4.3 Tanlovning shartlari
4.3 The conditions of preference
Yuqorida sanab o'tilganlar Xalifa tayinlanishi uchun zarur bo'lgan shartnoma shartlaridir. Yuqorida zikr qilingan yettita shartdan boshqa har qanday shart Xalifalikni tuzish uchun zaruriy old shart hisoblanmaydi. Biroq bunday shartlar, agar ularga oid matnlar tasdiqlangan bo'lsa yoki ular sahih matn bilan tasdiqlangan qoida ostida keltirilgan bo'lsa, afzallik shartlari hisoblanadi. Shart shartnoma sharti bo'lishi uchun, uning majburiy ekanini bildiruvchi qat'iy amr (Talab Jazim) mavjud dalil bo'lishi kerak. Agar dalilda qat'iy amr bo'lmasa, shart faqat afzallik shartiga aylanadi. Yettita shartdan boshqa qat'iy amrni o'z ichiga olgan hech qanday dalil topilmagan; shuning uchun aynan ular shartnoma shartlarini tashkil etadi. Qolgan, qoidasi sahih deb tasdiqlangan shartlar esa faqat afzallik shartlaridir. Shunday ekan, Xalifa mujtahid bo'lishi kerak degan talab shartnoma sharti emas, chunki bu qat'iy amrni ko'rsatuvchi matn bilan tasdiqlanmagan. Bundan tashqari, Xalifaning vazifasi hukm yuritishdir, shuning uchun u o'z ijtihodiga muhtoj emas: u fatvo so'rashi yoki mujtahidning fikrlariga ergashib, taqlid asosida razm qilishi mumkin. Shu sababli uning mujtahid bo'lishi shart emas. Uning mujtahid bo'lishi afzal, ammo mujtahid bo'lmasa ham Xalifalik baribir tuziladi. Xalifa jasur bo'lishi shart emas, shuningdek, ziyrak siyosatchi yoki xalq ishlarini boshqarishda mutaxassis bo'lishi ham shart emas, chunki bu shartlarni asoslovchi dalillar yo'q va ular shartnoma shartlarini belgilovchi ilohiy hukm doirasiga kirmaydi. Biroq Xalifaning ko'zi o'tkir, fikri teran jasur bo'lishi afzaldir. Xalifa Quraysh qabilasidan bo'lishi ham shart emas. Muoviya roziyallohu anhudan rivoyat qilinishicha, Bukhoriy rivoyat qilgan hadisda u aytadi: Men Allohning Elchisi ﷺ ning shunday deganlarini eshitdim:
The aforementioned are the contractual conditions necessary for the Khaleefah to be appointed. Any other condition, apart from the seven mentioned above, does not constitute a necessary prerequisite for contracting the Khilafah. Such conditions however, constitute conditions of preference if the texts relating to them are confirmed, or if they are listed under a rule that has been confirmed by a sound (Sahih) text. In order for the condition to be a contractual one it should have evidence that includes a decisive command (Talab Jazim) to indicate that it is obligatory. If the evidence does not include a decisive command then the condition becomes only one of preference. No evidence containing a decisive command has been found except for those seven conditions; therefore they alone constitute the contractual conditions. As for the other conditions, whereby a rule has been confirmed as sound, these would constitute conditions of preference only. Therefore, the stipulation that the Khaleefah must be a Mujtahid is not a contractual condition because this has not been confirmed by a text indicating a decisive command. Moreover, the duty of the Khaleefah is to rule, so He is not in need of his own Ijtihad, as He could ask about a verdict or follow the opinions of a Mujtahid and adopt opinions on the basis of his imitation (Taqlid), thus it is not necessary for him to be a Mujtahid. It is, however, preferable for him to be so, but if He is not his Khilafah would still be contracted. The Khaleefah does not have to be brave, nor a shrewd politician or an expert in managing the affairs of the people because there are no evidences to back these conditions, nor do they come under a divine rule that makes them contractual conditions. It is, however, preferable for the Khaleefah to be brave with vision and opinion . The Khaleefah does not also necessarily have to be from Quraysh. As for what has been reported by Al-Bukhari from Mu’awiya that He said: I heard the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) say:
"Albatta bu ish Qurayshga tegishlidir. Qachonki ular dinni joriy etar ekan, kim ularga dushmanlik qilsa, Alloh uni yuzi bilan yerga uradi." Va Al-Bukhoriy Ibn ‘Umardan rivoyat qilgan hadis: Allohning Elchisi ﷺ aytdilar:
“Verily this matter is within Quraysh. As long as they implemented the Deen, if anyone were hostile to them, Allah would throw him on his face.” And what Al-Bukhari narrated on the authority of Ibnu ‘Umar that He said: The Messenger of Allah (pbuh) said:
“Bu ish ikkitagina qolgan taqdirda ham Quraysh ichida bo‘lib qoladi” — bu va boshqa hadislar, ishonchli sanadga ega bo‘lib, Allohning Elchisi ﷺ dan rivoyat qilingan, hokimiyat Quraysh qavmi orasida bo‘lishi haqida; ular xabar berish shaklida kelgan, amr shaklida emas. Hech bir hadis buyruq bermaydi, garchi so‘rov ma’nosini ifodalasa ham. Bunday so‘rov esa qat’iy buyruq emas, chunki uni shunday deb belgilaydigan dalil yo‘q. Hech bir hadisga uni qat’iy buyruqqa aylantiradigan qarina (ishora-belgi) bog‘lanmagan, bu esa u mandub (mustahab) ekanini, vojib emasligini ko‘rsatadi. Demak, bu afzallik sharti bo‘lib, shartnoma shartidir emas. Allohning Elchisi ﷺ ning quyidagi so‘zlariga kelsak:
“This matter would still be within Quraysh even if only two of them remained.” These and other Ahadith, proved sound and related to the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) that the authority is amongst the people of Quraysh, they have actually come in an informative form and not an imperative one. Not one Hadith actually carries a command even though they carry a request. Such a request, however, is not a conclusive command because there is no evidence to qualify them for this. No Hadith has been linked to any connotation (Qareena) that makes it a conclusive command, which indicates that it is Mandub (desirable) and not obligatory. It is, therefore a condition of preference and not a contractual condition. As for Allah’s Messenger (pbuh) saying:
"Agar kimdir ularga dushman bo'lsa, Alloh uni yuzi bilan yiqitib tashlaydi." Bu ularga dushman bo'lishning man etilganini bildiradi, uning (ﷺ) ... ga bo'lgan (qilgan) so'ziga tasdiq emasligini bildiradi.
“if anyone were hostile to them, Allah would throw him on his face.” This indicates prohibition of being hostile to them and not confirmation to his saying:
«bu ish Quraysh ichidadir», deb aytilgan. Hadisda ushbu ish (hukmronlik) ular ichida ekani aytiladi, so‘ngra ularga qarshi chiqishni taqiqlanadi. Bundan tashqari, «Quraysh» so‘zi ism bo‘lib, sifat emas. Shariat istilohida u laqab sifatida ma’lum. Laqabdan kelib chiqadigan ma’no hech qachon e’tiborga olinmaydi, chunki laqabning ma’nosi (mafhumi) umuman yo‘q. Shuning uchun Quraysh nomining zikr qilinishi hukmronlik mansabi Qurayshdan boshqaga tegishli bo‘lishi mumkin emasligini anglatmaydi. Shunday ekan, Allohning Elchisi ﷺ: «Albatta, bu ish Quraysh ichidadir...» deganlarida va ﷺ ularning so‘zlari:
“this matter is within Quraysh.” The Hadith says that the matter (ruling) is within them, and it then proceeds to forbid hostility to them. Besides, the word Quraysh is a name and not a description. In Shari’ah terminology it is known as a title. And the meaning derived from the title is never considered, because the title has no meaning (Mafhoom) at all. Therefore, the mention of Quraysh does not mean that the position of ruling cannot belong to other than Quraysh. So when Allah’s Messenger (pbuh) said: “Verily this matter is within Quraysh...” and his saying:
“Bu masala hali ham Quraysh ichida bo‘ladi...” U zot ﷺ bu hukmning Quraysh dan boshqalarda bo‘lishi noto‘g‘ri, degani emas edi. U zot ﷺ bu hukmning Quraysh ichida bo‘lishini, shuningdek, Qurayshdan bo‘lmagan boshqalarning qo‘lida bo‘lishi ham joiz ekanini nazarda tutgan edilar. Demak, hukmdorlikni Quraysh ahliga xos qilib qo‘yish, boshqalarning hukmdor bo‘lishi joiz emas degani emas. Shunday ekan, bu afzallik sharti bo‘lib, shartnoma sharti emas.
