Muammo juda jiddiy tus oladi, qachonki kambag'al odam hayotini munosib ushlab turish uchun zarur oziq-ovqatga to'yib ovqat yeya olmaydigan bo'lib qoladi. Kapitalizm, tizim sifatida, ochlik masalasini hal qilmaydi. Aslida kapitalizm tamoyillari shunday imkoniyatni yuzaga keltiradiki, jamiyatdagi ayrim shaxslar o'z ehtiyojlarining ba'zilarini qondira olmaydi; bu ehtiyojlar ochlikni yo'qotish uchun zarur bo'lgan oziq-ovqatga bo'lgan ehtiyoj bo'lishi mumkin. Kapitalizm asossiz ravishda, har bir och qorinni to'yg'azish uchun resurslar (bu holda oziq-ovqat) yetarli emas, deb da'vo qiladi. Kapitalizm sharoitidagi ochlik hodisasiga javoban, ochlikka qarshi kurashish uchun ko'plab tashkilotlar tuzildi. Kapitalizm jamiyatlarida bunday tashkilotlarning mavjudligi kapitalizm tizim sifatida nafaqat ochlik epidemiyasi muammosini hal qila olmasligining, balki aynan shu muammoni keltirib chiqarayotganining oddiy isbotidir. Islom esa, boshqa tomondan (buni keyinroq muhokama qilamiz), ochlikni yo'qotishga chaqiradi va bu chaqiriqni Islomning asosiy tamoyiliga aylantiradi. Payg'ambar Muhammad ﷺ shunday degan deb rivoyat qilinadi: “Alloh va Uning Elchisi ﷺ jamiyatning bir a'zosiga och uxlashga ruxsat beradigan jamoadan voz kechadilar.”
The becomes problem really serious when the poor actually remains unable to fill his stomach with the necessary food to sustain a decent life. Capitalism as a system does not address the issue of hunger. In fact, the principles of capitalism give rise to the possibility that individuals in a society will not be able to satisfy some of their needs; these needs could very well be the need for food, which is necessary to eliminate hunger. Capitalism speciously claims that there is not enough resources (in this case food) to feed each and every hungry stomach. In response to the phenomenon of hunger under capitalism, many institutions were created to fight hunger. The existence of such institutions within the societies of capitalism is a simple proof that capitalism as a system not only fails to resolve the epidemic problem of hunger, but in fact it causes this problem. Islam, on the other hand (as will be discussed later), calls for the elimination of hunger and makes this call a fundamental principle of Islam. Prophet Mohammad is reported to have said, “Allah and his Messenger will disown a community which allows one of its members to sleep hungry.
AQSh iqtisodiyoti va boyligi ulkan o'sishiga qaramay, Amerikadagi ochlik bo'yicha shifokorlar guruhi (1984 yil boshida tashkil etilgan) xulosaga keldi: ochlik butun mamlakat miqyosida epidemiya darajasidagi muammo bo'lib, u yaxshilanish o'rniga yomonlashmoqda. Ular yana shuni xulosa qildilar: hozirgi siyosat Amerikadagi ochlikni yengillashtirmayapti56. Ko'pchilik bu haqiqatni qabul qilishi qiyin, deb ta'kidlaydi Ardis Armstrong Young57. U shunday savol beradi: "Agar amerikaliklar dunyoni boqish uchun yetarli oziq-ovqat yetishtira olsalar va och odamlar yeya oladiganidan ko'proq oziq-ovqatni isrof qilsalar, nega ular odamlarning ochlikdan azob chekishiga yo'l qo'yadilar?" Milliy ochlik va qashshoqlik markazi direktori Larri Braun o'zining "Amerikadagi ochlik: o'sib borayotgan epidemiya" kitobida AQShdagi ochlik muammosini qisqacha bayon qilib, shunday yozadi:
Despite the tremendous growth in the economy and the wealth of the United States, the Physician Task Force on Hunger in America (established in early 1984) concluded that hunger is a problem of epidemic proportions across the nation; it is getting worse, not better. They further concluded that present policies are not alleviating hunger in America56. This fact can be hardly accepted by many, as argued by Ardis Armstrong Young57. He raises the question “Why do Americans allow people to go hungry when they can grow enough food to feed the world and they waste more food than the hungry could eat?” Larry Brown, director of the National Center on Hunger and Poverty, summarized the hunger problem in the United States in his book Hunger in America: The Growing Epidemic58, where he writes:
Biz dunyo tarixidagi eng boy xalqmiz, lekin millionlab odamlar ochlikda yashaydi va keyingi ovqatlari qayerdan kelishini o‘ylab yuradi, biz esa jamiyatimizni bu balodan hali ham xalos qila olmayapmiz.
We are the richest nation in the history of the world with millions of people going hungry and wondering where their next meal is coming from and we’re still unable to rid our society of this scourge.
