Jagoranci a Musulunci guda ɗaya ne, ba na gama-gari ba
6 Leadership in Islam is singular and not collectivey
Shugabanci, shugaba da Imarah duk suna da ma'ana ɗaya. Haka kuma sarki (jagora), shugaban ƙasa da Amir suna da ma'ana ɗaya. To sai dai, Khilafah, duk da cewa ita ce jagoranci gabaɗaya na dukkan Musulmai a duniya, ta fi takamaimai fiye da Imarah, kuma Khaleefah ya fi takamaimai fiye da Ameer. Wannan saboda Imarah na iya zama Khilafah, ko kuma wani abu daban da Khilafah, kamar Imarah ta runduna, Imarah ta Wilayah, da Imarah ta ƙungiya. Don haka Imarah ta fi Khilafah faɗi. Ameer kuwa yana iya zama Khaleefah, ko Ameer na Wilayah, ko Ameer na runduna, ko Ameer na ƙungiya, ko Ameer na tafiya. Saboda haka Ameer ya fi Khaleefah faɗi. Don haka kalmar Khilafah tana nufin sanannen matsayi ne, yayin da kalmar Imarah kuma tana nufin gabaɗaya ga kowane Ameer.
Leadership, presidency and Imarah (emirate) are all of the same meaning. The leader, president and Ameer have the same meaning as well. However, the Khilafah, though it is a general leadership of all the Muslims in the world, is more specific than emirate (Imarah) and the Khaleefah is more specific than the Ameer. This is because the emirate can be the Khilafah and other than the Khilafah, like the emirate of an army and the emirate of the Wilayah and the emirate of the group. Thus the emirate is more general than the Khilafah. The Ameer could be the Khaleefah, the Ameer of a Wilayah, an Ameer of an army, an Ameer of a group, or an Ameer of travel. Hence, the Ameer is more general than the Khaleefah. Thus the word Khilafah is specific to the well-known post, while the word emirate is general for every Ameer.
Musulunci ya wajabta cewa shugaba, shugaban kasa da Amir su zama mutum ɗaya, a kan abu ɗaya, kuma bai halatta a sami fiye da mutum ɗaya a wuri ɗaya ba. Saboda haka, Musulunci ba ya amincewa da abin da ake kira jagoranci na gama-gari, kuma ba ya amincewa da shugabancin gama-gari, face dai jagoranci a Musulunci guda ɗaya ne kawai. Don haka shugaba, shugaban kasa da Amir dole ne su zama mutum ɗaya, kuma ba a halatta ya zama fiye da mutum ɗaya ba. Hujjar wannan al'amari ita ce hadisai da aikin Annabi ﷺ. Ahmad ya ruwaito daga Abdullahi ɗan Amr, cewa Manzon Allah ﷺ ya ce:
Islam obliges that the leader, the president and the Ameer be one person, over the same matter and it does not allow that there should be more than one person in the same post. Therefore, Islam does not recognise what is called the collective leadership and does not recognise the collective presidency, rather the leadership in Islam is solely singular. So the leader, the president and the Ameer must be singular, and it is not allowed to be more than one person. The evidence on this matter is the traditions and actions of the Prophet (pbuh). Ahmad narrated on the authority of ‘Abdullah ibn ‘Umru that the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) said:
"Ba a halatta ga mutum uku a wani fili mai buɗe ba, sai sun naɗa ɗaya daga cikinsu ya zama Ameer a kansu." Abu Dawood ya ruwaito daga Abi Sa'id cewa Manzon Allah ﷺ ya ce:
“It is not allowed for three persons in an open land without appointing one of them as an Ameer over them.” Abu Dawood narrated from Abi Sa’id that the Messenger of Allah said:
"Idan mutum uku suka fita tafiya, to bari su naɗa ɗaya daga cikinsu a matsayin Ameer." Al-Bazzaar ya ruwaito daga hadisin ‘Umar ibn Al-Khattab cewa Annabi ﷺ ya ce: "Idan akwai mutum uku a tafiya, to bari su naɗa ɗaya (Ahad) daga cikinsu a matsayin Ameer." Dukkan waɗannan hadisai sun nuna cewa Ameer ya zama ɗaya, kamar yadda ake fahimta daga hadisan. "...Ba tare da naɗa ɗaya (Ahad) daga cikinsu a matsayin Ameer ba." "Bari su naɗa ɗaya daga cikinsu a matsayin Ameer." Kalmar ɗaya, ‘Ahad’, tana daidai da kalmar ‘wahid’, wadda ke nuna lamba ɗaya ba fiye da haka ba. Ana fahimtar wannan daga akasin ma’ana (Mafhoom ul-Mukhalafah). Mafhoom ul-Mukhalafah ga lamba da siffa (Wasf) ana iya aiki da shi ba tare da buƙatar nassi ba. Kamar yadda Allah (swt) ya ce:
“If three people went out on a journey, let them appoint one of them as an Ameer.” Al-Bazzaar narrated from the tradition of ‘Umar ibn Al-Khattab that the Prophet (pbuh) said: “If there are three persons in a journey, let them appoint one (Ahad) of them as an Ameer.” All these traditions state that the Ameer should be one, as understood from the Ahadith. “...Without appointing one (Ahad) of them as an Ameer.” “Let them appoint one of them as an Ameer.” The word one ‘Ahad’ is equivalent to the word ‘wahid’ which indicates the number one and not more. This is understood from the opposite meaning (Mafhoom ul- Mukhalafah). The Mafhoom ul-Mukhalafah for numbers and description (Wasf) can be acted upon without the need of text. As Allah (swt) says:
"Ka ce: Allah Ɗaya ne." [TMQ Al-Ikhlas: 1]
“Say: Allah is One.” [TMQ Al-Ikhlas: 1]
wanda ke nufin babu wani na biyu a gare shi. Mafhoomul-Mukhalafah (ma'anar sabanin abin da aka faɗa) ba ya ɓacewa sai dai idan akwai nassi da ya soke shi. Kamar faɗar Allah (SWT):
which means that there is not a second to him. Mafhoomul-Mukhalafah (the opposite concept) is not annulled unless there is a text that does so. Like the saying of Allah (swt):
"Kada ku tilasta ma bayinku mata yin karuwanci idan suna son yin aure." [TMQ An-Nur: 33]
“Don’t force your (servant) girls on prostitution if they (wanted) marriage.” [TMQ An-Nur: 33]
Mafhoom ul-Mukhalafah na wannan ayar yana nufin cewa idan ba su son aure, to ana tilasta su yin karuwanci. Amma faɗin Allah ya soke wannan Mafhoom ul-Mukhalafah:
The Mafhoom ul-Mukhalafah of this verse (Ayah) means that if they did not want marriage then they are forced into prostitution. But the saying of Allah annuls this Mafhoom ul-Mukhalafah:
"Kada ku kusanci zina, domin lalata ce kuma hanya ce mugunta." [TMQ Al- Isra: 32]
“Don’t come close to adultery, it is an abomination and an evil way.” [TMQ Al- Isra: 32]
Saboda haka, idan babu nassi da zai soke Mafhoom al-Mukhalafah, to wajibi ne a aiki da shi. Haka kuma, faɗin Allah (SWT):
Hence, if there is no text to nullify the Mafhoom al-Mukhalafah then it has to be acted upon. Similarly, the saying of Allah (swt):
"Mazinacin namiji da mazinaciya, ku bugi kowannensu bulala ɗari" [TMQ An-Nur: 2]
“The adulterer, male and female, strike every one of them with one hundred lashes” [TMQ An-Nur: 2]
Hukuncin bulala a cikin wannan aya an iyakance shi zuwa wani adadi, wato bulala ɗari. Kasancewar an ambaci wannan takamaiman adadi yana nufin ba a yarda a ƙara fiye da bulala ɗari ba. Saboda haka, faɗin Manzon Allah ﷺ a cikin waɗannan hadisai: "Su naɗa ɗaya daga cikinsu (Ahadahum) a matsayin Ameer", yana nuna ta hanyar Mafhoom ul-Mukhalafah cewa ba a yarda a naɗa fiye da Ameer ɗaya ba. Don haka sarautar Imarah, jagoranci da shugabanci na mutum ɗaya ne kawai, kuma ba a yarda da shi kwata-kwata, bisa ga nassi da ma'anar waɗannan hadisai, ya zama na fiye da mutum ɗaya ba. Wannan kuma aikin Manzon Allah ﷺ ya tabbatar da shi, domin a dukkan lokutan da ya naɗa Ameer, ya naɗa mutum ɗaya kawai, bai naɗa fiye da haka ba. Kuma ba ya taɓa naɗa fiye da mutum ɗaya a wuri guda ba kwata-kwata.
