7.4 Vazifalangan yordamchining vazifasi
7.4 The task of the Delegated Assistant
Vakolat berilgan yordamchining vazifasi — halifaga o‘zi amalga oshirmoqchi bo‘lgan barcha ishlarni taqdim etishdir. Keyin u halifaga qaror qabul qilish jihatidan nimalarni ijro etgani va boshqaruv hamda tayinlash jihatidan nimalarni bajargani haqida hisobot beradi, shunda yordamchi vakolatlari jihatidan halifaga o‘xshab qolmaydi. Shuning uchun uning vazifasi o‘z ko‘rib chiqishini taqdim etish, so‘ngra uni ijro etishdir, faqat halifa uni buncha qilishdan to‘xtatmagan bo‘lsa.
The task of the delegated assistant is to submit to the Khaleefah all the work He intends to perform. He then reports to the Khaleefah what He has executed in terms of decisions and what He has discharged in terms of management and appointment, so that the assistant would not become like the Khaleefah in his powers. Therefore, his job is to submit his review and then execute it, unless the Khaleefah stops Him from doing so.
Dalil bu narsa bilan tasdiqlanadi: Mu'avin Xalifaning o'rinbosari sifatida haqiqatan mavjud. O'rinbosar o'zini o'rinbosar etib tayinlagan kishi nomidan ish yuritadi. Shu sababli u Xalifadan mustaqil bo'lib qolmaydi, balki har bir ishni Xalifa bilan birgalikda ko'rib chiqadi, худди 'Umar Abu Bakrning vazири bo'lganida qilganidek: u nima qilmoqchi bo'lsa, avval Abu Bakr bilan muhokama qilar, so'ngra shunga muvofiq ish bajarardi. Xalifa bilan ko'rib chiqish har bir tafsilot uchun uning ruxsatini so'rashni anglatmaydi, chunki bu Mu'avinning haqiqatiga zid keladi. Aksincha, ko'rib chiqish masalani u bilan muhokama qilishni anglatadi, masalan, qobiliyatli Vali ni viloyatlardan biriga tayinlash, bozorda oziq-ovqat tanqisligi haqidagi shikoyatlarni bartaraf etish yoki boshqa davlat ishlari. U, shuningdek, masalani taqdimot shaklida Xalifaga taqdim etishi mumkin, bu esa Mu'avinga kelajakda ishni barcha tafsilotlari bilan ijro etish uchun ruxsat so'rash zaruratisiz yetarli bo'ladi. Ammo agar Xalifa biror masalani bajarishni to'xtatish haqida buyruq bersa, unda u bajarilmasligi kerak. Demak, taqdimot shunchaki taklifni ilgari surish va u haqida Xalifa bilan maslahatlashishdir, u ishni bajarish uchun ruxsat so'rash degani emas. Mu'avin, Xalifa uni to'xtatmagan ekan, kerakli ishni bajarishi mumkin.
Evidence for this is the reality of the Mu’awin as a deputy of the Khaleefah. A deputy acts on behalf of the person who appointed Him as his deputy. Thus He does not become independent from the Khaleefah, but rather reviews with Him every action exactly as ‘Umar used to do when He was Wazir to Abu Bakr, where He used to review with Abu Bakr what He intended to perform, then executed it accordingly. Reviewing with the Khaleefah does not necessarily mean that He needs to ask for his permission in every single detail, for this contradicts the reality of the Mu’awin. Rather, reviewing with the Khaleefah means to discuss the matter with him, like for example to appoint a capable Wali to one of the provinces, or remove the complaints of people in terms of food shortages in the market, or any other state affairs. He may also submit a matter to him, in the form of a presentation, which would be sufficient for the Mu’awin in the future to carry out the matter with all its details, without the need for permission to act. However, if the Khaleefah issues orders to stop the carrying out of any issue, then it should not be executed. Hence, the presentation is simply putting forward of a proposal and the consultation with the Khaleefah about it, and it does not mean seeking permission to carry out the task. The Mu’awin can execute the task in question as long as the Khaleefah does not stop Him from doing so.
