25.7 Tattalin Arzikin Ƙasa
25.7 National Economy
Ka’idar tattalin arzikin ƙasa tana da alaƙa da ra’ayin “kare al’adu” wanda aka samo daga ka’idar masana’antu masu nauyi. Masu goyon bayan ka’idar tattalin arzikin ƙasa sun yi imanin cewa ci gaban tattalin arzikin al’umma dole ne ya nufi samar mata da ƙarfin siyasa da kuma ƙarfin tattalin arziki. Suna ganin cewa ci gaban kowace ƙasa yana wucewa ta matakai uku: mataki na makiyaya/noma, sannan mataki na noma/masana’antu, daga bisani kuma mataki na noma/masana’antu/cinikayya. Ƙasa ba za ta sami ainihin ƙarfi ba sai ta mallaki runduna ta ruwa, da mulkoki na mulkin mallaka, da al’ummomi masu ƙwarewa iri-iri. Haka kuma, ya zama wajibi ƙarfin samarwa da ci gaban tattalin arziki su kasance cikin daidaituwa, kuma wannan zai zama sharaɗi mai muhimmanci ga ƙarfin siyasa. Suna kuma ganin cewa duk da cewa alaƙar tattalin arziki ta ƙasa da ƙasa tana amfana daga gasa ta yadda ya kamata, hakan zai dogara ne akan kowace ƙasa mai gasa ta kai ga kamala wajen bunƙasa ƙarfinta; kuma domin ƙarfafa wannan ci gaba, wajibi ne a kare masana’antu. Amma game da noma, ba zai samu kariya ba, kuma za a bar shi ya fitar da kowane irin amfanin gona ba tare da takura ko sharuɗɗa ba, farashinsa kuma zai kasance bisa kasuwa mai ’yanci. Saboda haka, ka’idar tattalin arzikin ƙasa a ainihinta tana karkata ne zuwa ga masana’antu. Tana bayyana cewa al’ummomin da suke burin zama masu ƙarfi ya kamata su yi ƙoƙarin ƙetare matakin noma zuwa masana’antu, domin a ƙasar noma, yawan ƙarfin samarwa wato ma’aikata, da kuma yawan albarkatun ƙasa wato kayan masarufi, suna zama ba tare da aiki ba kuma ba a amfani da su. Saboda haka, domin zuba jari a cikin ma’aikata da albarkatun ƙasa, ya kamata a fara shirin masana’antu tare da noma. Ƙasar da ta kafa tattalin arzikinta bisa noma kawai ba za ta mallaki ƙarfin tattalin arziki da matsayin rayuwa da ƙasar da ke da tushe a noma da masana’antu za ta mallaka ba. Ka'idar tattalin arzikin ƙasa tana buƙatar kasancewar masana'antu tare da noma domin ƙasa ta iya tsayawa da ƙafafunta a fannin tattalin arziki. Saboda haka, ainihin ma'anar tattalin arzikin ƙasa tana aiwatar da ka'idar kariya (protectionism) a kan masana'antu, don haka tana sanya takunkumi da haraji masu dacewa kan shigo da kaya da fitar da kaya na masana'antu kawai, a lokaci guda kuma tana aiwatar da ka'idar cinikayya mara shinge a kan noma, tana mai da shi ba tare da wani takunkumin ciniki ba.
The theory of national economy is linked to the concept of “cultural protection” derived from the theory of heavy industry. The champions of the theory of national economy deem that the economic growth of a nation must aim at providing her with political power as well as economic power. They deem that the growth of any country would undergo three stages: The pastoral/agricultural stage, the agricultural/industrial stage, then the agricultural/industrial trading stage. A country would not achieve real power unless she acquired a navy, colonies and populations with various skills. Furthermore it would be essential for the productive forces and economic growth to be in harmony, and this would serve as a fundamental condition of political power. They also deem that although international economic ties would benefit from free competition, this would depend on all competing countries reaching perfection in developing their powers; and in order to stimulate this development, industry must be protected. As for agriculture, it would not enjoy any protection and it would be permitted to export all kinds of produce without restriction or conditions, and their prices would be set according to the free market. Therefore, the theory of national economy would be in essence industry orientated. It states that the nations who aim towards being powerful should be eager to pass the agricultural stage to industry, because in the agricultural country, a large size of the productive forces i.e. the workforce, as well as a considerable size of the natural resources i.e. the raw materials, would remain unemployed and unexploited. Therefore, in order to invest in the workforce and the natural resources, an industrial programme should be initiated alongside agriculture. A country who establishes her economy solely based on agriculture would not possess the economic capability and the standard of living which an agricultural/industrial based country would have. The theory of national economy necessitates the presence of industry alongside agriculture in order for the country to be able to stand on its own feet economically. Therefore, the concept of national economy in fact applies protectionist theory on industry, thus imposing the appropriate restrictions and tariffs exclusively on industrial imports and exports, whilst at the same time, it applies free trade theory on agriculture making it free of any trade restrictions.
Islam rejects this theory, because leaving foreign agricultural trade free of control means that the State would not control the foreign trade of agricultural products. This is forbidden, for the State organises all agricultural, industrial, or any other commodity which enters or leaves the country; it could ban the export of some commodities while permitting the export of others. It would deal directly with the issue of belligerents and traders under treaty, while choosing merely to supervise its own citizens. As for the State's interference in industrial matters in accordance with the country's interest and in order to boost the economy, this would form part of its duty to manage the Ummah's affairs, and this is commanded by Islam. However, all this would be restricted by the interest of the Da'wah (calling to Islam), together with industrial development, i.e. not just for industrial development. This demonstrates that, although the theory of national economy has, in parts of its industrial vision, aspects identical to those which are part of the management of the Ummah's affairs that Islam approves of, such aspects contradict Islam because they are not linked to the interests of the Da'wah for Islam. Overall, the whole theory contradicts Islam due to the total freedom given to agriculture, therefore Muslims would not adopt such a theory.
Islam is averse to such a theory, because leaving the foreign agricultural trade free of control means that the State would not control the foreign trade of agricultural products. This is forbidden, for the State organises all agricultural, industrial, or any other commodity which enters or leaves the country; she could ban the export of some commodities, while permitting the export of others. She would deal directly with the issue of belligerent and traders under treaty, while opting to merely supervise her own citizens. As for the State’s interference in industrial matters in accordance with the country’s interest and in order to boost the economy, this would form part of her duty to manage the Ummah’s affairs and this is commanded by Islam. However, all this would be restricted with the interest of the Da’wah (campaigning for Islam), together with the industrial development, i.e. not just for industrial development. This demonstrates that, although the theory of national economy has, in parts of its industrial vision, identical aspects to those which are part of the management of the Ummah’s affairs that Islam approves of, such aspects contradict Islam because they are not linked to the interests of the Da’awa for Islam. Overall, the whole theory contradicts Islam due to the total freedom given to agriculture, therefore Muslims would not adopt such a theory.