“This matter would still be within Quraysh...” He (pbuh) did not mean that it is wrong for it (the ruling) to be in other than Quraysh. He (pbuh) meant that it is within Quraysh and, as well, it is valid to be in the hands of others who are not from Quraysh. Thus specifying the people of Quraysh as rulers does not necessarily mean that others are not valid to rule. Therefore, it is a condition of preference and not a contractual condition.
Darhaqiqat, Rasulullah ﷺ 'Abdulloh ibn Ruvohah, Zayd ibn Horis va Usoma ibn Zayd ni hokimiyat lavozimlariga tayinladilar, va bu uch kishining hech biri Quraysh qabilasidan emas edi. Shunday qilib, Rasulullah ﷺ Quraysh dan bo'lmagan kishilarni ham hukmronlik lavozimlariga tayinlagan edilar. Bu iborada "bu ish" (amr) so'zi hokimiyatni, ya'ni hukmronlik qilish vakolatini anglatadi va bu faqat Xilofat lavozimiga taalluqli emas. Rasulullah ﷺ ning Quraysh dan tashqaridagi kishilarni hokimiyat lavozimlariga tayinlagani shuni ko'rsatadiki, hokimiyat faqat Quraysh xalqi bilan cheklanmagan va boshqalardan man etilmagan. Shu sababli, hadislarda Xilofat lavozimiga loyiq bo'lgan ba'zi kishilar zikr qilingan — bu ularning afzalligini bildirish uchun, lekin bu lavozimning faqat ular uchun xos ekanini yoki boshqalar uchun man etilganini ko'rsatmaydi.
Indeed the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) appointed ‘Abdullah Ibn Ruwahah, Zayd Ibnu Harith and Usama Ibnu Zayd to positions of authority and all three were not from Quraysh. Thus the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) did appoint people from other than Quraysh to positions of ruling. In this phrase “this matter” (Amr), means the authority, i.e. the authority to rule, and this does not only apply to the post of Khilafah. The fact that the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) did appoint people from outside Quraysh in posts of authority indicates that authority is not exclusively confined to the people of Quraysh, and prevented from others. Therefore, the Ahadith have mentioned some of the people who are worthy of the Khilafah post, to indicate their preference and do not indicate that it is exclusively confined to them or prohibited for other than them.
