Hukm Shar'i
9 Hukm Shar’ai
Hukmu sharʼi shi ne maganar Mai Shari'a da ta shafi ayyukan bayi ('ibaad). Ya kasu kashi biyu: ko dai an tabbatar da shi da hujja qat'iyya (qat'iy uthuboot), kamar Alqur'ani da hadisi mutawatir, ko kuma an tabbatar da shi da hujja zato (dhanniy uthuboot), kamar hadisi wanda ba mutawatir ba. Idan an tabbatar da shi da hujja qat'iyya kuma ma'anarsa ta bayyana sarai, babu shakka (qat'iy udalalah), to hukuncin zai zama qat'i. Misali na haka shi ne adadin dukkan raka'o'in sallah da aka wajabta, kamar yadda suka zo a hadisi mutawatir. Haka nan, haramcin riba, yankewar hannun barawo, da bulalar zina (zani) su ne hukunce-hukunce qat'i wadanda ingancinsu tabbatacce ne, inda ba a samu wata ra'ayi ba face guda daya wacce aka tabbatar da ita da hujja qat'iyya.
Hukm shar’ai is the speech of the Legislator related to the actions of the servants ('ibaad). It is either conclusively proven (qat'iy uthuboot), such as the Qur'an and hadith mutawatir or inconclusively proven (dhanniy uthuboot) such as the non-mutawatir hadith. If it is qat'iy uthuboot and its meaning is definitive (qat'iy udalalah), the hukm will be conclusive. An example of this is the number of all prescribed raka'ah in salat, as they are mentioned in the hadith mutawatir. Likewise, the prohibition of riba, the amputation of the hand of the thief, and the lashing of the zani (adulterer) are conclusive rules whose correctness is definite, where there is only one single conclusively proven opinion.
Idan maganar Mai-shari'a (Ash-Shaari') ta kasance qat'iy uthuboot amma ba ta ba da ma'ana tabbatacciya ba (dhanniy udalalah), to hukuncin da ya ƙunsa ba shi da tabbas. Misali, ayar da ta shafi jizyah a cikin Alkur'ani. Ayar qat'iy uthuboot ce amma ma'anarta ba ta tabbata ba. Makarantar Hanafiyya ta sanya sharadin a kira shi jizyah, kuma waɗanda aka wajabta musu biyansa dole ne su kasance cikin halin wulaƙanci a lokacin biyan. Amma makarantar Shafi'iyya ba ta sanya sharadin a kira shi jizyah ba, kuma ta halatta a kira jizyah da sunan zakka biyu. Ba su wajabta wanda ke biyan ya kasance cikin wulaƙanci ba, sai dai ya isa ya miƙa wuya ga dokokin Musulunci.
If the speech of the Legislator is qat'iy uthuboot and does not yield a definite meaning (dhanniy udalalah), then the included hukm is inconclusive. For example, the ayah related to jizyah in the Qur'an. The ayah is qat'iy uthuboot but the meaning is not definite. The Hanafi school stipulated that it be called jizyah and those who are required to pay it must be in a state of humiliation when rendering payment. However, the Shafi'i school did not stipulate calling it jizyah and permitted jizyah to be called double zakah They did not require for the one paying it to be humiliated, but it is enough to submit to the Islamic rules.
Idan maganar Mai Shari'a ta kasance zanniy ath-thubut, kamar hadisin da ba mutawatir ba, to hukuncin da ta ƙunsa ba zai zama qat'i ba, ko ma’anarsa ta kasance qat'iy ad-dalala ko a’a. Misali, azumtar kwana shida a watan Shawwal ko haramcin bayar da filin noma haya, dukkansu an tabbatar da su ta hanyar Sunnah.
If the speech of the Legislator is dhanniy uthuboot, such as the non-mutawatir hadith, then the hukm included will not be conclusive, regardless of whether the meaning is qat'iy udalalah or not. For example, fasting six days in Shawwal or the prohibition of leasing agricultural land, both of which are proven through Sunnah.
Hukmin Shari'a yana fahimtarsa daga maganar Mai Shari'a (Khitab Ash-Shari') ta hanyar ijtihadi mai inganci. Don haka, ijtihadin mujtahidi shi ne yake samar da Hukmin Shari'a. Saboda haka, hukuncin Allah (SWT) ga kowane mujtahidi shi ne hukuncin da mujtahidin ya isa gare shi ta hanyar ijtihadinsa, da abin da ya fi yiwuwa ya yi imani da cewa daidai ne.
The hukm Shara'i is understood from the speech of the Legislator (Khitab Ashari') through a correct ijtihad. Thus, the ijtihad of a mujtahid produces the Hukm Shara'i. Accordingly, Allah (swt)'s hukm for every mujtahid is the hukm that mujtahid arrived at through his ijtihad and what he most likely thinks to be correct.
