4 Kuyapinga Itikadi ya Ustaarabu wa Magharibi
4 Refuting the Creed of the Western Civilization
Barani Ulaya, Kanisa Katoliki kama ilivyojadiliwa awali lilitawala maisha, jamii, dola na watu kwa jina la dini. Lilipanua utawala wake juu ya wafalme na watawala, kwa kutumia wazo la mamlaka ya Mungu. Lingewaidhinisha watawala kutawala, likiwapa uhalali unaohitajika. Hivyo, watawala na wafalme walijinyenyekeza kwa Kanisa Katoliki. Wakati mwingine waliungana nalo kwa ajili ya maslahi yao. Kanisa Katoliki lilipanua utawala wake juu ya watu kwa kudai kwamba lilikuwa na haki ya msamaha, kupitia ondoleo la dhambi na sakramenti. Yeyote aliyekiuka mafundisho yake angeadhibiwa kwa kuhojiwa kikatili na kutengwa kwa adhabu. Kanisa lilidhibiti uchumi kwa kumiliki ardhi na mali zilizotokana na zaka na vyanzo vingine. Hata hivyo, kuanzia mwanzoni mwa karne ya kumi na sita Baada ya Kristo, ushawishi wake ulianza kupungua taratibu. Hili lilitokana na sababu nyingi, muhimu zaidi ikiwa ni Mageuzi ya Kiprotestanti yaliyoongozwa na Martin Luther. Mageuzi hayo yalitayarisha njia kwa kile ambacho Wamagharibi wanadai kuwa ni utawala wa dola na kutenganishwa kwa dini. Katika kitabu chake, *The Advent of Democracy Volume 1 The Modem Revolution* (Kifaransa: *L'avenement de la democratie I La revolution moderne*), Marcel Gauchet alisema, “Hatua ya Luther inashambulia kanuni ya upatanishi katikati yake, chini ya uongozi wa Kanisa, taasisi kuu iliyoidhihirisha katika ulimwengu wa Kikristo... Kuhoji kile ambacho umoja wa Mbingu na Dunia unahusisha, ni hatua ya kwanza ya enzi ya kisasa. (Kifaransa: *L’operation de Luther frappe le principe de mediation au coeur, sous les traits de I’Eglise, I’institution pivot qui le materialisait dans le monde Chretien... La remise en question de I’unite du Ciel et de la Terre qu’elle engage est le premier pas de I’ere moderne.*)”.
In Europe, the Catholic Church as discussed earlier had been dominating life, society, state and people in the name of religion. It extended its dominance over kings and rulers, from the perspective of the idea of divine authority. It would authorize ruling for them, providing them the necessary legitimacy. Thus, rulers and kings would submit to the Catholic Church. At times they would ally with the Catholic Church for the sake of their interests. The Catholic Church extended its dominance over the people by claiming that it had possessed the right of forgiveness, through absolution and sacrament. Whosoever violated its teachings would be subjected to brutal inquisition and punitive excommunication. The Church controlled the economy by possessing lands and wealth resulting from tithes and others. However, from the beginning of the sixteenth century CE, its influence began to gradually wane. This was due to many factors, the most important of which is the Protestant Reformation led by Martin Luther. Reformation paved the way for what the Westerners assert is the dominance of the state and the separation of religion. In his book, The Advent of Democracy Volume 1 The Modem Revolution (French: L'avenement de la democratie I La revolution moderne), Marcel Gauchet said, “Luther's operation strikes at the principle of mediation at the heart, at the auspices of the Church, the pivotal institution which materialized it in the Christian world... The questioning of what the unity between the Heaven and the Earth engages over, is the first step of the modern era. (French: L’operation de Luther frappe le principe de mediation au coeur, sous les traits de I’Eglise, I’institution pivot qui le materialisait dans le monde Chretien... La remise en question de I’unite du Ciel et de la Terre qu’elle engage est le premier pas de I’ere moderne.)”.
