2.4.2.1 Mulk egaligi
2.4.2.1 Property Ownership
Siyosiy iqtisodiyotlarning, ehtimol, eng muhim xususiyati jamiyatda mulkchilikni belgilab beruvchi tizimdir. Xususiy mulkchilik kapitalizmning o'ziga xos belgisi sifatida tan olingan. Ishlab chiqarish vositalarining jamoat mulkiga aylanishi esa sotsializmning asosiy xususiyatidir. Islom siyosiy iqtisodiyoti mulkchilikning uchta shaklini tan oladi: xususiy mulkchilik, jamoat mulkchiligi va davlat mulkchiligi. Ushbu mulkchilik shakllarining har birining doirasi aniq belgilab qo'yilgan.
Perhaps the most outstanding feature of political economies is that which defines property ownership in the society. Private ownership was recognized as the distinctive feature of capitalism. Public ownership of the means of production is the main characteristic of socialism. The Islamic political economy recognizes three forms of ownership, namely, the private ownership, the public ownership, and the state ownership. The scope of each of these forms of ownership is exclusively defined.
Ushbu mulkchilik shakllarini tushuntirishdan oldin shuni qayd etish kerakki, na sotsializm, na kapitalizm mulkchilik ta'riflariga faqat o'zlari qat'iy rioya qila olmadi. Sovet Ittifoqidagi sotsialistik rahbarlar jamoat mulkchiligi haqidagi qat'iy qarashlarini yumshatishga va, ayniqsa, qishloq xo'jaligida cheklangan xususiy mulkchilikka yo'l ochishga majbur bo'ldilar. Xuddi shunday, Xitoy sotsialistlari ham ishlab chiqarish sanoatida cheklangan xususiy mulkchilikka ruxsat berdilar. Kapitalizm olamida esa turli sabablarga ko'ra xususiy mulkni milliylashtirish odatiy holga aylangan. Qo'shma Shtatlarda va ayrim Yevropa mamlakatlarida banklar, sug'urta kompaniyalari va avtomobil sanoatining davlat tomonidan egallanishi moliyaviy inqiroz va iqtisodiy muammolarga maqbul javobga aylandi. Sotsializm va kapitalizm g'oyalari hukmronlik qilayotgan dunyoda mulkchilik doirasini 31-rasmdagi diagrammada ko'rsatilgandek tasavvur qilish mumkin. Xususiy mulkchilikka asoslangan davlat iqtisodiyotlari o'z tizimlariga jamoat mulkchiligini qo'shib boradi; jamoat mulkchiligiga ega bo'lganlar esa xususiy mulkchilikni qo'shib boradi.
Before proceeding to explain these forms of ownership, it should be noted that neither socialism nor capitalism was able to exclusively stand by their definitions of ownership. The socialist rulers in the Soviet Union were forced to relax their strict view of public ownership and open the door for limited private ownership, especially in the farming industry. By the same token, the Chinese socialists have also allowed a limited private ownership in the manufacturing industry. Within the world of capitalism, nationalization of private property for different reasons is more than common. The government takeover of banks, insurance companies, and auto industries in the United States and some European countries has become an acceptable response to financial crisis and economic problems. The scope of property ownership in a world dominated by the ideas of socialism and capitalism can be visualized as shown in the diagram in figure 31. State economies based on private ownership end up adding public ownership to their systems; those with public property ownerships end up adding private ownerships.
Amaliyotda bu shuni ko'rsatadiki, eng optimal va barqaror siyosiy iqtisodiyotlar bir nechta mulkchilik shaklidan foydalanadigan iqtisodiyotlardir. Mulkchilikning to'g'ri nisbati hamda nima xususiy, nima esa jamoat mulki ekanligining doirasi sinab ko'rish va kutib ko'rish usuli bilan topilmaydi. Bu nisbat rasmiyroq ravishda belgilanishi kerak, shunda hosil bo'lgan siyosiy iqtisodiyot barqaror bo'lishi va kambag'alllik hamda ochlikni bartaraf etish kabi kerakli maqsadlarga olib kelishi mumkin.