AQSh dunyodagi yagona ochlik muammosiga duch kelgan davlat emas, ammo u yetarli daromad yo'qligi sababli oziq-ovqat tanqisligidan aziyat chekayotgan aholi foizi yuqori bo'lgan yagona boy sanoat davlatidir. Bizning mamlakatimizda bolalarning deyarli beshdan biri qashshoqlik darajasidan past yashaydi. Bu muammoni hal qilish uchun bizda yetarlicha oziq-ovqat bor. Shunday ekan, masala Amerika ochlikni tugatishga qodirmi yoki yo'qmi emas, balki bunga erishish uchun yetarli yetakchilikka egamizmi, shuni hal qilish kerak.
The U.S. is not the only nation where people go hungry but it is the only wealthy industrial nation where such a high percentage of its population suffers from nutritional deprivation due to inadequate incomes. Nearly one in five children, in our nation, lives below the poverty level—we have more than enough food to end this problem—the real issue is not whether America can end hunger, the question is whether we have the leadership to do so.
Brownning xulosasidagi yagona kamchilik shundaki, u ochlik muammosini hal etishni siyosiy masala deb hisoblaydi, ya'ni siyosiy rahbarlar ochlikka qarshi dasturlarni joriy qila oladi, deb o'ylaydi. Bu tasavvur 1960-yillarning boshida qabul qilingan siyosatlar tufayli 1970-yillarda ochlik bartaraf etilganidan kelib chiqqan. Bu siyosatlar Reygan ma'muriyati davrida o'zgartirilgan yoki bekor qilinganda, ochlik yana qaytib kelgan57. Biroq shuni e'tirof etish kerakki, asosidagi iqtisodiy tamoyillar tufayli qashshoqlik va ochlik mavjudligining ichki va mohiyatan xos sababi bor. Ma'muriy dasturlar, siyosatlar va qoidalar, shuningdek xayriya tashkilotlari muammo ko'lamini kamaytirishi, uni ma'lum vaqt bostirishi yoki yashirishi mumkin. Biroq bu siyosat va dasturlar muammoning ildiz sababini yo'q qilmaydi, shu sababli ular bekor qilinishi yoki qisqartirilishi bilanoq ochlik bilan bog'liq muammolar darhol yana kuchayadi. Reygan ma'muriyati 1981-yilda oziq-ovqat markalari dasturidan yetti milliard dollar kesganida, anemiya, sil kasalligi, sekin o'sish va osteoporoz kabi ochlik bilan bog'liq muammolar darhol qaytib keldi.
The only issue with Brown’s conclusion is that he thinks that the resolution of hunger is a political issue, where political leaders can instill programs to deal with hunger. This illusion resulted from the fact that hunger was eliminated in the 1970s due to policies adopted in the early 1960s. When those policies were either changed or removed during the Reagan administration, hunger crawled back57. However, what should be noted is that there is an internal and intrinsic reason for poverty and hunger to exist because of the underlying economic principles. Administrative programs, policies, and regulations as well as charity organizations can reduce the scale of the problem, suppress it for some time, or hide it. However, these policies and programs do not eliminate the root cause of the problem; so once they are lifted or reduced, hunger immediately pumps up. When the Reagan administration cut seven billion dollars from the food stamp program in 1981, hunger related problems such as anemia, tuberculosis, poor growth, and osteoporosis crawled back immediately.
Kapitalistik davlatlarning ocharchilik muammosiga yondashuvi xuddi uyda gaz sizganini sezib, havodagi gazni tozalab filtrlash uchun yaxshi va sifatli filtr qidirib ketgan odamga o'xshaydi, sizgan joyni topib, uni butunlay tuzatish o'rniga. Filtr olib tashlangan yoki o'z vazifasini yaxshi bajara olmay qolgan zahoti gaz darhol uyni to'ldiradi! Xuddi shu o'xshatish bo'yicha, siyosat va qoidalar ocharchilikni filtrlash va ochlarni boqish uchun ishlatiladi. Ocharchilikning sababi iqtisodiy tizimning asosiy tamoyillarida yashirin qoladi: oziq-ovqat nisbatan kam. Narx ishlab chiqarish hajmini belgilaydi, iste'mol miqdorini aniqlaydi va kim yeyishi yoki yemasligini hal qiladi. Shu sababli, 1971 yilda Oxford English Dictionary lug'atida ocharchilikka berilgan ta'riflardan biri "mamlakatdagi oziq-ovqat etishmasligi yoki kamligi" bo'lishi ajablanarli emas.
The way governments in capitalist states deal with the problem of hunger is similar to someone who detects a gas leak in a house and goes to find a nice and good filter to clean up and filter out the gas from the air instead of finding the leak source and fixing it altogether. The moment the filter is removed or fails to do its job properly, the gas immediately fills the house! Using the same analogy, the policies and regulations are used to filter out hunger and feed the hungry. The cause of hunger remains dormant in the basic principles of the economic system: food is relatively scarce. Price dictates the output of the production, determines the amount of consumption, and decides who could or could not eat. It is no surprise then that one of the definitions found for hunger in the Oxford English Dictionary in 1971 is “the want or scarcity of food in a country.”