Malamai sun yi ittifaqi cewa idan mukallafi (wanda ya rataya masa alhaki na shari'a) ya cika sharuddan ijtihadi a wata tambaya ko fiye da daya, sannan ya yi ijtihadi ya kai ga hukunci a kanta, to ba a halatta masa ya bi sauran mujtahidai a wannan al'amari ba, domin hakan zai zama taqlidi ga ra'ayin da ya bambanta da abin da a ganinsa ya fi kusantar gaskiya. Muttabi'i kuwa shi ne wanda ya samu wasu muhimman ilimomi na ijtihadi, saboda haka yana bin hukunci bayan ya fahimci dalilinsa. Saboda haka, hukuncin Allah (SWT) ga wannan muttabi'i shi ne ra'ayin mujtahidin da yake bi. Shi kuwa 'Aammi shi ne wanda bai mallaki muhimman ilimomin ijtihadi ba, don haka yake bin mujtahidi ba tare da sanin dalilin hukuncin ba. Wannan 'aammi dole ne ya bi ra'ayin mujtahidai, ya kuma yi aiki da hukunce-hukuncen da suka fitar. Hukumar Shari'a kuwa a bangarensa ita ce wadda mujtahidin da yake bi ya fitar. Saboda haka, Hukumar Shari'a ita ce hukuncin da mujtahidin da ya cancanci yin ijtihadi ya fitar. Hukuncin Allah (SWT) ne a gare shi, kuma ba a halatta masa ya barshi ya bi wani ra'ayi ba. Haka kuma hukuncin Allah (SWT) ne ga wadanda suke bin mujtahidin, kuma ba a halatta musu su barshi ba.
It has been agreed upon amongst scholars that if a mukallaf (one under legal responsibility) fulfils the capacity of ijtihad in one question or more and makes ijtihad and reaches thereupon a hukm, he is not allowed to follow other mujtahideen in this issue, because it would be a taqleed of an opinion which is different to what is most likely correct in his opinion. The muttab'i is a person who has acquired some important knowledge in ijtihad and consequently follows the hukm after understanding its daleel. Accordingly, Allah's (swt) hukm for this muttab'i is the opinion of the mujtahid whom he follows. The 'aammi is the person who does not possess some important knowledge in ijtihad and hence follows the mujtahid without having knowledge of the daleel for the hukm. This 'aammi has to follow the opinion of the mujtahideen and apply the aHkam they have deduced. The Hukm Shara'i on his part is the one deduced by the mujtahid whom he follows. Therefore, the Hukm Shara'i is the hukm deduced by the mujtahid who is qualified to practise ijtihad. It is Allah's (swt) hukm for him, and he is not allowed to leave it to follow another opinion. It is also Allah's (swt) hukm for those who follow the mujtahid and they are not permitted to leave it.
Idan muqallid ya bi wani mujtahid a hukuncin wata mas'ala, ya kuma yi aiki da shi, to bai halatta ya bar wannan hukunci zuwa wani mujtahid ba kwata-kwata. Duk da haka, ya halatta muqallid ya bi mujtahid a wasu mas'aloli, domin ijma'in Sahabbai ya halatta cewa muqallid zai iya tambayar wani malami daban a wata mas'ala daban. Idan muqallid ya ware wani madhhabi, kamar Shafi'i, ya kuma ɗaura wa kansa alhakin bin dukkan madhhabin, to wannan hukunci ya rataya a kansa: Ba a halatta wa muqallid ya bi wani mujtahid a wata mas'ala da ya riga ya yi aiki da ita bisa madhhabin da yake bi ba. Game da mas'alolin da bai riga ya yi aiki da su ba tukuna, ya halatta ya bi sauran mujtahidai. Sai dai, idan mujtahid ya kai ga hukunci a wata mas'ala ta hanyar ijtihadinsa, ya halatta ya watsar da sakamakon ijtihadinsa ya bi wata ra'ayi daban, idan hakan yana nufin haɗa kan dukkan Musulmi a kan ra'ayi guda, kamar yadda ya faru a bai'ar 'Uthman.
If the muqallid follows a mujtahid in a hukm of any issue and acts accordingly, he is not allowed to leave that hukm for another mujtahid at all. However, it is permissible for the muqallid to follow the mujtahid in other issues, because ijma'a as-Sahabah permitted that a muqallid may ask a different 'aalim (scholar) on a different issue. If the muqallid assigned a certain School of Thought (madhab), such as the Shafi'i and committed himself to follow the entire madhab, then the following applies upon him: The muqallid is not allowed to follow any other mujtahid on an issue he has already practised according to the madhab he is following. Regarding the issues that he has not practised yet, he is allowed to follow the other mujtahideen. However, if a mujtahid reached a hukm on an issue through his ijtihad, he is allowed to abandon the result of his ijtihad and follow another opinion, if it means the unification of all Muslims on one opinion, as happened at the bai’ah of 'Uthman.