Practically this shows that optimal and stable political economies are the ones that deploy more than one form of ownership. The proper mix of ownerships and the scope of what constitute a private and what makes a public ownership cannot be obtained through a trial-and-error, wait-and-see kind of process. This mix should be more formally defined so that the resulting political economy can be a stable one and can lead to the desired objectives of resolving poverty and hunger.

Mulkchilikning to‘g‘ri aralashmasini belgilab beradigan narsa jamiyatning qanday shakllanishi va turli mafkuralar tomonidan qanday qabul qilinishidir. Agar jamiyat alohida shaxslar guruhi sifatida qaralsa, u holda shaxslarning xususiy mulkini ta’kidlash va boshqa mulk turlarini qisman yoki butunlay istisno qilish tabiiydir. Agar jamiyat shaxslar faqat butunning qismlari sifatida qaraladigan yagona moddiy birlik sifatida qabul qilinsa, u holda jamiyatdagi jamoa mulkini ta’kidlash tabiiydir. Biroq, agar jamiyat aniq va mustaqil tarkibiy qismlardan tashkil topgan tuzilma sifatida qaralsa, mulkchilik turlari uning tarkibiy qismlarining xilma-xilligiga ko‘ra turlicha bo‘ladi.
What defines the proper mix of ownerships is the way the society is formed and viewed by different ideologies. If the society is perceived as being as a group of individuals, then it is natural to emphasize the private ownerships of individuals and to partially or completely exclude other ownerships. If the society is perceived to be as a single material unit with individuals being only as parts of the whole unit, then it is natural to emphasize the collective ownership in the society. However, if the society is perceived as a structure composed of distinct and independent components, then property ownerships will diverse according to the diversity of its components.
Islomiy nuqtai nazardan jamiyat tuzilishi shundayki, jamiyat uch alohida tarkibiy qismdan iborat. Har birining o'ziga xos ehtiyojlari bor, ular boshqalarining ehtiyojlaridan farq qiladi. Bu tarkibiy qismlarning birinchisi – muayyan instinktlar va biologik ehtiyojlarga ega bo'lgan alohida inson bo'lib, bu ehtiyojlar uzluksiz qondirilishi kerak. Jamiyatdagi har bir shaxsning oziq-ovqat, boshpana, sog'liq, dam olish, juftlik, ibodat va nasl qoldirishga bo'lgan o'z ehtiyojlari bor. Bu ehtiyojlarni qondirish uchun shaxs har birini qondirish uchun zarur bo'lgan vositalar va asboblarga egalik qilishi kerak. Vositalar va asboblar bir kishiga yoki butun jamoaga tegishli bo'lganda, ularga ega bo'lmagan boshqa kishining ehtiyojlari qondirilishiga kafolat bo'lmaydi. Masalan, agar John, Ali va Adamning har biri bittadan non ega bo'lsa, lekin Samda hech narsa bo'lmasa, u ochlikdan azob chekishi mumkin, John, Ali va Adam esa to'yib yurishadi. Xuddi shunday, to'rtta non John, Ali, Adam va Samning birgalikdagi mulki bo'lsa, ulardan biri ham och qolishi mumkin. Shaxsning asosiy ehtiyojlari qondirilishini kafolatlash uchun u bu ehtiyojlarni qondirish uchun zarur bo'lgan mahsulot va asboblarga egalik qila olishi kerak.
The Islamic view of society is such that the society has three distinct components. Each has its specific needs which are different form the needs of the other ones. The first of these components is the individual human being who possesses specific instincts and biological needs which need to be satisfied on a continuous basis. Each individual in the society has his own needs for food, shelter, health, rest, mating, worshiping, and breeding. In order to satisfy these needs, the individual must own the means and tools necessary to satisfy each of these needs. When the means and tools are owned by one person, or by the community at large, there will be no guarantee that the needs of another person who does not own them will be satisfied. For example, if John, Ali, and Adam each has a loaf of bread, but Sam does not have any, then Sam may go hungry while John, Ali, and Adam are full. By the same token, if four loaves of bread are collectively owned by John, Ali, Adam, and Sam, then it is possible that one of them can go hungry as well. To guarantee the satisfaction of the individual basic needs, the individual must be able to own the commodities and tools which are necessary to fulfill these needs.