Xalifa mu’āvinning harakatlarini va ishlarni boshqarishini ko‘rib chiqishi kerak, shunda to‘g‘ri ishni tasdiqlab, noto‘g‘rini tuzatsin. Buning sababi shuki, ummat ishlarini boshqarish xalifaga topshirilgan bo‘lib, uni u o‘zining ijtihodiga ko‘ra ado etadi.
The Khaleefah should review the actions of the Mu’awin and his management of affairs, in order to approve what is right and redress what is wrong. This is because the management of the Ummah’s affairs is commissioned to the Khaleefah and discharged according to his own Ijtihad.
Dalil bu — Payg'ambar (s.a.v.) ning "Imom — qo'riqchi va u o'z raiyatiga javobgardir" degan hadisi, ya'ni raiyatga nisbatan mas'uliyat haqidagi hadisdir. Shuning uchun Xalifa hukumat ishini yuritish huquqiga ega va u o'z raiyatiga javobgardir, vakil qilingan Mu'avin esa raiyatga javobgar emas, balki faqat o'z harakatlari uchun javobgardir. Demak, raiyatga nisbatan mas'uliyat faqat Xalifaning zimmasidadir. Shu sababli Xalifa o'z raiyatiga nisbatan burchini bajarish maqsadida Mu'avinning harakatlarini va uning faoliyatini ko'rib chiqishga majburdir. Bundan tashqari, vakil qilingan yordamchi ba'zan xato qilishi mumkin va Xalifa bunday xatolarni tuzatishi kerak, shuning uchun u yordamchining barcha harakatlarini ko'rib chiqishi lozim. Demak, ikki sababga ko'ra — raiyatga nisbatan mas'uliyatni bajarish va vakil qilingan yordamchi tomonidan yuzaga kelishi mumkin bo'lgan xatolarni tuzatish uchun Xalifa Mu'avinning barcha harakatlarini ko'rib chiqishga majburdir.
The evidence for this is the Hadith of responsibility over the subjects where the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) said “The Imam is a guardian and He is responsible over his subjects.” Therefore, the Khaleefah is entitled to the task of government and He is responsible over his subjects, whereas the delegated Mu’awin is not responsible over subjects, but He is merely responsible for his own actions. Thus, responsibility about the subjects is for the Khaleefah alone. Therefore, the Khaleefah is obliged to review the actions of the Mu’awin and his performance in order to fulfil his duty towards his subjects. Besides, the delegated assistant can sometimes make errors, and the Khaleefah has to redress such errors, so He has to review all the assistant’s actions. Therefore, it is for these two reasons: fulfilling responsibility towards his subjects and redressing potential errors made by the delegated assistant, that the Khaleefah is obliged to review all of the Mu’awin’s actions.
Agar vakolatli yordamchi biror masalani hal qilgan bo‘lsa va xalifa unga rozi bo‘lsa, mu‘avin uni hech qanday o‘zgartirishsiz ijro etishi mumkin edi. Agar xalifa mu‘avin ijro etgan ishga e’tiroz bildirsa, bunda masala tekshirib ko‘rilar edi. Agar mu‘avin hukmni to‘g‘ri ijro etgan bo‘lsa yoki mablag‘larni to‘g‘ri yo‘nalishlarga yoki muayyan loyihalarga sarflagan bo‘lsa, u holda mu‘avinning fikri kuchga kiradi, chunki asosan bu xalifaning fikridir va xalifaning ijro etilgan hukm yoki sarflangan mablag‘lar yuzasidan mu‘avin qilgan ishni bekor qilishga haqqi yo‘q. Biroq, agar mu‘avin boshqa turdagi ishlarni, masalan, vali tayinlash yoki qo‘shin tayyorlashni amalga oshirgan bo‘lsa, xalifaning mu‘avin qarorini bekor qilib, o‘z qarorini joriy etish va mu‘avin amallarini bekor qilish haqqi bor. Bunga sabab shuki, xalifaning o‘z amallarini qayta ko‘rib chiqish haqqi bor, shuning uchun u yordamchisining amallarini ham qayta ko‘rib chiqish haqqiga ega.
