar that a man mentioned to the Prophet (pbuh) that He deceives in trading; the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) said: “If you entered into trading say there is no deceit (khilaba).” Ahmad ibn Hanbal narrated from Anas “that a man at the time of the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) used to trade while He was mentally weak; his relatives came to the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) and said: ‘O Prophet (pbuh) of Allah, declare so and so person as legally incompetent (i.e. prevent Him from disposition) because He trades while He is feeble minded; so the Prophet (pbuh) of Allah (swt) invited Him and forbade Him from selling; He said: ‘O Prophet (pbuh) of Allah, I cannot bear not to trade.’ The Messenger of Allah (pbuh) said: “If you are not going to stop trading, say: look at this look and at that, there is no deceit.’” Al-Bazzar narrated from Anas that the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) “forbade selling animals left unmilked” (as deception).
Hadithi hizi zilidai kuachwa kwa udanganyifu, jambo linaloonyesha kwamba katazo la udanganyifu lilikuwa la uamuzi wa wazi. Kwa hiyo, udanganyifu ni Haramu (umekatazwa). Lakini kwa kweli udanganyifu ulio Haramu ni ule wa jinai (yaani wa kupindukia), kwa sababu sababu ya kukataza udanganyifu ni kwamba ulikuwa ni udanganyifu katika bei; lakini hilo lisingeitwa udanganyifu kama lingekuwa dogo, kwani basi lingekuwa aina ya ustadi katika majadiliano ya biashara. Kwa hiyo udanganyifu huchukuliwa kuwa ulaghai tu pale unapokuwa wa kupindukia. Ikiwa ulaghai umethibitishwa, mtu aliyedanganywa ana chaguo la kubatilisha mauzo au kuyakamilisha, yaani, ikiwa ulaghai ulijitokeza katika mauzo basi mtu aliyedanganywa ana chaguo la kurudisha fedha na kuchukua bidhaa ikiwa yeye ndiye muuzaji, na kurudisha bidhaa na kuchukua fedha ikiwa yeye ndiye mnunuzi. Lakini hairuhusiwi kuchukua fidia, yaani tofauti kati ya bei halisi ya bidhaa na bei ya mauzo. Hii ni kwa sababu Mtume wa Allah ﷺ alimpa chaguo la kubatilisha mauzo au kuyakamilisha. Ad-Daraqutni ametaja kutoka kwa Muhammad bin Yahya bin Hibban kwamba alisema: Mtume wa Allah ﷺ alisema: "Mkinunua, sema hakuna udanganyifu, basi katika kila bidhaa mliyonunua mnayo chaguo baada ya usiku tatu kukubali (bidhaa) na hivyo kuishika, au kuirudisha kwa mwenyewe." Hili linaonyesha kwamba mtu aliyedanganywa ana chaguo; lakini chaguo hilo linathibitishwa kwa masharti mawili: la kwanza ni kutokujua bei wakati wa mkataba (au makubaliano), na la pili ni ongezeko au punguzo la kupindukia ambalo watu hawahusiki nalo wakati wa mkataba. Udanganyifu wa jinai ni ule ambao wafanyabiashara wanauona kuwa hivyo. Hii haipimwi kwa theluthi moja wala kwa robo ya bei, bali inaachwa kwa makadirio ya wafanyabiashara wa mji wakati wa kufunga mkataba; kwa sababu kiwango cha ongezeko na upungufu hutofautiana kulingana na aina za bidhaa na masoko.
These Ahadith demanded giving up deception, which indicates that forbidding of the deception was decisive. Therefore, deception is Haram (prohibited). But in fact, the deception that is Haram is the criminal (i.e.excessive) deception (or fraud), because the reason for prohibiting fraud is that it was a deception in the price; but this would not be called a deception if it was minute, as it would then be a form of skill in negotiation. So deception is only considered fraud if it was excessive. If fraud was proven, the deceived person has the choice to abrogate the sale or to conclude it i.e. if fraud appeared in the sale then the deceived person has the choice to return the money and take the commodity if He was the seller, and to return back the commodity and take the money if He was the purchaser. But He is not allowed to take the indemnity i.e. the difference between the actual price of the commodity and the sale price. This is because the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) gave Him the choice either to abrogate the sale or to conclude. Ad-Daraqutni mentioned from Muhammad ibn Yahya ibn Hibban that He said that the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) said: “If you purchased say there is no deception, then in every commodity you purchased you have the choice after three nights to accept (the commodity) and thus hold it or to return it back to its owner.” This indicates that the deceived person has the choice; but the choice is proved by two conditions: the first is the lack of knowledge of the price at the time of contract (or deal), and the second is the excessive increase or decrease with which people do not involve in deception at the time of contract. The criminal fraud is that which the traders consider as being so. This is not assessed by one third or by one fourth of the price, but it is rather left to the estimation of the traders in the town at the time of concluding the contract; because the amount of increase and decrease differs according to the types commodities and the markets.