The lashing in this verse is limited to a certain number, which is one hundred lashes. The fact that it has given this specific number means that it is not allowed to increase over the hundred lashes. Therefore, the saying of the Messenger (pbuh) in these Ahadith; “Let them appoint one from them (Ahadahum) as an Ameer”, indicates by use of Mafhoom ul-Mukhalafah, that it is not allowed to appoint more than one Ameer. Thereupon the emirate (Imarah), leadership and presidency is for one person only, and it is not allowed absolutely, from the text and meaning of these Ahadith, to be for more than one person. This is also supported by the action of the Prophet (pbuh), as he, in all the situations in which He appointed an Ameer; He appointed only one person and no more. And He absolutely did not appoint more than one person in the same place.
Dangane da Hadisin da aka ruwaito daga Manzon Allah ﷺ cewa ya aika Mu'azu da Abu Musa zuwa Yaman, sai ya ce musu:
With regards to the Hadith narrated from the Messenger (pbuh) that He sent Mu’az and Abu Musa to Yemen, and He said to them:
"Ku sauƙaƙa, kada ku sa wahala; ku yi bushara, kada ku tsoratar; kuma ku yi haɗin kai da juna." A cikin wannan lamari Annabi ﷺ ya aika kowannensu zuwa wani yanki daban na Yemen, ba zuwa wuri ɗaya ba. Al-Bukhari ne ya rawaito wannan Hadisi cikin rubutu biyu dabam-dabam. A cikin ɗaya daga cikinsu ya bayyana cewa an aike su zuwa wurare biyu, inda ya ce:
“Make it easy and not difficult, give good tidings and not bad news, and co-operate with eachother.” In this incident the Prophet (pbuh) sent each one of them to a different part of the Yemen and not to the same place. This Hadith was narrated by Al-Bukhari in two different texts. In one of them He states that they were sent to two places, where He said:
“Musa ya ba mu labari cewa Abu ‘Owanah ya ruwaito cewa ‘Abdul Malik ya ruwaito daga Abi Burdah wanda ya ce: Manzon Allah ﷺ ya aika Abu Musa da Mu’az ibn Jabal zuwa Yemen, ya aika kowannensu zuwa lardi, sannan ya ce: ‘Yemen tana da wurare biyu.’ Sannan ya ce: ‘Ku sauƙaƙa, kada ku tsananta. Ku yi bushara, kada ku tsoratar.’ Kowannensu ya tafi wajen aikinsa…” Saboda haka, ba a yarda a sami shugabanni biyu a kan mas’ala ɗaya ba, kuma ba a yarda a sami shugabanni biyu a wuri ɗaya ba, illa dai shugaba, jagora da Ameer su zama ɗaya kawai, kuma an haramta a sami fiye da ɗaya.
“Musa narrated to us that Abu ‘Owanah narrated that ‘Abdul Malik narrated from Abi Burdah who said that the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) sent Abu Musa and Mu’az ibn Jabal to Yemen and He sent each of them to a province and said: ‘Yemen is of two places.’ Then He said ‘Make it easy not difficult. Give good news and not bad.’ Each one of them set out for his job…” Therefore, there must not be two chiefs for the same matter, nor two presidents for the same place, rather the president, the leader and Ameer must be only one and it is forbidden for there to be more than one.
Dangane da abin da ya yaɗu a ƙasashen Musulmi game da kafa shugabanci na gama-gari a cikin tsarin majalisa, ko kwamiti, ko ƙungiyar gudanarwa da makamantansu, waɗanda ke da ayyukan shugabanci, duk wannan ya saɓa wa hukuncin Allah, idan an ba ƙungiyar, ko majalisar, ko kwamitin shugabanci. Wannan saboda shugabanci zai zama an bai wa rukuni, kuma hakan haramun ne bisa nassosin Hadisai. Amma idan kwamitin, ko majalisar, ko ƙungiyar za ta gudanar da ayyuka, ko tattauna al'amura, ko yin shawara, to duk wannan halal ne kuma yana cikin Musulunci, domin an yabi Musulmi saboda shawara a tsakaninsu. Ra'ayin waɗannan kwamitoci za a yi la'akari da shi bisa hukuncin Shura da aka yi bayani a kansa a cikin wannan littafi.
In regards to what has spread in Muslims’ countries with regard to the establishment of a collective leadership in the form of a council, or a committee, or an administrative association and the like, that have the functions of leadership, all this disagrees with the divine rule, if leadership is given to the association, council or committee. This is because leadership would be given to a group, which is Haram according to the texts of the Ahadith. However, if the committee, the council or the association were to carry out tasks, or discuss matters and make consultation, then all this is allowed and is from Islam, because the Muslims are praised for having consultation amongst themselves. The opinion of these committees would be considered according to the Hukm of Shura explained in this book.