Xususiy mulkchilik
Private Ownership
Kapitalistik mafkura hukmronlik qilayotgan dunyoda tovarlar, mahsulotlar va ishlab chiqarish vositalarining xususiy mulkchiligi mulkdorlikning odatiy me'yori hisoblanadi. Sotsializm doirasida esa xususiy mulkchilik me'yorga zid deb qaraladi. 1970-yillarning o'rtalarida Sovet Ittifoqida yashaganimda, hamkasblarimni xususiy mulkchilik inson uchun tabiiy xulq ekanligiga ishontirish menga qiyin kechdi. Islom kabi din tarafdori bo'lish ham oson emas edi, chunki u xususiy mulkka shunchalik kafolat beradiki, mulkka qarshi jinoyat uchun eng qattiq jazoni belgilaydi. Kapitalistik dunyodagi tajribam esa mutlaqo teskari edi: xususiy mulk odatiy holat, boshqacha narsa esa istisno edi.
In a world dominated by the capitalist ideology, the private ownership of commodities, goods, and means of production is the default norm of ownership. However, within the realm of socialism, private ownership is considered to be against the norm. When I lived in the Soviet Union in the mid-1970s, I had a hard time convincing my colleagues that private ownership was a normal human behavior. It was not easy to belong to a religion, like Islam, which protects private ownership to the extent that it invokes the harshest punishment against the crime against the private property ownership. My experience in the capitalist world was totally the opposite; private property was the norm, and anything else was the exception.
Sotsializmdan farqli o‘laroq, Islom insonning eng ichki xususiyatini tan oladi, bu xususiyat boylik orttirish va boylik yaratish vositalarini izlashga undaydi. Lekin u kapitalizmdan ham farq qiladi, chunki xususiy mulkchilik faoliyat ko‘rsatishi mumkin bo‘lgan doira va chegaralarni cheklaydi. Islom shaxsga Islomda taqiqlangan mahsulot hisoblanadigan narsalarni egallash yoki ishlab chiqarishga ruxsat bermaydi. Masalan, Islomga ko‘ra giyohvand moddalar, spirtli ichimliklar yoki kazinoni ishlab chiqarish yoki egalik qilish mumkin emas. Islom shuningdek, neft konlari, o‘rmonlar yoki daryolar kabi jamoat mulki hisoblangan mulkni shaxslarning egallashini ham cheklaydi.
Unlike socialism, Islam recognizes the innermost characteristic of a human which calls for the acquisition of wealth and the means to produce wealth. But it also differs with capitalism in the sense that it restricts the scope and the range in which private ownership is allowed to operate. Islam does not allow an individual to own or produce things which are categorized as prohibited goods in Islam. For example, it is not allowed under Islam to produce or own drugs, alcoholic drinks, or a casino. Islam also restricts individuals from acquiring property which is considered to be a public property such as oil fields, forests, or rivers.
Aslida, Islom insonning tabiiy xususiyatlarini tan oladi va xususiy mulkchilik insonning yashash instinktining tabiiy namoyonidir, deb e'tirof etadi. Shu bilan birga, u ayrim mulklar jamiyatning umumiy qo'lida qolishi kerakligini tan oladi, chunki shaxslarning boylik orttirish qobiliyatidagi farqlar tufayli yuzaga keladigan muvozanatsizlikning oldini olish lozim. Jamiyatda ayrim kishilarning boshqalarga qaraganda ko'proq ko'nikmaga ega bo'lishi, ba'zilarning boylik orttirishga kuchliroq intilishi yoki ba'zi kishilarning o'z ehtiyojlarini qondirish uchun yetarli boylik orttirishiga to'sqinlik qiladigan nogironlik yoki jismoniy nuqsonlarga ega bo'lishi odatiy holdir. Urushlar va ichki g'alayonlar, zilzila va tsunami kabi tabiiy ofatlar, qullik va kamsitish, siyosiy va iqtisodiy adolatsizlik kabi sharoitlar ham ba'zi kishilarning mulk jihatidan orqada qolishiga sabab bo'lishi mumkin.