Xalifa Hoshimiy yoki Alaviy bo'lishi shart emas, chunki Allah Elchisi ﷺ Banu Hoshim va Banu Aliydan bo'lmagan kishilarni ham mas'ul lavozimlarga tayinlaganlar. Tabuk tomon chiqqanlarida Muhammad ibn Maslamani Madina ustiga vali qilib tayinlaganlar, u esa na Hoshimiy, na Alaviy edi. Shuningdek, Yaman ustiga Mu'az ibn Jabal va Amr ibnul-As ﷺ ni tayinlaganlar, ularning ikkalasi ham Hoshimiy yoki Alaviy emas edi. Bundan tashqari, musulmonlar Abu Bakr, Umar va Uysmonga bay'a berganliklari va Aliy ham ularning uchovlariga bay'a berganligi aniq isbotlangan, holbuki ular Banu Hoshimdan emas edilar. Sahoba ularga bay'a berishga e'tiroz bildirmagan va ular Hoshimiy yoki Alaviy emasliklari sababli ularga bay'a berishga biror kishi e'tiroz bildirgani rivoyat qilinmagan. Bu, Aliy, Ibn Abbos va Banu Hoshimning butun oilasi ham kiradigan sahobalarning ijmosi (Ijmo') hisoblanadi: xalifa Hoshimiy yoki Alaviydan boshqa kishi bo'lishi mumkin. Aliy va Allah Elchisi ﷺ ahli baytining afzalligini bildiruvchi hadislarga kelsak, ular xalifalik faqat ularga berilishi mumkin degani emas, balki ular bunga ko'proq loyiqdir, degan ma'noni bildiradi.
The Khaleefah does not also have to be Hashemi or ‘Alawi because the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) appointed people who were not from Banu Hashim nor from Banu ‘Ali to positions of authority. When He (pbuh) went out to Tabuk, He appointed Muhammad Ibnu Maslama as Wali over Madina and He was neither a Hashemi nor ‘Alawi. He (pbuh) also appointed Mu’az Ibnu Jabal and ‘Amru Ibn al-‘A‘as over Yemen, neither were of the Hashemi or ‘Alawi. In any case, it has been definitely proven that the Muslims gave the Bay’ah to Abu Bakr, ‘Umar and ‘Uthman, and that ‘Ali gave the Bay’ah to the three of them despite the fact that they were not from Banu Hashim. The Sahabah did not object giving the Bay’ah to them, and it was not reported that anyone had actually objected giving Bay’ah to them, because they were not Hashemites or ‘Alawis. This is considered a consensus of the Sahabah, (Ijmaa’) including ‘Ali and Ibnu Abbas and Banu Hashim’s entire household, that the Khaleefah could be from other than a Hashemi or an ‘Alawi. As for the Ahadith expressing a preference of ‘Ali and the Messenger of Allah’s household, these do not indicate that the Khilafah can’t be contracted except to them, they rather indicate that they are more favourable to it.
Yuqoridagilardan aniq ko'rinadiki, yuqorida bayon etilgan yetti shartdan tashqari boshqa shartnoma shartlari mavjudligini bildiruvchi hech qanday dalil yo'q. Agar boshqa har qanday shart ifodalovchi matn sahih ekani isbotlangan bo'lsa yoki bunday shart sahih matndan chiqarilgan hukm (Hukm) doirasiga kirgan bo'lsa, u shartnoma sharti emas, balki afzallik sharti hisoblanadi. Shari'at qonunlariga ko'ra, Xalifalikni Xalifaga shartnoma orqali topshirish uchun zarur bo'lgan narsa shartnoma shartidir. Bundan tashqari, nomzodlar musulmonlarga taqdim etilganda ularga bu haqda xabar beriladi, shunda ular o'zlari afzal ko'rgan kishini saylashlari mumkin. Musulmonlar tanlagan har qanday erkak, shartnoma shartlari bajarilgan taqdirda, boshqa shartlardan qat'i nazar, Xalifa etib tayinlanadi.
The above clearly indicates that there is no evidence whatsoever stating that there are other contractual conditions apart from the seven previously outlined. Any other condition constitutes a condition of preference and not a contractual one if the text expressing such a condition has been proven genuine or such a condition has come under a rule (Hukm) derived from a sound text. Under Shari’ah law, what is required is the contractual condition for the Khilafah to be contracted to the Khaleefah. Apart from this, the Muslims will be told about it when the candidates are presented to them, so that they can elect the one whom they prefer. Any man whom the Muslims choose would be appointed Khaleefah if the contractual conditions were fulfilled regardless of the other conditions.