Shunga ko'ra, farq shundaki, u zot (s.a.v.) vahiy, ya'ni nubuvvatga ega bo'lgan. Bundan tashqari u zot (s.a.v.) boshqa har bir odam kabi oddiy inson edi. Shuning uchun hukmronlikda u zot (s.a.v.) inson edi va shubhasiz, uning xalifalari (Xulafa') ham boshqa har qanday inson kabi inson bo'lar edilar, chunki ular unga faqat hukmronlikda voris bo'lar edilar, nubuvvat va risolatda emas. Shu sababli xalifaga ismatlilik (gunohsizlik) talab qilinmaydi, chunki bu hukmronlikda emas, balki nubuvvatning talabidir. Xalifa faqat hukmdor, xolos, shuning uchun bu lavozimni egallagan kishilar uchun ismatlilik sharti ahamiyatsizdir. Hatto xalifalik lavozimini egallagan har bir kishi zimmasiga ismatlilikni shart qilib qo'yish ham man etiladi. Chunki ismatlilik faqat payg'ambarlarga xos bo'lib, payg'ambar bo'lmagan birovga bunday da'vo qilish harom qilingan. Shariatni yetkazish (tableg') faqat payg'ambar va rasulda ismatlilikning mavjudligini talab qiladi, ya'ni bu ilohiy xabarni yetkazishdagi ismatlilikdir. Gunohlardan saqlanish shaklidagi uning amalga oshishi yetkazishdagi ismatlilikdan keyin keladi. Chunki unda gunoh qilmaslik bilan birga taqiqlangan narsalardan ismatlilik bo'lmasa, uning ismatligi to'liq bo'lmas edi. Demak, ismatlilik xabarni yetkazish uchun zarurdir, odamlarning unga iymon keltirishi yoki keltirmasligi uchun yoki amallarda xato yuz berishi yoki bermasligi uchun emas. Balki ismatlilikni talab qiladigan narsa xabarni yetkazishdir, boshqa narsa emas. Agar Alloh payg'ambar yoki rasulni ma'sum qilmagan bo'lganida, unda Alloh xabarni yashirishi, unga qo'shishi yoki undan ayirishi, Alloh aytmagan narsalarni to'qishi yoki o'zi yetkazishga buyurilganidan boshqasini e'lon qilib xato qilishi mumkin bo'lar edi. Bularning barchasi Allohdan (s.a.v.) xabarni yetkazish bilan zid keladi va e'tiqod qilinishi lozim bo'lgan rasul bo'lish bilan ham ziddir. Shuning uchun, Elchi xabarni yetkazishda ‘ismat (gunohsizlik) bilan ajralib turishi zarur edi va shunga muvofiq, uning gunohlar sodir etishdan ‘ismati ham shundan kelib chiqadi. Shu sababli olimlar payg‘ambarlarning ‘ismati haqida, ya’ni harom qilingan narsalarni (al-muharramat) sodir etish masalasida ixtilof qilganlar. Ba’zilari, u faqat katta gunohlardan (al-kaba’ir) ma’sum bo‘lib, kichik gunohlarni (as-saghaa’ir) sodir etishi mumkin, dedilar. Ba’zilari esa u ham katta, ham kichik gunohlardan ma’sumdir, dedilar. Ular buni shunga asoslab aytdilar: xabarni mukammal yetkazish amallarga bog‘liqdir. Agar xabarning mukammalligi amallarga bog‘liq bo‘lsa, u holda xabardagi ‘ismat amallarni ham o‘z ichiga oladi. Demak, Payg‘ambar ﷺ gunoh qilishdan ma’sum bo‘ladi, chunki amallarida ma’sum bo‘lmasa, xabar mukammal bo‘lmaydi. Ammo agar xabarning mukammalligi amallarga bog‘liq bo‘lmasa, u holda ‘ismat ularni o‘z ichiga olmaydi. Shunday ekan, u ulardan ma’sum bo‘lmaydi, chunki xabar ularsiz ham mukammal bo‘lardi. Shu sababli musulmonlar orasida hech qanday ixtilof yo‘qki, Payg‘ambar ﷺ Alloh ta’olo munosib deb hisoblamagan amallarni qilishdan ma’sum emas edi, chunki xabarning mukammalligi aynan o‘sha amallarga bog‘liq emas. Shunday qilib, ‘ismat faqat xabarga xos bo‘lib, u faqat Elchilar va Payg‘ambarlarda mavjuddir va ularden boshqalar uchun mutlaqo ruxsat etilmaydi.
The distinction, therefore, lies in the fact that he (pbuh) received revelation, namely the Prophethood. Other than that he (pbuh) was a man like any other man. Therefore, in ruling he (pbuh) was human, and undoubtedly his successors (Khulafaa’) would also be humans just like any other human, because they would only be successors to Him in ruling, not Prophethood and Messengership. Infallibility does not therefore apply to the Khaleefah, as this is not required in ruling but it is a requirement of Prophethood. The Khaleefah is only a ruler no more, so the condition of infallibility is irrelevant to those who take up this post. It is even forbidden to stipulate infallibility as a precondition incumbent upon whoever takes up the post of Khilafah. This is because infallibility is restricted to the Prophets and it is forbidden to claim it on behalf of anyone other than a Prophet. The conveyance (Tableegh) of a Shari’ah requires the existence of infallibility in the Prophet and Messenger alone, so it is infallibility in the conveyance of the divine Message. Its realisation in the shape of not committing any sins follows the infallibility in conveyance (Tableegh). This is because the infallibility in Him would not be complete without the infallibility from committing the forbidden things. Thus infallibility is necessary for conveying of the Message and not for the people to believe or not in Him or for the occurrence or not of error in the actions. Rather what requires the infallibility is the conveyance of the Message and no more. If Allah had not made the Prophet or Messenger infallible it would then have been possible for Him to hide the Message or to add to it, or take away from it, or fabricate things which Allah did not say, or make a mistake by proclaiming other than what he has been ordered to convey. All these matters contradict with the conveyance of a Message from Allah (pbuh), and for being a Messenger, who must be believed in. Therefore, it was necessary that the Messenger be characterised by infallibility (‘Isma) in proclaiming the Message, and accordingly his infallibility from committing sins follows. Therefore the scholars differed over the infallibility (‘Isma) of the Prophets in the issue of committing the forbidden things (Al-muharramaat). Some of them said he is infallible from committing the major sins (Al-kabaa’ir) only and it is possible that he commits minor sins (As-saghaa’ir). Some of them said that he is infallible with regards to both major and minor sins. They said that because the perfection of proclamation depends on the actions. If the perfection of the proclamation depends on the actions, then the infallibility in the proclamation will include the actions. Accordingly, the Prophet will be infallible from committing sins, since the proclamation will not be perfected unless he is infallible in the actions. But if the perfection of the proclamation does not depend on the actions, then the infallibility does not include them. Thus, he will not be infallible from them, because the proclamation would then be perfected without them. This is why there is no difference amongst the Muslims that the Prophet (pbuh) was not infallible from doing actions other than those that Allah considered more appropriate, because the perfection of proclamation definitely does not depend upon these actions. Thereupon, the infallibility (‘Isma) is only specific to the proclamation, and thus it does not exist except for the Messengers and the Prophets and it is not allowed to be for other than them absolutely.