Kutokana na kuibuka kwa Uprotestanti, Uingereza iliacha mafundisho ya Kikatoliki na kuanzisha Kanisa la Anglikana ili kusisitiza ukuu wa kifalme juu yake, ikijitenga na Roma na mamlaka ya Upapa. Kisha Vita vya Miaka Thelathini vilizuka, ambavyo vilihusisha utawala wa Habsburg, Dola ya Hispania, Ufaransa, Uswidi, Denmark-Norway na vyombo vya Kijerumani. Vita viliendelea hadi mwaka 1648, mwaka ambao mikataba iliyounda Amani ya Westphalia ilianza kutiwa saini, na hivyo kumaliza vita vya kidini. Mkataba huo uliashiria mwanzo wa kuibuka kwa taifa la kisasa, kwa kuwa ulijumuisha kutajwa kwa usekularishaji wa mali za kanisa, maana yake ni kwamba zilihamishiwa kwa mamlaka zisizo za kidini, yaani mamlaka za kidunia za dola. Yote haya yaliambatana na maendeleo ya kiuchumi yaliyoshuhudiwa na Ulaya baada ya hatua ya ugunduzi wa kijiografia. Pia, yaliambatana na mabadiliko ya mtazamo kuhusu Kanisa, mafundisho yake na elimu yake, kupitia mapinduzi ya kiakili na kisayansi yaliyotajwa hapo awali.
As a result of the emergence of Protestantism, England abandoned the Catholic doctrine and established the Anglican Church to emphasize royal supremacy over it, separating from Rome and the Papal authority. Then the Thirty Years War broke out, in which the Hapsburg monarchy, the Spanish Empire, France, Sweden, Denmark-Norway and Germanic entities participated. The war continued until 1648, the year in which the treaties constituting the Peace of Westphalia began to be signed, ending the religious war. It marked the beginnings of the emergence of the modern nation state, as it included the reference to the secularization of church assets, meaning that they were transferred to non-religious authorities, i.e. temporal state authorities. All of this coincided with economic developments witnessed by Europe, after the stage of geographical discoveries. Also, it coincided with the change in view about the Church, its teachings and knowledge, through the intellectual and scientific revolutions that has been mentioned previously.
Kwa sababu ya mambo haya yote, Ulaya ilipokea karne ya kumi na nane Mtawala (CE) ikiwa katika hali iliyofaa kutenganisha dini na maisha, kama ilivyothibitishwa na kanuni za Mapinduzi ya Ufaransa ya mwaka 1789. Wazo hilo halikuimarishwa wala kutekelezwa hadi mwisho wa karne ya kumi na tisa (CE) na mwanzo wa karne ya ishirini (CE), wakati baadaye lilipojulikana kama usekulari. Asili ya usekulari iko katika maana ya kidunia na kuhusu dunia, kutokana na maana ya dunia (^) na si kutokana na elimu au sayansi (<^). Katika mataifa yanayozungumza Kifaransa na ya Kikatoliki, huitwa LaTcite. Inafaa kutajwa kwamba si mataifa yote ya Magharibi yaliyopitisha usekulari yaliyoweka usekulari katika katiba zao. Badala yake, baadhi, kama Uingereza, huweka kanisa fulani au dini fulani kuwa dini ya dola. Hata hivyo, Ufaransa, kama mfano tofauti, iliweka Ibara ya 1 ya Katiba ya Ufaransa inayokataza ushiriki wa kidini katika mambo ya serikali, kwa msingi wa mwaka 1905.
As a result of all these factors, Europe welcomed the eighteenth century CE within an atmosphere conducive to separating religion from life, as affirmed by the principles of the French Revolution of 1789. The idea was not consolidated and implemented until the end of the nineteenth century CE and the beginning of the twentieth century CE, when it was later known as secularism. The origin of secularism is in the sense of Earthliness and worldliness from the sense of the world (^) and not from knowledge or science (<^). It is called LaTcite in the Francophone and Catholic nations. It is worthy of mention that not all Western nations that adopted secularism, stipulated secularism in their constitutions. Instead, some, like England, stipulate a particular church or a particular religion as the religion of the state. However, France, as a contrasting example, enacted Article 1 of the French Constitution discouraging religious involvement in government affairs, based on the 1905
Sheria ya Ufaransa ya Kutenganisha Makanisa na Serikali (Kifaransa: Loi du 9 décembre 1905 concernant la séparation des Églises et de l'État). Inachukuliwa kuwa kitu cha ajabu katika muktadha wa mambo ya kihistoria, kiakili na kisiasa. Ndiyo maana baadhi ya Wamagharibi hutofautisha kati ya "secularism" na "Laïcité", kwa kuwa Laïcité ndiyo secularism iliyowekwa kikatiba na Ufaransa.
French law on the Separation of the Churches and the State (French: Loi du 9 decembre 1905 concernant la separation des Eglises et de I’Etat). It is considered an anomaly in the context of historical, intellectual and political considerations. That is why, some Westerners differentiate between secularism and Laicite as Laicite is the secularism stipulated by France constitutionally.