Inson mehnati
Human Labor
Inson mehnati boylik orttirishning birinchi va eng asosiy vositasidir. Jismoniy yoki aqliy mehnat yordamida erkak yoki ayol o'zi uchun asl boylik yaratishi mumkin, bu boylik uning shaxsiy mulkiga aylanadi, qonun bilan himoyalanadi va davlat tomonidan ta'minlanadi. Rivoyat qilinishicha, Payg'ambar Muhammad ﷺ shunday degan: "Kim o'lik yerni obod qilsa, u o'shaniki bo'ladi."100 Payg'ambarning bu so'zi ilgari hech qanday shaklda foydalanilmagan va hech bir kishi tomonidan egalik qilinmagan, ekilmagan yalang yerga taalluqlidir. Yerni obod qilib, uni dehqonchilik yoki rivojlanish uchun foydali holatga keltirgan kishi o'sha yerning yagona egasiga aylanadi.
Human labor is the first and foremost means of wealth acquisition. Using physical or mental labor, a man or woman can create an original wealth which becomes his or her private property, protected by law and enforced by the state. It is reported that Prophet Mohammad (PBUH) had said, “Whoever cultivated a dead land, it becomes his.”100 This statement of the Prophet applies to bare land that has never been used in any form before and had not been owned by any people. By cultivating a piece of land and converting it into a useful piece for farming or development, one becomes the sole owner of the land.
Islom shuningdek shaxsga yer ostidan olinadigan narsalarni, masalan toshlar va marvaridlarni, dengizdan olinadigan narsalarni, masalan qimmatbaho dur-marvaridni, yoki havodan olinadigan narsalarni, masalan kislorod va azotni egalik qilishga ruxsat bergan. Istisno sifatida katta konlarda mavjud bo'lgan minerallar bundan mustasno, chunki bu minerallar jamoatning mulki ekani ma'lum. Xuddi shunday, qushlar, hayvonlar, baliqlar va boshqa dengiz mahsulotlarini ovlash orqali ham boylik orttirish mumkin. Qur'oni Karimda Mo'minlar (Ma'ida) surasining 96-oyatida shunday deyiladi: "Sizlar uchun dengiz ovi va uning taomi halol qilindi." Boshqa o'rinda esa Qur'on quruqlikdagi ovni ham egalik qilish vositasi sifatida zikr qiladi.102
Islam also allowed the individual to own what he can extract from beneath the ground such as stones and marbles, from the sea such as precious pearl,101 or from the air such as oxygen and nitrogen. An exception would be the minerals which exist in large mines since these minerals are known to be the property of the public. By the same token, wealth acquisition can be attained by hunting of birds, animals, fish, and other sea products. The Quran says in Surah Al-Mai’dah (chapter 5, verse 96), “Lawful to you is (the pursuit of) sea hunting and its use for food.” In another location, the Quran speaks of hunting on the land as a means of possession.102
Odamlar o'zlarining aqliy va jismoniy mehnatlarini savdo sheriklari o'rtasida qonuniy bitimlarni vositachilik qilish uchun ishlatishlari mumkin; shuni e'tiborga olish kerakki, savdogarlar asl boylikka egalik qiladilar, vositachi esa o'z mehnatidan foydalanib, shu boylikning bir qismiga egalik qiladi. Shuningdek, odamlar "Mudoraba" deb nomlanuvchi maxsus sherikchilik shaklida shug'ullanishlari mumkin. Bu shakl sherikchilikda bir tomon pulni ta'minlaydi, boshqa tomon esa faqat mehnatini taqdim etadi. Mehnati bilan ishtirok etgan kishi o'zi uchun boylik yaratadi. Bu turdagi sherikchilikni dehqonchilik uchun ham kengaytirish mumkin.
Meros
Inheritance
Ikkinchi mol-mulk orttirish vositasi — meros. Islomda meros — aniq belgilangan jarayon bo‘lib, vafot etgan kishining boyligi belgilangan tartib bo‘yicha farzandlar, ota-ona, turmush o‘rtog‘i, aka-ukalar va opa-singillar o‘rtasida taqsimlanadi. Islomdagi meros qoidalari mol-mulk egasi vafot etganidan keyin boylikni bo‘lish va taqsimlash imkonini beradi. Iqtisodiy o‘sish jarayonida boylik hayot davomida bir necha kishining qo‘lida to‘planib qolishi mumkin. Meros qoidalari aynan shu tendentsiyani to‘xtatish va boylikni bir necha kishi o‘rtasida qayta aylanishiga erishish uchun xizmat qiladi. Islomda merosning uchta alohida holati mavjud:
The second means of wealth acquisition is inheritance. Inheritance in Islam is a well-defined process, whereby the wealth of a deceased person is distributed among the children, parents, spouses, brothers, and sisters according to a certain formula. Inheritance rules in Islam allow the wealth to be broken and distributed after the death of the wealth owner. It is possible in the process of economic growth for wealth to accumulate in the hands of a few individuals during their life. The rules of inheritance are then used to break this tendency and cause the wealth to be recycled among several individuals. There are three distinct cases of inheritance in Islam:
1. Birinchi holat — merosxo'rlar meros qonunlariga ko'ra butun merosni oladigan holat bo'lib, bunda barcha boylik ular o'rtasida taqsimlanadi.
1. The first case is when the inheritors take the whole inheritance according to the laws of inheritance, whereby all the wealth is distributed amongst them.
Ikkinchi holat — merosxo'rlar meros mulkining faqat bir qismiga haqli bo'lgan holatdir. Masalan, marhum faqat turmush o'rtog'ini (er yoki xotinini) qoldirgan bo'lsa. Bunday hollarda meros mulkining faqat to'rtdan bir yoki yarmi meros qilib olinadi, qolgan meros esa davlat xazinasiga o'tadi.
The second case is when the inheritors are entitled for part of the 2. inheritance only. For example, the deceased leaves behind only the spouse (husband or wife). In these cases only a quarter or half of the wealth is inherited, while the rest of the inheritance goes to the state.
Uchinchi holat — merosxo'r qoldirilmagan holat: 3. bunday holatda butun mol-mulk davlat xazinasiga o'tadi.
The third case is when the deceased leaves no inheritor behind; in 3. this case the whole property goes to the state.
Shunday qilib, boylik bo‘linadi va mol-mulk merosxo‘rlarga o‘tadi; shu tariqa odamlar o‘rtasida mol-mulk almashinuvi iqtisodiy aylanma shaklida davom etadi. Mol-mulk biror kishining qo‘lida to‘planib qolmaydi, bunda boylik to‘planadi. Meros mol-mulkka egalik qilishning qonuniy yo‘li hisoblanadi, shuning uchun meros qilib biror narsa olgan kishi uni qonuniy ravishda egallaydi. Demak, meros Islom Shariati ruxsat bergan mol-mulkka egalik qilish vositalaridan biridir.
Kambag'allarga berilgan boylik
Wealth Provided to Poor
Garchi jamiyatni qashshoqlikdan xalos etish uchun barcha choralar ko'rilgan bo'lsa-da, turli sabablarga ko'ra ayrim kishilarning qashshoqlikka tushib qolishi kutiladi. Bunday kishilarning ehtiyojlariga javob berish maqsadida Islom davlatga o'z kuchi bilan ish topa olmagan kishilar uchun mos ish o'rinlari yaratib berishni tavsiya etgan. Payg'ambar ﷺ shunday degan: "Imom (davlat rahbari) cho'pondir va u o'z fuqarolari uchun mas'uldir."108 Ish kishilarga mehnatlari orqali boylik topish imkonini beradi. Agar bozor sharoitlari tufayli ish topish imkoni bo'lmasa yoki kishi yoshi, kasalligi yoki nogironligi sababli ishlay olmay qolsa, uning ta'minoti va nafaqasi o'g'illari, otasi va eri kabi yaqin qarindoshlarining burchi va mas'uliyatiga aylanadi, bu kishilar zarur yordamni ko'rsata oladigan bo'lsa. Bu masala islom fiqh kitoblarida "Nafaqa" (nafaqa to'lash) bobida bayon etilgan.
Despite all measures taken to relieve the society from poverty, it is expected that some individuals will end up in a state of poverty for all types of reasons. In order to attend for the needs of these individuals, Islam recommended the state to provide a suitable opportunity for the employment of those who could not find employment on their own. The Prophet (PBUH) said, “The Imam (head of state) is a Shepard, and he is responsible for his subjects.”108 Employment enables individuals to use their labor to acquire wealth. In case it is not possible to find a job due to market conditions, or the person becomes unable to work due to age, sickness, or disability, then his support and sustenance becomes the duty and responsibility of his next of kin such as sons, father, and husband assuming that these parties are able to provide the required support. This is outlined in the books of Islamic jurisprudence under the section of “Nafaqah” (alimony).
Agar yaqin qarindoshlar talab qilinadigan nafaqani ta'minlay olmasa, mas'uliyat davlatga yuklanadi. Davlat jamoat mulklaridan olinadigan daromadlar hamda zakot mablag'laridan foydalanadi. Zakot — boylarning mol-mulkidan ma'lum miqdorda olinib, kambag'allarga yetkaziladigan hissadir. Ma'arij surasi (70-sura, 24-25-oyatlar) va Tavba surasi (9-sura, 103-oyat)da Alloh shunday deydi:
If the immediate relatives are unable to maintain the required alimony, then responsibility is escalated up to the state. The state uses the funds available from the revenues of the public properties as well as from the Zakah. The Zakah is a specific amount of wealth taken out of the property of the rich and relayed to the poor. In Surah Al-Ma’arij (chapter 70, verse 24-25), and Al-Tauba (chapter 9, verse 103), Allah says,
[70:24] Va ular o'z mollarida ma'lum haq bor kishilardir; so'raydigan va mahrum bo'lgan (kambag'al) uchun.
Davlat grantlari
State Grants
Islom davlati jamiyatdagi odamlarga mehnat unumdorligini rag'batlantirish va ularning biznesini foydali bosqichga olib chiqishga yordam berish maqsadida grantlar berishi mumkin. Davlat rag'batlantiruvchi grantlarni berishda ham davlat mulkidan, ham jamoat mulkidan foydalanadi. Rivoyat qilinishicha, ikkinchi xalifa Umar ibn al-Xattob Iroqdagi dehqonlarga ularning yerlarini obodonlashtirishlari uchun rag'batlantiruvchi mablag' bergan. Bu yordam qarz shaklida emas, balki davlat granti shaklida berilgan.
The Islamic state is allowed to provide grants for people in the society for the purpose of stimulating productivity and enabling people to grow their business to a profitable stage. The state uses both state as well as public property to issue stimulus grants. It is narrated that the second caliph Omar Bin Al-Khattab provided stimulus money for the farmers in Iraq to help them cultivate their farms. The help was in a form of state grant, rather than loans.
Payg'ambar Muhammad ﷺ hijratdan keyin Abu Bakr va Umarga yer bergani rivoyat qilinadi. U shuningdek Az-Zubayrga ham bir qism yer bergan. Muhammad ﷺ vafotidan keyin xalifalar foydalanilmagan yalang yerlardan foydalanish maqsadida jamoat yerlarining bir qismini turli shaxslarga berishda davom etdilar. Shuni ta'kidlash lozimki, davlat yer grantlari uchun soliq pullarini yoki zakot mablag'larini ishlatmaydi. Davlat ishlatishga ruxsat etilgan yagona mablag' davlat yoki jamoat mulkidan kelib tushgan mablag'dir.
Prophet Mohammad is reported to have given land for Abu Bakr and Omar after the migration to Medina. He also gave a piece of land to Al-Zubair. After the death of Mohammad (PBUH), the caliphs continued to give part of the public lands to various individuals in an attempt to utilize unused bare land. It should be noted that the state does not use tax money or the funds of the Zakah for the grants. The only fund the state is allowed to use is the one that comes from the state or public property.