If the delegated assistant decided a matter and the Khaleefah approved of it, the Mu’awin could then execute it without any alterations. If the Khaleefah objected to what the Mu’awin had executed, then in this case the matter would be examined. If the Mu’awin had correctly carried out a verdict or if He had spent some funds in the right areas or in certain projects, then the Mu’awin’s opinion comes into force, for, in principle, it is the Khaleefah’s opinion, and the Khaleefah has no right to redress what the Mu’awin had executed in terms of rules or funds He had spent. However, if the Mu’awin had performed other types of actions, such as the appointing of a Wali or the preparation of an army, the Khaleefah has the right to reverse the Mu’awin’s decision and enforce his own and nullify the Mu’awin’s actions. This is because the Khaleefah has the right to redress his own actions so He has the right to redress the actions of his assistant.
Bu Mu’āvinning o‘z amallarini bajarishdagi tartibi va Xalifaning Mu’āvin amallarini ko‘rib chiqishdagi tartibi haqida bayon. Bu Xalifa qaysi amallarni tuzatishga haqli va qaysilarini tuzatishga haqli emasligidan kelib chiqadi. Sababi, vakolat berilgan Mu’āvinning amallari Xalifaning amallari hisoblanadi. Buning izohi shuki, vakolat berilgan yordamchiga, Xalifa kabi, mustaqil hukm qilish va hokimlar tayinlash joizdir, chunki hukm qilish shartlari unga berilgan. U shikoyatlarni tekshirishga yoki buni boshqaga topshirishga ham haqlidir, chunki shikoyatlarni ko‘rish shartlari unga tasdiqlangan. U jihodga mustaqil rahbarlik qilishga yoki buni boshqaga topshirishga ham haqlidir, chunki urush shartlari unga tasdiqlangan. U o‘zi qaror qilgan buyruqlarni ijro etishga yoki ularni o‘rniga boshqaga ijro etishni topshirishga haqlidir, chunki fikr bildirish va boshqaruv shartlari unga berilgan. Ammo bu Xalifa Mu’āvin qilgan ishlarni, u unga xabar berilgan ekan, bekor qila olmaydi, degani emas. Balki bu, uning Xalifa bilan teng vakolatga ega bo‘lishi, lekin uning nomidan ish yuritishi va undan mustaqil bo‘lmasligini anglatadi. Shuning uchun Xalifa Mu’āvin bilan rozi bo‘lmaslikka va ijro etilgan ishni tuzatishga yoki uning har qanday amalini bekor qilishga haqlidir, faqat bu Xalifaning o‘zi o‘z amallarini tuzatishi mumkin bo‘lgan turdagi ishlarga nisbatan qo‘llanadi. Agar Mu’āvin hukmni to‘g‘ri ijro etgan yoki mablag‘larni to‘g‘ri sohalarga sarflagan bo‘lsa, Xalifaning e’tirozlari ahamiyatga ega bo‘lmaydi va Mu’āvinning qarori ijro etiladi. Sababi, asosan, bu Xalifaning o‘z qarori bo‘lib, bunday hollarda u o‘z qarorini bekor qila olmaydi yoki o‘zi ijro etgan ishni yo‘qqa chiqara olmaydi; demak, u o‘z Mu’āvinining amalini ham bekor qila olmaydi. Shunga qaramay, agar Mu’awin Vali, ma’mur, qo‘shin qo‘mondoni yoki boshqa biror tayinlovchini tayinlagan bo‘lsa yoki iqtisodiy strategiya, harbiy reja, sanoat dasturi yoki shunga o‘xshash har qanday ishni belgilagan bo‘lsa, unda Xalifaga uni bekor qilish mumkin. Buning sababi shundaki, garchi bular Xalifaning fikrlari hisoblansa-da, ular Xalifaning o‘zi qilgan taqdirda ham tuzatish huquqiga ega bo‘lgan qarorlar toifasiga kiradi. Demak, u Mu’awinning qarorlarida ham xuddi shunday qilishi mumkin. Shunday ekan, bu toifada Xalifa Mu’awinning harakatlarini bekor qilishi joizdir. Bu borada asosiy qoida quyidagicha: Xalifa o‘z harakatlaridan tuzatishi mumkin bo‘lgan har qanday ish, Mu’awin tomonidan qilingan bo‘lsa, Xalifa uni xuddi shunday tuzatish huquqiga ega; Xalifa o‘z harakatlaridan tuzata olmaydigan har qanday ish esa, Mu’awin tomonidan qilingan bo‘lsa, Xalifa uni tuzatishi joiz emas.
