11.9 Mamlaka za lazima za qadhi wa Mazaalim
11.9 The mandatory powers of the Mazaalim judge
Qāḍī al-Maẓālim ana mamlaka ya lazima ya kumwondoa mtawala yeyote au mtumishi yeyote wa umma, na pia ana haki ya kumwondoa Khalifa.
The Qadhi al-Mazaalim has the mandatory power to remove any ruler or civil servant, and He also has the right to remove the Khaleefah.
Mahakama ya Mazalim (Qadhi al-Mazaalim) ina haki ya kuwaondoa watawala, kwani mtawala huteuliwa kwa mkataba unaojulikana kama mkataba wa kukabidhi madaraka, ambao pia huitwa mkataba wa uteuzi (Taqleed). Khalifa ana haki ya Wilaya, yaani utawala, na pia ana haki ya kuteua, ambayo ni kukabidhi madaraka, na uteuzi unaweza kufanywa tu kwa maneno yaliyo wazi. Kwa hiyo kumwondoa mtawala aliyeteuliwa na Khalifa ni kuvunja mkataba huo, na Khalifa bila shaka anahifadhi haki hiyo. Hii ni kwa sababu Mtume wa Allah ﷺ aliwateua Wali na kuwaondoa. Makhalifa Waongofu pia waliwateua Wali na kuwaondoa; Khalifa pia angeweza kuwapa wale aliowateua haki ya kuteua na kuondoa. Hata hivyo, mahakama ya Mazalim haina haki ya kuwaondoa watawala kwa niaba ya Khalifa, kwani haitendi kwa niaba yake katika uteuzi na kuondoa. Badala yake inatenda kwa niaba yake katika kuchunguza madhulumu (Mazalim). Kwa hiyo, ikiwa kuwepo kwa mtawala huyo katika wilaya yake ni dhulma, mahakama ina haki ya kuiondoa dhulma hiyo, yaani ina haki ya kumwondoa mtawala huyo madarakani. Basi uwezo wake wa kumwondoa mtawala hautekelezwi kwa niaba ya Khalifa, bali ni kwa ajili ya kuondoa dhulma tu. Hivyo, yule ambaye mahakama inamhukumu kuondolewa, lazima aondolewe, hata kama Khalifa hakubaliani na hukumu hiyo. Hii ni kwa sababu kumwondoa mtawala huyo ni kuondoa dhulma, na hili linamhusu kila mtu, pamoja na Khalifa, kwa kuwa hukumu ya hakimu inawahusu wote. Kuhusu uwezo wake wa kumwondoa Khalifa, nao pia ni kwa hukumu inayolenga kuondoa dhulma. Kwa sababu ikiwa Khalifa yuko katika hali inayohitaji aondolewe, au katika hali ambayo kwa sababu yake anapaswa kuondolewa, basi kubaki kwake madarakani kutakuwa ni dhulma. Ni mahakama ya Mazalim inayohukumu kuondolewa kwa madhulumu, kwa hiyo itaamuru aondolewe. Kwa hiyo, hukumu ya mahakama ya Mazaalim ya kumwondoa Khalifa itakuwa hukumu inayolenga kuondoa dhulma.
The Qadhi al-Mazaalim has the right to remove the rulers, for the ruler is appointed by a contract, known as the contract of assignment which is also called the contract of appointment (Taqleed). The Khaleefah has the right of the Wilayah that is the ruling, and He has the right of appointment, which is the assignment, and the appointment can only be done with clear wording. Thus the removal of the ruler appointed by the Khaleefah would be a termination of that contract, and the Khaleefah undoubtedly reserves that right. This is because the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) appointed the Wulah and removed them. The Khulafaa’ Ar-Rashidoon also appointed the Wulah and removed them; the Khaleefah could also delegate to those whom He appointed the right to appoint and remove. However, the court of Mazaalim does not have the right to remove the rulers on behalf of the Khaleefah, for it does not act on his behalf in appointing and removal. it rather acts on his behalf in looking into the Mazaalim. So if the presence of that ruler in his Wilayah was a Mazlema, the court has the right to remove that Mazlema i.e. it has the right to remove that ruler from office. Therefore, its power to remove the ruler is not done on behalf of the Khaleefah, but merely to remove the Mazlema. So the one whom it judges to be removed should be removed, even if the Khaleefah does not agree with the judgement. This is because the removal of that ruler would be the removal of a Mazlema, and this applies to everyone, including the Khaleefah, for the judgement of the judge applies to everyone. As for its power to remove the Khaleefah, this would also be by a judgement aimed at removing a Mazlema. This is because if the Khaleefah were in a situation that necessitates his removal, or in a situation as a result of which He should be removed, then his stay in office would be a Mazlema. It is the court of Mazaalim that judges the removal of Mazaalim, so it would order his removal. Therefore, the judgement of the court of Mazaalim to remove the Khaleefah would be a judgement aimed at removing a Mazlema.