Sekularism mara nyingi hufafanuliwa kuwa ni kutenganishwa kwa Kanisa na dola. Hata hivyo, ufafanuzi huu wa kwanza haufikii kikamilifu falsafa hii wala hauelezi kwa ukamilifu mafundisho yake. Badala yake unaeleza tu matokeo yake, ambayo ni kwamba Magharibi ilifikia imani ya kutenganisha dini na maisha. Hii ndiyo dhana ya sekularism iliyofuatwa na Magharibi tangu karne ya kumi na nane, katika nyanja zote mbili za kimafundisho na kifalsafa. Hata hivyo, sifa zake zilizo bainifu zaidi zinaamuliwa kwa vitendo na miili miwili inayowakilisha sekularism. Miili hiyo ni, kwa upande mmoja, Kanisa, kama chombo kinachodhihirisha dini pamoja na imani zake za kale na mafundisho yake, na kwa upande mwingine, dola, kama chombo kinachodhihirisha maisha pamoja na njia zake za kisasa za kiakili.
Secularism is often defined as the separation of the Church from the state. However, this first definition neither completely encapsulates the philosophy nor fully elucidates its doctrine. Instead it only expresses the consequence, which is that the West reached the conviction of separating of religion from life. This is the concept of secularism followed by the West since the eighteenth century, in both doctrinal and philosophical realms. However, the most distinct characteristics are practically determined by the two bodies that symbolize secularism. They are, on the one hand, the Church, as a body expressing the religion with its ancient beliefs and teachings, and, on the other hand, the state as a body expressing life with its modern, rationalist modalities.
Uhalisia wa usekula au Laicite, katika ufafanuzi wa Wamagharibi wenyewe, pia unajitokeza kama ufafanuzi wa pili: kutenganisha dini na maisha. Kwa mfano, Maurice Barbier anasema katika kitabu chake La Laicite: “Kwa maana yake pana, Laicite maana yake ni kutenganisha kati ya dini na uhalisia wa kidunia (les realites profanes).” Hii inadhania kwamba uhalisia huu wa kidunia hauko chini ya kuingizwa wala ushawishi wa dini. Kinachokusudiwa kwa dini ni imani, au kundi lolote, au mamlaka yoyote ya kidini. Hivyo basi, tunaona kwamba falsafa katika Magharibi inajitegemea na theolojia. Sayansi mbalimbali ziliundwa nje ya mfumo wa Ukristo. Hakika, sayansi wakati fulani zilikuwa kinyume kabisa cha Ukristo. Vilevile, uhalisia wote wa kibinadamu kama vile wa kisiasa, kijamii na kiutamaduni, na uhalisia mwingine, unapaswa kujitegemea na dini. Hili lilipatikana kwa kutenganishwa kwa muda mrefu, ambacho ndicho tunachokiita usekularishaji au ulaiki.
The reality of secularism or Laicite, in the definitions of the Westerners themselves, also appears as a second definition, the separation of religion from life. For example, Maurice Barbier says in his book La Laicite, “In its broad sense, Laicite means the separation between the religion and worldly realities (les realites profanes).” It assumes that these worldly realities are subject neither to the inclusion nor influence of religion. What is meant by religion is beliefs or any group or any religious authority. Thus, we see that the philosophy in the West is independent of theology. Various sciences were formed outside the framework of Christianity. Indeed, the sciences were polar opposites to Christianity at times. Similarly, all the human realities such as political, social and cultural and other realities, are to be independent of religion. This was achieved by the long-term separation, which is what we call secularization or laicization.