This is a description of the way that the Mu’awin follows in performing his actions and of the way that the Khaleefah follows in reviewing the Mu’awin’s actions. It is derived from what sort of actions the Khaleefah is allowed to redress and what actions He is not allowed to redress. This is because the actions of the delegated Mu’awin are considered as actions of the Khaleefah. As an explanation for this, it is allowed for the delegated assistant to rule by himself and to appoint rulers as it is allowed for the Khaleefah. This is because the conditions of ruling have been conferred to him. He is also entitled to investigate complaints or to deputise someone to do so, because the conditions of complaints have been verified for him. He is also entitled to take charge of Jihad by himself, or appoint someone to do so, for the conditions of war have been verified for him. He is entitled to execute orders He has decided upon or to deputise someone to execute them on his behalf, for the conditions of voicing an opinion and management are conferred to him. However, this does not mean that the Khaleefah can’t reverse whatever the Mu’awin performed as long as He had been briefed about it. It means rather that He possesses the same powers as the Khaleefah, but He acts on his behalf and not independent of him. Therefore, the Khaleefah is entitled to disagree with the Mu’awin and redress what has been executed or reverse any of his actions, bearing in mind that this applies only to the sort of actions that the Khaleefah could redress of his own actions. If the Mu’awin had executed a rule correctly or spent funds in the right areas, then the Khaleefah’s objections would carry no weight and the Mu’awin’s decision would be executed. This is because in principle, it is the Khaleefah’s own decision and in such cases He himself could not reverse his decision or nullify what He himself had executed, hence, He could not reverse his Mu’awin’s action. However, if the Mu’awin had appointed a Wali, an administrator, an army commander or any other appointee or if He had laid down an economic strategy, a military plan or an industrial programme or any similar undertaking, then the Khaleefah is allowed to nullify it. This is because, although they are considered as being the Khaleefah’s opinions, they fall under the category of decisions that the Khaleefah is entitled to redress even when done by him. Accordingly, He could do likewise with his Mu’awin’s decisions. So in this category, it is allowed for the Khaleefah to nullify the actions of the Mu’awin. The basic rule concerning this would be as follows: Any action that the Khaleefah is allowed to redress of his own actions, He is entitled to redress in a like manner if performed by his Mu’awin; and every action the Khaleefah cannot redress of his own actions, He is not allowed to redress if performed by his Mu’awin.
Tafvidga vakil bo‘lgan Mu’avin muayyan bir bo‘limga, masalan, ta’lim bo‘limiga tayinlanmaydi; yoki muayyan bir ishga, masalan, qo‘shin va uning qurol-yarog‘ tizimlarini tayyorlashga tayinlanmaydi, chunki uning tayinlanishi umumiydir. U ma’muriy ishlarni ham olib bormaydi, balki xalifa kabi ular ustidan umumiy nazoratga ega bo‘ladi. Agar u shunday tayinlangan bo‘lsa, bu tayinlash unga Vizorat (yordamchilik) lavozimini bermaydi va u o‘zi tayinlangan ishda xalifaning yordamchisi bo‘lmaydi. Chunki bunday shartnoma aniq va cheklangan bo‘lib, umumiy nazoratni o‘z ichiga olmaydi, holbuki umumiy nazorat tafvidga vakil bo‘lgan yordamchini tayinlashning shartidir. Oliy qozini tayinlash esa xalifaning sud sohasidagi yordamchisini tayinlash hisoblanmaydi, balki ijro hokimiyatidan boshqa sohadagi, masalan, qo‘shin amirligi yoki sadaqot amirligi kabi muayyan vakolatga ega Vali (hokim) tayinlashdir. Bunday lavozimlar viloyatlarga tayinlash kabi amalga oshiriladi, tafvid mu’aviniga tayinlash kabi emas. Shu sababli oliy qozi amirdir: u qozilarni tayinlash, sud ishlarini tekshirish va odamlar o‘rtasida hukm chiqarish vakolatiga ega, lekin u yordamchi emas. Demak, tafvidga vakil bo‘lgan yordamchini muayyan bir bo‘lim bilan cheklash noto‘g‘ri bo‘lardi. Agar u muayyan bo‘lim bilan cheklansa, uning shartnomasi haqiqiy bo‘lmay, bekor bo‘lardi. Tafvidga vakil yordamchining tayinlanishi to‘g‘ri bo‘lishi uchun u shartnoma bo‘lishi, ya’ni aniq so‘zlar bilan ifodalanib, ikki shartni o‘z ichiga olishi kerak: birinchisi uning umumiyligi, ikkinchisi esa naiblikdir. Uni ma’lum bir bo‘lim bilan cheklash shartnomaning ikki shartidan birini yo‘qotishga olib keladi va natijada uning ish bo‘yicha shartnomasi bekor bo‘ladi. Bundan tashqari, u ma’muriy ishlar bilan shug‘ullanishi ham mumkin emas, chunki ma’muriy ishlar bilan shug‘ullanuvchilar davlat xizmatchilari bo‘lib, hukmdorlar emas. Vakil hokim emas, balki davlat xizmatchisi ham emas. Uning (vakilning) vazifasi ishlarni boshqarish bo‘lgani uchun, u davlat xizmatchilari bajarishga yollangan vazifalarni bajarmasligi kerak.
The delegated Mu’awin is not designated to a particular department, like the education department for example; nor a particular action, like the preparation of an army and its weaponry systems, because his appointment is general. He also does not carry out administrative matters, but He has like the Khaleefah, a general supervision over them. If He had been appointed as such then the Wizara (the assistantship) would not be conferred to Him by this appointment nor will He be assistant to the Khaleefah in the matter in which He was appointed. This is because such a contract is specific and thus does not include general supervision, which is a condition in appointing the delegated assistant. As for the appointment of the Supreme Judge, this is not considered an appointment of an assistant to the Khaleefah in the Judiciary, but an appointment of a Wali with a specific Wilayah in other than the ruling; like the Imarah of the army, or the Imarah of the Sadaqat and the like. Such posts would be convened like those of the Wilayahs, not like the appointment of the Mu’awin-ut-Tafweedh. Hence the supreme judge is an Ameer, with a mandate to appoint Judges and to examine the judicial matters, and to judge between people, but He is not an assistant. Therefore, it would be wrong to confine the delegated assistant to a particular department. If He were confined to a particular department, his contract would be null and void. In order for the appointment of the delegated assistant to be valid, it must be a contract i.e. it should be expressed in clear wording that contains two conditions: one would be its generality and the second is the deputyship. By limiting Him to a certain department would make Him miss one of the two conditions of his contract, and accordingly the contract of his employment would be nullified. In addition to this, He is not allowed to practice the administrative matters; this is because those who practice administrative matters are civil servants not rulers. Since the delegated assistant is a ruler, not a civil servant, and his (assistants’) functions are to look after the affairs, He is not to perform the functions that the civil servants are employed to perform.
Shu sababli U administrativ ishlarni boshqarmaydi. Biroq bu U biror ma'muriy harakatni amalga oshirishdan to'silgan, degani emas; balki U faqat ma'muriy vazifalar bilan cheklanmagan, aksincha, unga umumiy mas'uliyat berilgan.
This is the reason why He does not run the administrative matters. It does not mean, however, that He is prevented from carrying out any administrative action; rather He is not confined to administrative functions, but is given a general responsibility.