Ushbu mulk orttirish usullaridan tashqari, xadya va vafot etganlarning vasiyatlari kabi xususiy mulkchilikning boshqa usullari ham mavjud. Payg'ambar ﷺ xadya berishga ruxsat bergan va musulmonlardan ham, musulmon bo'lmaganlardan ham sovg'alar qabul qilgan. Shuningdek, Islom musulmonga o'z boyligining bir qismini vasiyat shaklida belgilashga ruxsat bergan, shunda vasiyat oluvchilar qonun bo'yicha meros oluvchilar qatorida bo'lmasligi kerak; vasiyat miqdori ham umumiy boylikning uchdan biridan oshmasligi kerak.111
Besides these means of property acquisition, there are other means of private ownership such as gifts and wills of deceased. Prophet Mohammad permitted gift giving110 and he accepted gifts from both Muslims and non-Muslims. Also, Islam allowed a Muslim to designate part of his wealth in form of a will such that the recipients of a will should not be among those who are entitled for inheritance by law; also the amount of will should not exceed one-third of the total wealth.111
Umumiy mulk
Public Property
Islom jamiyatni o'zining alohida ehtiyojlarga ega bo'lgan mustaqil bir mohiyat sifatida tan olgan. Bu ehtiyojlar alohida shaxslarning ehtiyojlarining yig'indisi emas, shuning uchun jamiyat ehtiyojlarini qondirish har bir shaxsning ehtiyojlarini qondirish orqali amalga oshirilishi mumkin emas. Jamiyatning xavfsizligi, hududining butunligi, havosi va muhitining tozaligi va pokligi, uning a'zolari o'rtasidagi birdamlik, dengizlar, daryolar va suv omborlarini asrash, shuningdek, boshqa xalqlar oldidagi obro'si — bularning barchasi shaxslarga emas, balki butun jamiyatga tegishli ehtiyojlardir. Jamiyatni jamiyat ichida yagona birlik sifatida saqlab qolish maqsadida Islom mulkning ma'lum turlarini belgilagan va ularni jamoat mulki deb e'lon qilgan.
Islam recognized the existence of public as an entity which has its own needs. These needs are not the sum of the needs of individuals, and therefore the satisfaction of the public needs cannot be achieved by satisfying the needs of each individual. The security of the public, the integrity of its territory, the cleanness and purity of its atmosphere and environment, the solidarity among its units, the preservation of the seas, river, and water reservoirs, and its image in front of other nations are all needs which pertain to the public as a whole and not to specific individuals. In order to preserve the public as one unit in the society, Islam defined certain types of property and declared them as a public property.
Jamoat mulki mulk toifasiga suv manbalari, o'rmon qo'riqxonalari va energiya resurslari kiradi.113 Qadimgi qabilaviy jamiyatlar chorva mollari uchun suv va yashil o'tloqlarning mavjudligiga qarab o'z joylashuvini o'zgartirib, ko'chib yurardi. Suv buloqlari quriganda yoki boshqa qabilaning hukmronligi ostiga o'tib qolganda, qabila ko'chishga va suv mo'l bo'lgan joyni izlashga majbur bo'lardi. O'rmonlar quriganda ham xuddi shunday bo'lardi, chunki ular qabila chorvasi uchun oziq-ovqatni kamaytirardi. Suv resurslari va o'tloqlar butun guruhning omon qolishi uchun zarur ekanini anglagan Islom bu resurslarga bir kishi emas, balki hammaning egalik qilishi kerakligini e'lon qildi. Agar bu resurslar bir kishi yoki bir necha kishining qo'liga o'tib qolsa, jamoatning yaxlitligi va birligi buzilishi mumkin. Xuddi shu gap energiya manbalariga ham taalluqlidir. Dastlabki musulmon olimlari Payg'ambar ﷺ hadisidagi "olov" so'zini qadimgi jamiyatlardagi o'tin kabi olov manbai ma'nosida tushunganlar. Bugun "olov" so'zi umumiy ma'noda energiya resurslariga ishora qiladi.
The category of public property includes water resources, forest preserves, and energy resources.113 Old tribal societies used to move and change their location based on the availability of water and green meadows for their cattle. Whenever water springs dry out or fall under the dominance of another tribe, the tribe would be forced to move and search for a location where water is plenty. The same happens when the forests dry out and leave less food for the cattle of the tribe. Realizing that water resources and meadows are essential for the survival of the whole group, Islam announced that these resources should be owned by all and not by any single individual. If these resources fall in the hands of one or few, then the integrity and unity of the public may be compromised. The same applies to energy sources. Earlier Muslims scholars interpreted the word “fire” in the statement of the Prophet to mean the source of fire like woods (in the older societies). Today “fire” refers more generally to energy resources.
Davlat mulki
State Property
Islom davlat tomonidan to'g'ridan-to'g'ri egalik qilinadigan ma'lum turdagi mulkni belgilab qo'ygan. Davlat mulki bilan jamoat mulki o'rtasidagi asosiy farq mulk daromadlaridan foydalanish usulida namoyon bo'ladi. Jamoat mulkini davlat boshqaradi, lekin u davlatning mulki hisoblanmaydi. Davlat jamoat mulkining daromadlaridan faqat davlatning o'z daromadi ehtiyojlarini qoplashga yetmagan hollardagina davlat funksiyalariga sarflash uchun foydalanishi mumkin. Davlat mulkiga kelsak, u davlatga o'z ishlarini va fuqarolarning ishlarini olib borish uchun uni o'zi xohlagancha sarflash bo'yicha to'liq vakolat beradi.
Islam designated certain types of property to be owned directly by the state. The main difference between state and public property shows in the way the property revenues are used. The public property is administered by the state but not owned by the state. The state may use revenues of the public properties to spend on state’s functions only when the state own revenue falls short of meeting its needs. The state property, on the other hand, gives the state full authority to spend as it sees fit to conduct its affairs and the affairs of the citizens.
Islom davlatining butun tarixi davomida davlatning eng katta daromad manbai Xaroj deb ataladigan yer mulkchiligidan olinadigan daromad bo‘lgan (urush yo‘li bilan Islom davlatiga qo‘shib olingan yerlar). Xaroj so‘zi lug‘aviy ma’noda mahsulot degan ma’noni anglatadi. Xaroj atamasi urushsiz qo‘shib olingan yerlarga nisbatan ishlatilgan fay’ atamasi o‘rniga kelgan. Abu Ubayd o‘zining “Al-Amvol” kitobida Az-Zuhriy rivoyati bilan naql qiladi: Payg‘ambar ﷺ Bahrayn yerlari fath etilganidan so‘ng, u yerdagi odamlar Islomni qabul qilganlaridan keyin ham, uni Xaroj yeri deb hisoblagan.116 Xaroj yeri Islom davlati hududiga qo‘shilgan va mulkchiligi davlatga tegishli bo‘lgan yer sifatida ta’riflanadi. Davlat bu yerdan dehqonchilik yoki obodonlashtirish uchun foydalanish huquqini oldindan belgilangan to‘lov evaziga beradi. Bu to‘lovni yerdan foydalanuvchi to‘lashi shart, u yerdan foyda ko‘rganmi yoki yo‘qmi, farqi yo‘q. To‘lov yer mahsulotining evaziga emas, balki undan foydalanish huquqining evaziga olinadi. Agar Xaroj yeridan foydalanuvchi musulmon bo‘lsa, u baribir mahsulotning zakot ulushini berishi lozim. Agar Xaroj yeridan foydalanuvchi musulmon bo‘lmasa, u faqat Xaroj to‘lovini to‘laydi.
Throughout the history of the Islamic state, the largest source of income for the state has been the revenue generated from the property ownership of land called Kharaj (the lands annexed to the Islamic state through war). Kharaj literally means output. The term kharaj replaced the term fai’i, which was used for the land annexed without a fight. Abu Obaid narrated in his book Al-Amwal on the authority of Az-Zuhri that Prophet Mohammad (PBUH) considered the lands of Bahrain after its conquest a land of Kharaj even after the people in Bahrain had converted to Islam.116 Kharaj land is defined as a land added to the territory of the Islamic state and whose ownership belongs to the state. The state grants the right to use the land for farming or development in exchange for a predefined fee. The fee is due to be paid by the user of the land whether he was able to benefit from the land or not. The fee is not in exchange for the product of the land; it is in exchange for the right to use it. If the user of the land is a Muslim, he still has to pay the Zakah portion of the products. If the user of the Kharaj land is not a Muslim, he only has to pay the Kharaj fee.