Ndiyo sababu tunaweza kuelezea jamii yoyote, fikra yoyote au maadili yoyote kuwa ni ya LaTcite, iwapo hayana athari yoyote ya kidini kabisa, na iwapo yanafuata tu kanuni za mifumo ya kiakili (rationalist) au ya kibinadamu (humanist). Kwa maana finyu ya neno hili, tunaweza kuelezea elimu kuwa ya LaTcite, kwa mfano, iwapo haina sifa yoyote ya kimadhehebu (kidhehebu) au ya kidini. Mwanafalsafa Charles Taylor, katika kitabu chake, A Secular Age, anatofautisha kati ya fasili tatu za usekula zinazoshikiliwa Magharibi: "Uelewa mmoja wa usekula ni kwa mujibu wa nafasi za umma. Inadaiwa kuwa nafasi hizi zimeondolewa Mungu, au rejeo lolote kwa uhalisia wa mwisho. Au, kwa upande mwingine, tunapofanya kazi ndani ya nyanja mbalimbali za shughuli—kiuchumi, kisiasa, kiutamaduni, kielimu, kitaaluma, kiburudani—kanuni na misingi tunayofuata, mijadala tunayoshiriki, kwa ujumla hazituelekezi kwa Mungu wala kwa imani yoyote ya kidini; mambo tunayoyatendea kazi yanatokana na "mantiki" ya kila nyanja yenyewe—faida kubwa zaidi katika uchumi, manufaa makubwa zaidi kwa watu wengi zaidi katika eneo la siasa, na kadhalika. Hili linatofautiana sana na vipindi vya awali, wakati imani ya Kikristo ilipoweka maelekezo yenye mamlaka, mara nyingi kupitia midomo ya viongozi wa kidini, ambayo hayakuweza kupuuzwa kwa urahisi katika nyanja yoyote kati ya hizi, kama vile katazo la riba, au wajibu wa kulazimisha msimamo wa kiimani."
It is for this reason that we can characterize any society or thought or morality as LaTcite, if it is completely devoid of any religious influence, and if it only follows the principles within the rationalist or humanist regimes. In the narrow sense of the word, we can characterize education in LaTcite, for example, as not containing any sectarian (denominational) or religious characteristics. The philosopher Charles Taylor, in his book, A Secular Age, distinguishes between three definitions of secularism held in the West, “One understanding of secularity then is in terms of public spaces. These have been allegedly emptied of God, or of any reference to ultimate reality. Or taken from another side, as we function within various spheres of activity—economic, political, cultural, educational, professional, recreational—the norms and principles we follow, the deliberations we engage in, generally don’t refer us to God or to any religious beliefs; the considerations we act on are internal to the “rationality” of each sphere—maximum gain within the economy, the greatest benefit to the greatest number in the political area, and so on. This is in striking contrast to earlier periods, when Christian faith laid down authoritative prescriptions, often through the mouths of the clergy, which could not be easily ignored in any of these domains, such as the ban on usury, or the obligation to enforce orthodoxy.”.
Kuhusu ufafanuzi wa tatu wa Magharibi wa usekula, ulilenga kudharau dini. Kwa maneno ya Charles Taylor, "Tukiwa watoto, lazima tujione tukiwa tumezungukwa na upendo na kujali, la sivyo tunanyauka. Lakini tunapokua, lazima tujifunze kukabiliana na ukweli kwamba mazingira haya ya kujali hayawezi kuenea zaidi ya ulimwengu wa kibinadamu, na mara nyingi hayaenei mbali sana ndani yake. Lakini mpito huu ni mgumu. Hivyo tunabuni ulimwengu wenye kutupatia riziki, ulioumbwa na Mungu mwenye fadhili... Kwa hiyo dini hutokana na ukosefu wa ujasiri wa kitoto. Tunapaswa kusimama kama wanaume na kukabiliana na uhalisia."
As for the third Western definition of secularism, it focused on the denigration of religion. In the words of Charles Taylor, “As children, we have to see ourselves as surrounded by love and concern, or we shrivel up. But in growing up, we have to learn to face the fact that this environment of concern can’t extend beyond the human sphere, and mostly doesn’t extend very far within it. But this transition is hard. So we project a world which is providential, created by a benign God... So religion emanates from a childish lack of courage. We need to stand up like men, and face reality.”.