Mahakama ya Mazaalim ina mamlaka ya kuchunguza Mazlema yoyote, iwe Mazlema hayo yamefanywa na watumishi wa serikali, au yanahusiana na kwenda kinyume cha Shar’a na Khaleefah, au yanahusiana na maana ya maandishi ya kisheria katika katiba, kanuni, au kanuni mbalimbali za Shari’ah zilizopitishwa na Khaleefah, au yanahusiana na kutozwa kodi, au jambo lingine lolote.
The court of Mazaalim has the power to look into any Mazlema, whether the Mazlema were perpetrated by government employees, or related to a contradiction of the Shar’a by the Khaleefah, or related to the meaning of a legislative text in the constitution, the canons or the various Shari’ah rules adopted by the Khaleefah, or related to the imposing of a tax, or any other matter.
Hii ni kwa sababu Mjumbe wa Allah ﷺ alikataa kupanga bei pale Masahaba walipomwomba afanye hivyo baada ya bei kupanda, na alichukulia upangaji wa bei kuwa ni dhulma. Pia alichukulia mipango haramu ya upatikanaji wa umwagiliaji wa watu kuwa ni dhulma. Hii inathibitisha kwamba iwapo kitendo cha mtawala kinapingana na haki (Haqq), au kinakiuka kanuni za Shari'ah, kitazingatiwa kuwa ni dhulma. Mjumbe wa Allah ﷺ alikuwa mtawala juu ya Waislamu na Mkuu wao wa Dola.
This is because the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) refused to fix the prices when the Sahabah requested Him to do so after the prices had soared, and He (pbuh) considered price fixing as a Mazlema. He (pbuh) also considered the illegal arrangements of the peoples’ access to irrigation as a Mazlema. This proves that if the action of the ruler contradicted the truth (Haqq), or violated the Shari’ah rules, it would be considered a Mazlema. The Messenger of Allah (pbuh) was a ruler over the Muslims and their Head of State.
Zaidi ya hayo, ikiwa kitendo chochote kilicho sehemu ya shughuli za serikali, kinachofanywa na mjumbe yeyote wa serikali, kilipingana na haki (Haqq), au kilikiuka kanuni za Shari'ah, kitahesabiwa kuwa ni Mazlema. Hii ni kwa sababu mtu huyo angekuwa mwakilishi wa Khaleefah, akitenda kwa niaba yake katika kazi aliyopewa ndani ya muundo wa serikali.
Furthermore, if any action that is part of government business, performed by any member of the government, was in contradiction with the truth (Haqq), or if it violated the Shari’ah rules, it would be considered a Mazlema. This is because that person would be representative to the Khaleefah, acting on his behalf in the task assigned to Him in the government structure.
Kwa hiyo, Hadith kuhusu bei inaonyesha kwamba kosa linalofanywa na Khalifa ni Mazlema, na ni mahakama ya haki ndiyo yenye mamlaka ya kuchunguza Mazaalim. Kuhusu kuchunguza maandishi katika katiba au kanuni, katiba ni sheria ya msingi na kanuni ni amri ya Sultani. Kwa hiyo, kuchunguza hilo ni kuchunguza amri ya Sultani, jambo ambalo pia limo ndani ya Hadith kuhusu bei, kwani ni sawa na kuchunguza matendo ya Khalifa. Zaidi ya hayo, Allah (SWT) anasema: "Mkikhitalifiana katika jambo lolote, lirudisheni kwa Allah na Mtume" [TMQ An-Nisa’a: 59].
Therefore, the Hadith about pricing indicates that the offence committed by the Khaleefah is a Mazlema, and it is the court of justice that has the power to look into the Mazaalim. With regards to examining a text in the constitution or the canon, the constitution is the basic law and the canon is the decree of the Sultan. So examining that is examining the decree of the Sultan, which is also included in the Hadith about pricing, for it would be like examining the Khaleefah’s actions. Furthermore, Allah (swt) says; “If you dispute about something refer it to Allah and the Messenger” [TMQ An- Nisa’a: 59],
yaani ikiwa ulibishana na wenye mamlaka juu ya jambo fulani. Ikiwa mzozo huu ungehusu kifungu katika katiba au kifungu katika kanuni ya sheria, basi ungekuwa ni mzozo kati ya raia na wenye mamlaka juu ya kanuni ya Shari'ah, ambao lazima urejeshwe kwa Allah na Mtume Wake. Hii ingemaanisha kuupeleka mahakama ya Mazaalim, yaani kwa hukumu ya Allah na Mtume Wake ﷺ.
i.e. if you disputed with the people in authority about a matter. If this dispute were about an article in the constitution or an article in the canon of the law, then it would be a dispute between the subjects and those in authority on a rule of Shari’ah, which must be referred to Allah and His Messenger. This would mean referring it to the court of Mazaalim, i.e. to the judgement of Allah and His Messenger (pbuh).
Kuhusu mamlaka ya lazima aliyopewa hakimu wa Mazaalim ya kuchunguza suala la kuwekwa kwa kodi, hii inatokana na Hadithi ya Mtume wa Allah ﷺ aliposema: "Na natumai kukutana na Allah Azza wa-Jall bila kuwa na mtu yeyote anayedai dhulma dhidi yangu, iwe ya damu au ya mali." Ikiwa Khalifa atachukua fedha kutoka kwa raia kinyume cha sheria, hilo litakuwa dhulma; na kuchukua fedha kutoka kwa raia ambazo Shari'a haijaziidhinisha ni dhulma. Kwa hiyo, mahakama ya Mazaalim ina haki ya kuchunguza kodi, kwa kuwa ni fedha zinazochukuliwa kutoka kwa raia. Uchunguzi wake wa mambo ya kodi utalenga kuamua kama kodi hiyo imewekwa kisheria na Shari'a juu ya Waislamu, kama fedha zinazochukuliwa kulisha wahitaji, ambazo hazitakuwa dhulma; au kama kodi hiyo haijawekwa na Shari'a, kama fedha zinazochukuliwa kujenga bwawa ambalo si la lazima, ambalo basi litakuwa dhulma inayopaswa kuondolewa. Hii ndiyo sababu mahakama ya Mazaalim ina mamlaka ya kuchunguza kodi.
As for the mandatory power given to the judge of Mazaalim to look into the imposing of a tax, this is derived from the Hadith of the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) where He said; “And I hope to meet Allah Azza wa-Jall without having anyone claiming a Mazlema against me, whether in blood or money.” If the Khaleefah took money from the subjects unlawfully, it would be a Mazlema; and taking money from the subjects that is not approved by the Shar’a is a Mazlema. Therefore, the court of Mazaalim has the right to investigate taxes for it is money taken from the subjects. Its investigation of tax affairs would be with the aim of ruling whether that tax is lawfully obliged by Shar’a on the Muslims, such as the money taken to feed the needy, which would not be a Mazlema; or whether that tax is not obliged by the Shar’a, such as the monies taken to build a dam that is not considered essential, which would therefore be a Mazlema that has to be removed. This is why the court of Mazaalim has the power to examine the taxes.
Katika mahakama ya Mazaalim, kuketi kwa mahakama ni jambo la hiari, na kumwita mshtakiwa si lazima, wala uwepo wa mlalamikaji si lazima. Mahakama ya Mazaalim ina haki ya kuchunguza Mazlema hata kama hakuna mtu aliyewasilisha dai. Hili linahusu Mazlema yoyote inayohusiana na watu walio katika muundo wa serikali, ukiukwaji wa Khaleefah wa hukumu za Shari'ah, maana ya maandishi yoyote ya kisheria, katiba au kanuni zilizopitishwa na Khaleefah, kutozwa kwa kodi yoyote, au inayohusiana na dhuluma ya Dola kwa raia wake na kuwanyang'anya mali kwa nguvu, ukiukaji wake katika mali zilizokusanywa kutoka kwao, au kupunguza mishahara ya wafanyakazi na jeshi au kuchelewesha malipo yao.
In the judiciary of Mazaalim, the court sitting is optional, and the summons of the defendant is not necessary, nor is the presence of a plaintiff. The court of Mazaalim has the right to look into a Mazlema even if nobody filed a claim. This is with regards to any Mazlema related to the people in the government structure, the Khaleefah’s violation of the Shari’ah rules, the meaning of any legislative text, the constitution or the canons adopted by the Khaleefah, the imposing of any tax, or related to the State’s oppression of its citizens and seizure (properties) from them by force, its transgression in terms of the collected properties (from them) or reducing the salaries of the employees and the army or delaying their payment.
Hii ni kwa sababu ushahidi unaothibitisha haja ya mahakama ya kawaida kuchunguza kesi hauhusu mahakama ya Mazaalim, kwani si lazima kila wakati kuwepo mlalamikaji. Mahakama ya Mazaalim huchunguza dhulma hata kama hakuna aliyewasilisha dai. Pia si lazima kumwita mshtakiwa, kwa sababu hu-chunguza dhulma bila kuhitaji kuwepo kwake. Kwa hiyo ushahidi kuhusu umuhimu wa mahakama ya kawaida hauhusiani nayo. Hili linatokana na yale aliyoyapokea Abu Dawood na Ahmad kutoka kwa ‘Abdullah bin Az-Zubair, aliyesema: “Mtume wa Allah ﷺ aliamuru wale wadai wawili waketi mbele ya hakimu”, na kauli yake ﷺ kwa Ali (rta): “Ikiwa wadai wawili wameketi mbele yako.” Kwa hiyo mahakama ya Mazaalim ina haki ya kuchunguza dhulma inapotokea, bila vikwazo vya muda, mahali au kikao cha mahakama. Hata hivyo, kwa sababu ya hadhi ya mahakama hii na mamlaka yake ya lazima, daima imezungukwa na mambo ya heshima na ukuu. Katika zama za Masultani wa Misri na Ash-Sham, Baraza la Sultani, ambamo Mazaalim zilishughulikiwa, lilijulikana kama Dar al-’Adl (Nyumba ya Haki). Sultani alikuwa akiteua manaibu wa kumwakilisha, na Qudhah (Majaji) pamoja na Fuqahah (Wanazuoni wa fiqhi) pia walikuwa wakihudhuria. Al-Maqreezi alitaja katika kitabu chake kiitwacho Al-Sulook Ila Ma’arifati Douwal Al-Mulook (Njia ya Kujua Hali za Wafalme), kwamba Sultani Al-Malik Al-Salih Ayyub aliwateua manaibu wa kumwakilisha katika Dar al-Adal. Walikuwa wakiketi huko ili kuondoa dhulma, na kuwakusanya mashahidi, Qudhah na Fuqahah. Kwa hiyo hakuna ubaya mahakama ya Mazaalim ikiwa na jengo la kifahari, kwani hilo ni Mubah, hasa ikiwa linaonyesha nguvu ya haki.
This is because the evidence that confirms the need for a judicial court to look into a case does not apply to the court of Mazaalim for it is not always necessary to have a plaintiff. The court of Mazaalim looks into the Mazlema even if nobody filed a claim. It is also not necessary to summon the defendant, because it examines the Mazlema, without the need of his attendance. Therefore, the evidence regarding the necessity of a judicial court does not apply. This is due to what Abu Dawood and Ahmed narrated from ‘Abdullah bin Az-Zubair, He said; “The Messenger of Allah (pbuh) ordered that ‘the two disputing parties sit before the judge”, and his (pbuh) saying to Ali (rta); “If the two disputing parties sat before you.” Therefore, the court of Mazaalim reserves the right to look into the Mazlema as it occurs without any restrictions such as time, place or court sitting. However, due to the standing of this court, as far as its mandatory power are concerned, it has always been surrounded by the elements of prestige and grandeur. In the times of the Sultans in Egypt and Ash-Sham, the Council of the Sultan, where the Mazaalim used to be dealt with, used to be known as the Dar al-’Adl (House of Justice), where the Sultan used to appoint deputies to act on his behalf, and the Qudhah (Judges) and the Fuqahah (Jurists) also used to attend. Al-Maqreezi mentioned in his book entitled, Al-Sulook Ila Ma’arifati Douwal Al-Mulook (The way to know the States of the kings), that the Sultan Al-Malik Al-Salih Ayyub appointed deputies to act on his behalf in the Dar al-Adal. They used to sit there to remove the Mazaalim, and to gather the witnesses, Qudhah and the Fuqahah. Therefore, there is no harm if the court of Mazaalim had a splendid house, for this would be Mubah, especially if this reflected the might of justice.