Baadhi ya wanafikra wa Magharibi huendelea kuainisha usekula (Laicite) bila kuuchukulia kama mfumo mmoja, wenye mshikamano wa kisiasa na kifalsafa. Hata hivyo, wanafikra wengine huugawanya katika mapokeo mawili: la Kifaransa na la Kianglo-Saxon. Baadhi yao wameugawanya usekula katika aina "laini" na "ngumu". Wengine wameuainisha kama Laicite ouverte (usekula wazi), wenye uvumilivu mkubwa zaidi kwa dini kama ilivyo Marekani, na Laicite militante (usekula wa kupigania), ulio karibu zaidi na Ufaransa. Pia wapo waliouainisha usekula kuwa wa kiatheisti na usio wa kiatheisti, na miongoni mwao wapo waliouainisha kuwa wa sehemu au wa kila upande, na kadhalika. Uainishaji wote huu, hasa mgawanyo wa usekula kuwa wa sehemu au wa kila upande, ambao ni wa kawaida miongoni mwa baadhi ya Waislamu, haubadilishi uhalisia wa usekula au Laicite katika asili yake. Asili ya usekula ni kutenganisha dini na maisha, jambo ambalo kwa upande wake linazaa kutenganisha dini na dola. Usekula wa sehemu si mtazamo wa kivitendo tu. Badala yake, ni mtazamo wa kiakili unaotokana na falsafa ya kiakili (rationalism), ambayo haitambui uhalali wa dini kutawala na kusimamia mambo ya watu. Vipengele vya kivitendo vya suluhisho za kisekula haviwezi kutenganishwa na vipengele vya kiakili na kifalsafa, kama baadhi wanavyodhani. Hii ni kwa sababu anayeunga mkono usekula wa sehemu anahitaji kuthibitisha ukweli na uhalali wa mbinu hiyo, kiakili na kifalsafa. Kwa hiyo, usekula-Laicite ni kutenganisha dini na maisha. Usekula ni itikadi, msingi wa kiakili na uongozi wa kifikra wa Magharibi.
Some Western thinkers go on to classify secularism- Laicite, without regarding it as a single, cohesive political- philosophical paradigm. Yet other thinkers sub-divide it into French and Anglo-Saxon secularist traditions. Some of them sub-classified secularism into “soft” and “hard” variants. Some of them classified as Laicite ouverte (open secularism), with greater tolerance of religion as in the US, and Laicite militante (militant secularism), which is more like France. Some of them classified secularism into atheist and non-atheist variants. Amongst them are those who sub-classified secularism into partial or comprehensive and so on. All these classifications, particularly the partial and comprehensive divisions of secularism, that are common amongst some of the Muslims, do not change the reality of secularism or Laicite in its nature. Secularism’s nature is that of separating the religion from life, which in turns results in the separation of religion from the state. Partial secularism is not just a pragmatic, operational view. Instead, partial secularism is an intellectual viewpoint based on the rationalist philosophy, which does not recognize the validity of religion to rule and take care of the affairs of people. The operational aspect of secular solutions cannot be separated from the intellectual and philosophical aspects, as some may hold. This is because the one who advocates partial secularism needs to justify the truth and validity of the approach, intellectually and philosophically. Therefore, secularism-Laicite is the separation of religion from life. Secularism is the creed, intellectual basis and intellectual leadership of the West.
Kuhusu sekularism kuwa itikadi ya Magharibi, hii ni kwa sababu ni fikra ya msingi ambayo Magharibi inaithibitisha kwa uhakika. Sekularism inachukuliwa na Magharibi kuwa suluhisho la tatizo kubwa zaidi la binadamu, ikiwakilisha mtazamo kamili kuhusu ulimwengu, mwanadamu na maisha, katika mahusiano yao yote na yaliyo kabla na baada ya maisha haya ya kidunia. Kuhusu sekularism kuwa msingi wa kifikra wa Magharibi, hii ni kwa sababu ndiyo msingi (usoo/) ambao fikra zote ndogo (matawi) zimejengwa juu yake. Ni msingi ambao mfumo wa maisha unatokana nao. Kuhusu sekularism kuwa uongozi wa kifikra wa Magharibi, hii ni kwa sababu Magharibi huwaongoza wote wanaoipitisha sekularism kuelekea mtazamo maalum kuhusu maisha, kwenye namna maalum ya kuishi, na kwenye kigezo kilichoshirikiwa cha kupima fikra, ukweli na matukio, vyote kutoka pembe maalum.
As for secularism being the creed of the West, this is because it is the fundamental thought affirmed by the West conclusively. Secularism is considered by the West as the solution for the greatest problem of humankind, representing a comprehensive viewpoint about universe, man and life, in all of their relationships with what is before and after this worldly life. As for secularism being the intellectual basis of the West, this is because it is the foundation (usoo/) upon which all the sub-thoughts (branches) are built. It is the foundation from which the system for living emerges. As for secularism being the intellectual leadership of the West, this is because the West leads all those who adopt secularism into a specific viewpoint about life, into a specific way of living and into a shared criterion for judging thoughts, facts and events, all from a specific angle.
Usekula umeharibika kuhusu kuwa imani, msingi wa kifikra na uongozi wa kifikra. Uharibifu wake unatokana na vipengele kadhaa, baadhi yake ni:
Secularism is corrupted with respect to its being a creed, intellectual basis and intellectual leadership. Its corruption arises from several aspects, some of which are: