13 Mitala (Ndoa ya Mke Zaidi ya Mmoja)
13 Polygyny
Allah (SWT) amesema katika Kitabu chake Kitukufu:
Allah (swt) has said in his Noble Book:
"Oeni wanawake mnaowapenda, wawili, watatu, au wanne. Lakini mkihofu kwamba hamtaweza kutendea haki (wake zenu), basi mmoja tu, au wale wajakazi mliowamiliki. Hayo ni karibu zaidi kuepusha udhalimu." Hii aya [An-Nisaa: 3] iliteremshwa kwa Mtume ﷺ katika mwaka wa nane wa Hijra. Iliteremshwa kupunguza idadi ya wake ambao mtu anaweza kuoa hadi wanne. Wakati aya hii ilipoteremshwa, hapakuwa na kikomo cha idadi ya wake ambao mtu angeweza kuoa. Kwa kuisoma na kuielewa aya hii, inadhihirika wazi kwamba iliteremshwa kupunguza idadi ya wake hadi wanne. Maana ya aya ni: oeni wanawake wawili, watatu au wanne miongoni mwa wale walioruhusiwa na wanaokubalika kwenu. Maneno "wawili, watatu na wanne" yametajwa badala ya kurudiwarudiwa kwa hesabu. Yaani, oeni wanawake mnaowachagua kutoka katika idadi hizi zilizotajwa: wawili, watatu au wanne. Hotuba inaelekezwa kwa kila mtu, kwa hiyo kulazimika kurudiwa, ili kila mwenye kutaka kuoa wanawake kadhaa aweze kuchagua idadi anayoitaka, kwa sharti kwamba mchanganyiko anaoutaka uwe ndani ya idadi hii. Kwa maneno mengine, kila mwenye kutaka kuoa zaidi ya mke mmoja anaweza kuoa wengi kadiri atakavyo kutoka katika idadi iliyowekwa kuwa ya hiari kwake. Kama tunavyosema kwa kikundi: gaweni dinari hizi. Tuseme zilikuwa dinari elfu moja, kwa mfano. Tungesema: gaweni dinari kwa jozi, kwa makundi ya watatu na ya wanne. Kama tungetoa kauli hiyo katika umoja, isingekuwa na maana. Kwa hiyo usemi "wawili, watatu na wanne" ni wa lazima ili kila mtu achague anachotaka katika idadi hiyo maalum. Basi Allah (SWT) anaposema kila mmoja wenu anaweza kuoa wanawake wa chaguo lake, wawili, watatu au wanne, maana yake ni: oeni nyinyi nyote wawili, watatu au wanne. Yaani kila mmoja wenu anaweza kuoa wawili, watatu au wanne. Kuhusu maana ya kauli yake (SWT):
“Marry women of your choice, two or three, or four but if you fear that you shall not be able to deal justly (with them), then only one or your concubines. That is more fitting so that you do not deviate from the right course” [An- Nisa: 3] This verse was revealed to the Prophet (pbuh) in the 8th year of the Hijra. It was revealed to limit the number of wives one can marry to four. At the time of revelation of this verse there was no limit to the number of wives one could marry. On reading and understanding the verse it becomes clear that it was revealed to limit the number of wives to four. The meaning of the verse is: marry of the women, two, three or four who are permitted and agreeable to you. Twos, threes and fours are mentioned instead of repeated enumerations. i.e. marry the women of your choice from these mentioned numbers twos, threes and fours. The speech is addressed to everybody, therefore there has to be a repetition so that each suitor who wishes to marry a number of women can choose whatever He wants of number on condition that the combination He desires is restricted to this number. In other words, each suitor who wishes to marry more than one woman can marry as many as He likes from the number that is made optional for Him. Just as we would say to a group distribute this money. Let's say there was a thousand dinars for example.We would say; distribute dinars by twos, threes and fours. If you made your statement in the singular form then it would have no meaning. So the expression twos, threes and fours is inevitable so that each individual can choose what He wants from the specific number in the expression. So when Allah (swt) says each one of you can marry the woman of his choice two, three or four, this effectively means: marry all of you twos, threes or fours. i.e. each of you can marry two, three or four. As for the meaning of his (swt) saying:
“Lakini mkihofu kwamba hamtaweza kutenda haki (kwao), basi oeni mke mmoja tu” [An-Nisaa: 3]. Hii inamaanisha kwamba mkihofu kwamba hamtaweza kutenda haki kwa idadi hii ya wake, basi mchague mke mmoja tu, na mwache mara moja ndoa ya wake zaidi ya mmoja. Jambo linahusu haki. Mahali popote mnapoona haki ipo, shikamaneni nayo. Kuoa mke mmoja tu kunakaribia zaidi kutokufanya dhuluma. Ili msiende upande (wa njia iliyo sahihi) maana yake ni kwamba ni bora zaidi, ili msifanye dhuluma, kwa kuwa kupotoka hapa ni dhuluma. Inasemekana kwamba mtawala amepotoka kutoka njia iliyo sahihi anapofanya dhuluma. ‘Aisha (ra) alisimulia kuhusu Mtume ﷺ kwamba alisema: “Ili msiende upande (wa njia iliyo sahihi): ili msifanye dhuluma.” Aya inaruhusu wake wengi na kuweka kikomo cha wanne. Hata hivyo, inaamuru haki baina yao, na inaelekeza kikomo cha mke mmoja pale inapohofiwa kwamba kutakuwa na dhuluma, kwa kuwa kuwekewa kikomo cha mke mmoja pale kunapohofiwa kufanyika dhuluma kunakaribia zaidi kuepuka dhuluma, jambo ambalo Mwislamu analazimika kulifanya.
“But if you fear that you shall not be able to deal justly (with them), then marry only one” [An- Nisa: 3] This means that if you fear that you shall not be able deal with these numbers of wives justly then you should simply choose one wife and relinquish the marriage to more than one wife immediately. The issue revolves around justice. Wherever you find it just, adhere to it. Marrying only one wife is closer to not doing injustice. So that you should not deviate (from the right course of action) means it is more fitting so that you do not do injustice, because the deviation here means injustice. It is said the ruler has deviated from the right course when He has committed injustice. 'Aisha (ra) narrated about the Prophet (pbuh) that He said: “So that you may not deviate (from the right course): so that you do not make injustice.” The Ayah permits the plurality of wives and limits it to four. However, it orders justice between them and enjoins the restriction to one wife when it is feared there would be injustice, because the restriction to one wife when there is fear of committing injustice is closer to avoiding injustice, a matter for which a Muslim is obliged.
Ni muhimu kujua kwamba haki iliyotajwa hapa si sharti la kuoa zaidi ya mke mmoja. Badala yake, ni hukumu kwa mwanaume anayetaka kuoa wake kadhaa, ambayo lazima aizingatie endapo ataoa zaidi ya mke mmoja, pamoja na wito wa kujizuia kwa mke mmoja ikiwa anaogopa kwamba hataweza kuwatendea haki. Hii ni kwa sababu maana ya sentensi inakamilika katika aya kupitia kauli yake ﷺ: "Oeni wanawake mnaowapenda, wawili au watatu au wanne" [4:3]. Hii inamaanisha kwamba kuoa zaidi ya mke mmoja kumehalalishwa bila masharti. Hivyo, maana ya sentensi inakamilika. Katika kauli nyingine, Allah (SWT) amesema: "Lakini mkiogopa". Maneno "Lakini mkiogopa" hayawezi kuwa sharti kwa sababu hayajaunganishwa na aya ya kwanza kama kifungu cha masharti. Badala yake, ni mwendelezo wa kauli mpya. Kama Allah angetaka liwe sharti, angesema: "Oeni wanawake mnaowapenda, wawili au watatu au wanne ikiwa mnaweza kuwatendea haki", lakini hilo si lililosemwa. Kwa hiyo imethibitika kwamba haki si sharti, bali ni hukumu nyingine ya Shariʿa tofauti na hukumu ya kwanza. Kwanza, Allah aliruhusu kuoa wake wengi hadi wanne, kisha akaleta hukumu nyingine, nayo ni kwamba ni bora kujizuia kwa mke mmoja pale mtu anapoamini kwamba kuoa zaidi ya mmoja kutamfanya ashindwe kuwatendea haki kwa uadilifu.
Indeed it should be known that the justice mentioned here is not a condition for marrying more than one wife. Rather it is a ruling for the man who wishes to marry a number of wives, that He must observe in the event of marrying more than one wife, and an exhortation to restrict Himself to one wife if He fears He will not be able to deal with them justly. This is because the meaning of the sentence is completed in the verse by his (pbuh) saying: “Marry women of your choice, twos or threes, or four”. [4:3] this means there is an absolute permissibility of marrying more than one wife. Thus, the meaning of the sentence is completed. In another statement, He (pbuh) said: “But if you fear”. The phrase “But if you fear” cannot result in being a condition because it is not linked with the first verse as a conditional clause. Rather it is a resumption of a new statement. If Allah had wished to make it a condition then He would have said: “Marry women of your choice, twos or threes, or fours if you can deal with them justly”, but that is not the case, so it is established that justice is not a condition, rather it is another Shar’a ruling different to the first rule. So firstly He permitted the plurality of marriages up to four, then He came with another ruling which is that it is better to restrict oneself to one wife when He believes that marriage to more than one wife will make Him incapable of dealing with them in a just manner.
Kutokana na yaliyotangulia, inadhihirika wazi kwamba Allah (swt) ameruhusu ndoa ya wake wengi bila kikomo, sharti wala kutegemea sababu yoyote ya kuhalalisha. Badala yake, kila Muislamu amepewa haki ya kuoa wake wawili, watatu au wanne, kwa kuchagua mwenyewe. Ndiyo maana tunamwona Allah (swt) akisema: "wanawake mnaowapenda" [4:3], yaani wale wanawake ambao unawaona wanakufaa. Ni wazi kwamba Allah (swt) ametuamuru kuwa wenye haki baina ya wake zetu, na ametuonya kwamba ikiwa tunaogopa kutoweza kuwatendea haki wake zetu, basi tujizuie kuwa na mke mmoja tu, kwa sababu kizuizi cha kuoa mke mmoja kinatufanya tuwe mbali zaidi na kutenda dhulma.
From the above it becomes clear that Allah (swt) has permitted polygyny without restriction, condition or any recourse to any justification. Rather, every Muslim is given the right to marry two, three or four wives of his choice. That is why we find Allah (swt) saying: “women of your choice” [4:3] i.e. those women whom you find agreeable to you. It is clear that Allah (swt) has ordered us to be just between our wives and exhorted us that if we fear we could not be able to do justice between our wives, we restrict ourselves to just one wife because the restriction of marrying one wife make us more likely not to commit injustice.
Kuhusu kile kinachojumuisha haki ya usawa inayotakiwa kati ya wake, si "usawa kamili". Badala yake, ni usawa katika ndoa kati ya wake ambao uko ndani ya uwezo wa mwanamume kuutekeleza, kwa sababu Allah hamlazimishi mtu kile ambacho hawezi kukibeba. Amesema (SWT):
As for what constitutes desired justice between wives, it is not 'absolute justice'. Rather it is the justice in marriage between wives which is within the ability of the man to undertake, because Allah does not impose on man that which He cannot bear. He (swt) said:
"Allah haimlemei nafsi yoyote zaidi ya uwezo wake" [Al-Baqarah: 286]. Ni kweli kwamba neno 'kuwa wa haki' limetajwa katika aya hiyo kwa maana ya jumla, kama alivyosema (SWT):
“Allah burdens not a person beyond his scope” [Al- Baqarah: 286] It is true that the phrase 'be just' has been mentioned in the verse with a general import, as He (swt) says:
"Lakini ikiwa mnaogopa kwamba hamtaweza kufanya uadilifu (kwao)" [An-Nisa: 3] Hili linajumuisha vipengele vyote vya uadilifu, lakini amri hii ya jumla imefafanuliwa katika aya nyingine kwa kuzingatia kile ambacho mwanadamu ana uwezo wa kukifanya. Hivyo, Allah (SWT) amesema:
“But if you fear that you shall not be able to deal justly (with them)” [An- Nisa: 3] This encompasses all aspects of justice, but this general order has been specified in another verse to what the human has the capability to do. Thus, Allah (swt) said:
"Hutaweza kamwe kutenda haki kamili kati ya wake zako hata kama hilo ni hamu yako kuu, basi usielekee kabisa kwa mmoja wao kiasi cha kumwacha mwingine akiwa ametundikwa katikati" [An-Nisa: 129] Allah (SWT) ameweka wazi katika aya hii kwamba haiwezekani kwetu kufikia haki na usawa kamili kati ya wake, kiasi kwamba mwelekeo kwa mmoja wao usitokee kamwe, wala kuongezeka au kupungua kwa kile kinachotulazimu katika kuwatunza. Kwa sababu hiyo, Yeye (SWT) ameturahisishia kutokana na ukamilifu wote wa haki, wala hakutuwekea jukumu isipokuwa lile ambalo mtu anaweza kulibeba, kwa sharti kwamba tujitahidi kwa juhudi na nguvu zetu zote. Kwani kulazimishwa jambo ambalo mtu hawezi kulifanya ni sawa na dhuluma:
“You will never be able to do perfect justice between wives even if it is your ardent desire, so do not incline completely to one of them so as to leave the other suspended” [An- Nisa: 129] Allah (swt) has clarified in the verse that it is impossible for us to realise justice and equality between wives, such that no inclination (towards one of them) would ever happen nor increase or decrease in what is obligatory upon us in providing for them. Due to this He (swt) has lifted from us the complete and full extent of justice and He (swt) has not imposed on us except that which one can bear on condition that we exert our utmost effort and energy. For the imposition of what one is not able to do is tantamount to oppression:
"Na Mola wako hamfanyii mtu yeyote dhuluma" [Al-Kahf: 49] Naye (SWT) anasema:
“And your Lord treats no one with oppression” [Al-Kahf: 49] And He (swt) says:
“Basi msimwegemee kabisa mmoja wao” [An-Nisa: 129] kama ufafanuzi wa kauli yake (SWT): “Hamtaweza kamwe kufanya uadilifu kamili” [An-Nisa: 129], na kama ushahidi wake, ni dalili kwamba maana yake ni: hamtaweza kamwe kuwatendea kwa haki na usawa kwa upande wa mapenzi. Ufahamu sahihi ni kwamba inawezekana kuwa mwadilifu katika kila jambo isipokuwa mapenzi. Hii ndiyo aya iliyotangulia inayolazimisha, kwani imebainisha kuwa uadilifu unaotakiwa ni tofauti na mapenzi, na imeyatenga mapenzi na tendo la ndoa kutoka katika uadilifu, kwa sababu hayalazimishwi katika mambo haya mawili, kwa kuwa mwanadamu hawezi kuwa sawa katika mapenzi yake. Maana hii inaungwa mkono na yaliyopokewa kutoka kwa 'Aisha (ra) kwamba alisema: “Mjumbe wa Allah ﷺ alikuwa akigawa mambo na kutenda haki kwa wote, na alikuwa akisema: ‘Ee Mola wangu, hii ndiyo mgawanyo wangu wa yale yaliyo chini ya uwezo wangu, lakini usinilaumu kwa yale yaliyo chini ya uwezo Wako nisiyoyamiliki’”, yaani moyo wake. Imepokewa kutoka kwa Ibn 'Abbas (ra) kuhusu kauli ya Allah (SWT):
“So do not incline completely to one of them” [An- Nisa: 129] as a comment on his (swt) saying: “You will never be able to do perfect justice” [An- Nisa: 129] and as a reference for it, is an evidence that its meaning is: you will never be able to deal with them justly and equally with regards to love. The correct understanding is that it is possible to be just in everything other than love. This is what the previous verse obliges, as it has specified the desired justice to be other than love, and made love and sexual intercourse excluded from justice, because it is not obliged in these two issues, since a human is not able to be equal in his love. This meaning is supported by what has been reported about 'Aisha (ra) that she said: “The Messenger of Allah used to distribute things and do justice to all and used to say, “Oh My God, this is my distribution of what is in my control, but do not blame me for what is in Your control and over which I have no control”. i.e. his heart. It has been narrated from Ibn 'Abbas (ra) concerning the saying of Allah (swt):
“Hamtaweza kamwe kufanya uadilifu kamili baina ya wake” [An-Nisa: 129]. Alisema: “hili linahusu mapenzi na tendo la ndoa.” Allah (SWT) ametuamuru tujiepushe kabisa na kuelekea upande mmoja wa mke mmoja. Hii ina maana kwamba Yeye ameruhusu kuelekea (kwa mke mmoja kwa kiasi), kwa kuwa katazo la kuelekea kabisa linaashiria kuruhusiwa kwa kuelekea huko. Mfano wa hili ni katazo la ukarimu usiozuiliwa na wa kupita kiasi lililotajwa katika kauli yake (SWT):
“You will never be able to do perfect justice between wives” [An- Nisa: 129]. He said “this is with regards to love and sexual intercourse.” Allah (swt) has ordered us to abstain from completely inclining towards one wife. This means He has permitted the inclination because the prohibition of the complete inclination indicates the permissibility of the inclination. An illustration of this is the prohibition of unrestrained and excessive generosity mentioned in his (swt) saying:
“Wala usinyooshe mkono wako hadi kikomo chake” [Al-Isra: 29]. Maana yake ni kwamba inaruhusiwa kunyoosha mkono wako kwa kutoa kwa wenye uhitaji. Kwa hiyo, Allah (SWT) amemruhusu mume kuelekea zaidi kwa baadhi ya wake zake kwa kuwaacha wengine. Hata hivyo, ameharamisha mwelekeo huu kuhusu mambo yote. Badala yake, mwelekeo huo unapaswa kuwa kwa lile ambalo mwelekeo huu unahusika nalo, ambalo ni mapenzi na hamu. Kwa hiyo maana ya aya ni: jiepushe na mwelekeo kamili kwa mke mmoja, kwa sababu ikiwa mwelekeo kamili utatoka kwako, utamwacha mke mwingine akiwa amening'inia, yaani, asiye aliyeachwa wala mwenye mume. Imepokewa kutoka kwa Abu Hurayra (ra) kwamba Mtume ﷺ alisema: “Yeyote aliye na wake wawili, akaelekea kwa mmoja wao kwa kumwacha mwingine, atakuja Siku ya Kiyama akiwa nusu ya mwili wake umeanguka au umeinama chini.”
“Nor stretch your hand forth to its utmost reach” [Al- Isra: 29] Which means it is permitted to stretch your hand by giving to the needy. Therefore, Allah (swt) has permitted the husband to incline towards some of his wives to the exclusion of others. However, He has forbidden this inclination to include all matters. Rather, the inclination should be to whatever this inclination applies, which is the love and desire. So the meaning of the verse is: refrain from the absolute inclination towards a wife, because if the complete inclination occurs from you, it will leave the other wife suspended, i.e. one who is neither divorced nor possessing a husband. It has been narrated by Abu Hurayra (ra) that the Prophet (pbuh) said: “Whosoever has two wives and He inclines towards one to the exclusion of the other, He will come on the Day of Judgement with half his body dropping or bending down”.
Hivyo basi, haki ya lazima kwa mume ni usawa kati ya wake zake katika mambo yale ambayo yako chini ya uwezo wake, kama vile kulala usiku, kuwapa chakula, mavazi na makazi n.k. Kuhusu yale yanayoangukia maana ya mwelekeo wa moyo, ambayo ni mapenzi na hamu, si lazima kuwa mwadilifu katika mambo haya kwa sababu hilo haliwezekani, na Qur'ani imeyatenga.
Thus, the justice which is obligatory upon a husband is the equality between his wives in that which He has control over such as staying overnight, providing food, clothing and lodging etc. As for what falls under the meaning of inclination, which is love and desire, It is not obligatory to be just in these things because that is impossible, and they are excluded by the Qur'an.
Hili ni somo la mitala kama lilivyotajwa katika matini za Shari'a. Kwa kusoma matini hizi na kujizuia na maana zake za Shari'a na za lugha, kwa mujibu wa anachoashiria na kinachotolewa kutoka kwake, inadhihirika kwamba Allah (SWT) ameruhusu kwa ujumla ndoa ya zaidi ya mke mmoja (hadi wanne) bila kizuizi wala sharti. Matini inayohusu jambo hili haikuwa na sababu ya kuruhusu ('Illa). Kinyume chake, Allah (SWT) amejieleza kwa namna inayoashiria kukataa kuwepo kwa sababu ya kuhalalisha. Kwa hiyo amesema:
This is the subject of polygyny as mentioned in the Shar’a texts. By studying these texts and limiting oneself to their Shar’a and linguistic meanings in terms of what they indicate and what is deduced from them, it becomes clear that Allah (swt) has in a general manner permitted the marriage to more than one wife (up to four) without restriction or condition. The text concerning this matter did not include any cause ('Illa). On the contrary, Allah (swt) has expressed Himself in a way which indicates the rejection of a justification. So He (swt) said:
“(Oa) wanawake wa chaguo lenu”. [An-Nisa: 3] Kwa hiyo, lazima tusimame kwenye mpaka wa maandiko ya Shar'a na kwenye yale yanayotokana nayo kwa upande wa hukumu ya Shari'ah. Hairuhusiwi kuhalalisha hukumu hii kwa sababu yoyote ('Illa), au kuihalalisha kwa haki, mahitaji au kitu kingine chochote, kwa sababu maandiko hayakuleta 'Illa kwa hukumu hiyo, wala sababu yoyote (Illa) haiwezi kupatikana katika maandiko mengine yoyote ya Shar'a. 'Illa ya hukumu inapaswa kuwa sababu ya Shar'a, yaani, lazima kuwe na maandiko yanayoitaja ili hukumu inayotokana nayo iweze kuchukuliwa kwa usahihi kuwa hukumu ya Shar'a. Ikiwa sababu ni ya kimantiki au haijatajwa katika maandiko yoyote, basi hukumu inayotolewa kwa njia yake haitakuwa hukumu ya Shar'a. Badala yake, itakuwa sheria ya kibinadamu, na kuipitisha itakuwa Haramu, wala haitaruhusiwa kuitekeleza. Hii ni kwa sababu itakuwa hukumu ya Kufr, kwani hukumu yoyote isiyokuwa hukumu ya Shar'a ni hukumu ya Kufr. Hata hivyo, kwa kuwa ufafanuzi wa Hukm Shar'i (hukumu ya Shari'ah) kuwa 'kauli ya Mwekaji Sheria' unafanya ilazimu kwamba hukumu inatokana na kauli ya Mwekaji Sheria, ama imetajwa wazi katika maandiko, au kutokana na maana yake, au kwa dalili, au kutokana na kuwepo kwa ishara (Amara) katika maandiko inayoashiria hukumu ya Shar'a, kiasi kwamba kila hukumu yenye ishara hiyo itakuwa hukumu ya kiungu. Ishara hii (Amara) ndiyo sababu ya Shar'a (Illa Shar'iyya) inayotajwa katika maandiko, ama wazi au kwa dalili, kwa hoja au kwa kulinganisha. Ikiwa ishara hii (Amara), yaani Illah hii, haipatikani katika maandiko, basi haina thamani. Kwa hiyo, inadhihirika kwamba hairuhusiwi kuhalalisha mitala kwa sababu (Illa) kwa kuwa hakuna Illa inayopatikana katika kauli ya Mwekaji Sheria. Illa haina thamani ya kufanya hukumu kuwa hukumu ya Shar'a isipokuwa pale inapopatikana katika kauli ya Mwekaji Sheria.
“(Marry) women of your choice”. [An- Nisa: 3] Therefore, we must stop at the limit of the Shar’a text and at what is derived from it in terms of Shari’ah rule. It is not permitted to justify this rule with any cause ('Illa), or justify it with justice, need or anything else, because the text did not bring 'Illa for the rule nor can any reason (Illa) be found in any other Shar’a text. The cause (Illa) of the rule should be a Shar’a reason i.e. there must be a text to mention it so that the rule which is derived from it can correctly be considered a Shar’a rule. If the reason is rational or not mentioned in any text, then the rule which is derived by means of it will not be a Shar’a rule. Rather it will be a man-made law and it will be Haram to adopt, nor will it be permitted to apply it. This is because it will be a Kufr rule, since any rule which is not a Shar’a rule is a Kufr rule. However, since the definition of the Hukm Shar'i (Shari’ah rule) being 'the speech of the Legislator' makes it inevitable that the rule is derived from the speech of the Legislator, either explicitly mentioned in the text, or from its meaning, or by indication, or due to the presence of a sign (Amara) in the text which points to the Shar’a rule, such that every rule which has that sign (Amara) will be a divine rule. This sign (Amara) is the Shar’a reason (Illa Shar'iyya) which is mentioned in the text either explicitly or by indication, inference or analogy. If this sign (Amara) i.e. this Illah is not found in the text then it has no value. Consequently, it becomes clear that it is not allowed to justify polygyny with reason (Illa) since no Illa is found in the speech of the Legislator. An Illa has no value in making a rule into a Shar’a rule except when it is found in the speech of the Legislator.
Hata hivyo, kutokuwepo kwa maelezo ya hukumu ya Shari'a kwa kutumia 'Illa hakumaanishi kwamba haiwezekani kueleza uhalisia wa kile kitakachotokea kwa mujibu wa athari ya hukumu hii ya Shari'a, na uhalisia wa kile inachotatua katika matatizo. Bali hili ni maelezo ya uhalisia, wala si uhalali wa hukumu. Tofauti kati ya kueleza uhalisia na kuhalalisha hukumu ni kwamba kuhalalisha hukumu kwa 'Illa kunamaanisha kwamba 'Illa hiyo inapaswa kuwepo daima katika hukumu, na kulinganisha mambo mengine na hukumu hii hufanyika kila 'Illa inapopatikana ndani yake. Kwa upande wa kueleza uhalisia, hii ni kufafanua uhalisia wakati ulipo wakati wa kuelezwa. Uhalisia huo unaweza kukoma, hivyo si sahihi kufanya kulinganisha nao na mambo mengine. Hivyo, inadhihirika kutokana na athari ya mitala kwamba katika jamii ambayo inaruhusu mitala hakutakuwa na wingi wa wanawake wasio rasmi (masuria), na katika jamii zinazokataza wake wengi kutakuwa na wingi wa masuria. Zaidi ya hayo, mitala hutatua matatizo mengine mengi yanayotokea katika jamii ya kibinadamu kama jamii ya kibinadamu, ambayo hutegemea mitala ili kuyatatua. Yafuatayo ni baadhi ya mifano ya matatizo haya:
However, the absence of an explanation of a Shar’a rule by an Illa does not mean it is not permitted to explain the reality of what will take place in terms of the effect of this Shar’a rule and the reality of what it solves in terms of problems. Rather this is an explanation of a reality and not justification for a rule. The difference between explaining the reality and justifying a rule, is that the justification of a rule by an Illa, is that the Illa should constantly exist in the rule, and analogy of other things to this rule is made whenever the 'Illa is found in them. As for explaining the reality this is the clarification of the reality at the point in time when it is explained. The reality may cease, so it is incorrect to make an analogy to it with other things. Hence, it becomes clear from the effect of polygyny of wives that in the community in which it is permitted there will not be a plurality of mistresses, and in communities which forbid the plurality of wives there will be a plurality of mistresses. In addition, polygyny solves many other problems, which take place in a human community in its capacity as a human community, which depends on polygyny to solve them. The following are some examples of these problems:
1. Kuna baadhi ya wanaume wenye tabia zisizo za kawaida, ambao hawawezi kujiridhisha kwa mke mmoja tu. Wanaume kama hao wanaweza kumdhulumu au kumuumiza mke wao pekee, au wanaweza kuwatazama wanawake wengine iwapo wataona mlango umefungwa mbele yao ili kuoa mke wa pili, wa tatu au wa nne. Kuna hatari ya hili kutokea kwa sababu ya kuenea kwa uchafu na zinaa miongoni mwa watu, na kwa sababu ya kuzua shaka na wasiwasi ndani ya familia. Kwa hiyo, ni muhimu sana kwa mtu mwenye tabia kama hiyo kupata nafasi ya kutimiza hamu yake kubwa kwa njia halali, yaani kwa njia ambayo Allah (SWT) ameiwekea sheria.
1. There are some men with unusual dispositions, who are unable to satisfy themselves with one wife. Either such men will oppress or hurt their only wife or they will look at other women if they find the door shut in front of them to take a second, third or fourth wife. There is a danger of this happening in terms of the spread of indecency and fornication amongst people and the creation of suspicion and doubts within families. Therefore, it is essential that a person who possesses such a disposition should have the opportunity to satisfy his strong urge in a halal manner i.e. in a way that Allah (swt) has legislated.
2. Huenda mwanamke akawa tasa (hawezi kuzaa), kwa hiyo hawezi kupata watoto, lakini mumewe bado anampenda sana, na kinyume chake pia; jambo linalowafanya wadhamirie kuendelea na maisha yao ya ndoa yenye furaha. Hata hivyo, mume anaweza kutamani kuwa na watoto na kuwapenda watoto. Ikiwa hairuhusiwi kwake kuoa mke mwingine, na hapati njia nyingine yoyote, atalazimika ama kumpa talaka mke wake wa kwanza, jambo ambalo lingeleta uharibifu wa utulivu wa nyumba na kumaliza ndoa yenye furaha, au kunyimwa furaha ya kuwa na watoto. Hili litasababisha kukandamizwa kwa upande wa ubaba uliopo katika silika ya uzazi. Kwa hiyo, ni muhimu kwamba mwenzi wa namna hii apewe fursa ya kuoa mke mwingine pamoja na mke aliyepo ili aweze kupata watoto anaowatamani.
2. It may be that a woman is barren and therefore cannot bear children but her husband still loves her dearly and vice versa, which makes them determined to continue with their happy married life. The husband may however desire offspring and have a love for children. If it is not permitted for Him to marry another wife and He finds no options available to Him He will have to either divorce his first wife, which would lead to the destruction of the stability of the household and the end of a happy marriage, or He is deprived from enjoying offspring. This will lead to the suppression of the aspect of fatherhood present in the procreation instinct. Therefore, it is essential that such a spouse is given the opportunity to marry another wife in addition to the existing wife so that He can have the offspring which He desires.
3. Mke anaweza kuwa na ugonjwa unaomzuia kutimiza tendo la ndoa au kusimamia nyumba, kumhudumia mume na watoto. Hata hivyo, anaweza bado kupendwa sana na kuthaminiwa na mume wake, ambaye hana nia ya kumwacha, lakini hawezi kuishi maisha yake vizuri akiwa na mke huyo peke yake, na hivyo anahitaji mke mwingine. Katika hali kama hii ni lazima apewe fursa ya kuoa zaidi ya mke mmoja.
3. The wife may be ill with a disease, which excuses her from having conjugal relations or looking after the house and seeing to the husband and children. She might still be cherished and dearly loved by her husband who might have no wish to divorce her, although He cannot live his life properly with just her alone, and consequently without another wife. It is imperative that in such a situation the opportunity is given to Him to marry more than one wife.
4. Vita na maasi vinaweza kutokea na kuua maelfu, hata mamilioni ya wanaume, jambo ambalo linaweza kuvuruga usawa kati ya idadi ya wanaume na wanawake, kama ilivyotokea kweli, hasa barani Ulaya, katika Vita vya Kwanza na Vita vya Pili vya Dunia. Iwapo mwanaume hawezi kuoa zaidi ya mke mmoja, basi wanawake waliobaki wanapaswa kufanya nini? Watanyimwa maisha ya kifamilia na furaha ya nyumba, pamoja na starehe na faraja ya maisha ya ndoa, bila kusahau kile silika ya kuzaliana inaweza kusababisha kwa upande wa hatari kwa maadili.
4. Wars and uprisings might take place which claim the lives of thousands, even millions of men which may upset the balance between the numbers of men and women, as has happened actually, especially in Europe, in the First and Second World War. If a man is not able to marry more than one wife what are the rest of the women supposed to do? They will be deprived from family life and the happiness of a home and the ease and comfort of married life, not to mention what the procreation instinct can lead to in terms of the danger to morality.
5. Huenda ikawa kwamba katika taifa, watu au eneo, idadi ya wanaume na wanawake si sawa. Idadi ya wanawake inaweza kuwa kubwa kuliko ya wanaume, hivyo usawa wa kiidadi kati ya wanaume na wanawake unavurugika. Hali hii ni karibu ya kawaida kwa watu na mataifa mengi. Katika hali kama hiyo, hakuna suluhisho la tatizo hili isipokuwa kuruhusiwa kwa ndoa ya mke zaidi ya mmoja.
5. It may be that in a nation, people or region the number of males and females is not equal. The number of females may be higher than males so the numerical balance between men and women is upset. And this is almost the case amongst many peoples and nations. In such a situation there is no solution to this problem except the permissibility of polygyny.
Hizi ni changamoto halisi zinazowakabili wanadamu katika jamii na mataifa. Ikiwa ndoa ya wake wengi itapigwa marufuku, changamoto hizi zitaendelea kuwepo, kwa kuwa hakuna suluhisho la changamoto hizi isipokuwa kwa kuruhusu ndoa ya wake wengi. Kwa hiyo, ndoa ya wake wengi inapaswa kuruhusiwa ili changamoto ambazo wanadamu wanakabiliana nazo zishughulikiwe. Kwa hakika, Uislamu umeruhusu ndoa ya wake wengi lakini haujaifanya kuwa lazima. Uhalali wa ndoa ya wake wengi ni jambo lisiloepukika, ingawa inapaswa kufahamika kwamba hali zilizoelezwa hapo juu na zinazofanana nazo, ambazo zinaweza kuwepo kati ya wanadamu na katika jamii za binadamu, ni changamoto halisi zinazotokea, lakini hazina nafasi ya sababu (Illa) ya kuoa zaidi ya mke mmoja, wala si sharti la kuhalalisha ndoa ya wake wengi. Badala yake, mwanamume anaruhusiwa kuoa mke wa pili, wa tatu na wa nne, iwe changamoto zinazohitaji ndoa ya wake wengi kama suluhisho zimejitokeza au hazijajitokeza. Kwa sababu Allah (SWT) anasema:
These are real problems faced in the human community among peoples and nations. If polygyny is outlawed then such problems remain, since there is no solution for these problems except through allowing polygyny. Hence, polygyny should be permitted so that these problems which humans face are dealt with. Indeed Islam has permitted polygyny but has not obliged it. The permissibility of polygyny is inevitable although it should be known that the situations outlined above and their like which may exist among humans and in human societies are real problems which occur but they are not an Illa (cause) for marrying more than one wife nor are they a condition for the permissibility of polygyny. Rather, the man is allowed to marry a second, third and fourth wife whether problems which require polygyny as a solution has arisen or not. Because Allah (swt) says:
“Oeni wanawake mnaowapenda, wawili au watatu au wanne” [An-Nisa: 3] Na Yeye (SWT) amesema: “mnaowapenda”. Yeye (SWT) ameifanya kauli hii kuwa ya jumla bila kizuizi wala sharti. Kuhusu kizuizi cha kuoa mke mmoja, Shari‘ah imependelea hilo katika hali moja tu, nayo ni pale kunapokuwa na hofu kwamba mtu hataweza kuwatendea wake zake haki. Kwa kisichokuwa hicho, hakuna upendeleo wazi wa kuoa mke mmoja tu katika matini yoyote. Licha ya ukweli kwamba ndoa ya wake wengi ni hukumu ya Shari‘ah iliyo katika matini wazi ya Qur’ani, utamaduni wa Kibepari na propaganda za Magharibi, hasa dhidi ya Uislamu ikilinganishwa na dini nyingine, zimeonyesha kuoa zaidi ya mke mmoja kuwa jambo chafu na la kuchukiza, na kuliwasilisha kama kasoro na chanzo cha aibu katika Dini. Sababu ya hilo si kwamba kasoro imeonekana katika sheria za Allah (SWT), bali ni kwa ajili ya kuidharau Uislamu, na hakuna nia nyingine isipokuwa hiyo. Propaganda hii imewaathiri sana Waislamu, hasa tabaka tawala na vijana wenye elimu. Hali hiyo iliwasukuma wale waliohamasishwa na hisia za Kiislamu kusimama kuutetea Uislamu. Waislamu hao walikubali tafsiri potofu za kukataza ndoa ya wake wengi, hivyo kwa kweli walishawishiwa na propaganda za uongo zilizoenezwa na maadui wa Uislamu. Ndiyo maana ni lazima tuwaonye Waislamu kwamba jambo zuri (Hasan) ni lile ambalo Shari‘ah inalichukulia kuwa zuri (Hasan), na jambo baya (Qabeeh) ni lile ambalo Shari‘ah inalichukulia kuwa baya (Qabeeh); kila kitu ambacho Shari‘ah inakiruhusu ni kizuri (Hasan), na kila kitu ambacho Shari‘ah inakikataza ni kibaya (Qabeeh). Pia tunapaswa kuwaonya Waislamu kwamba ndoa ya wake wengi, iwe ina manufaa yanayoonekana au la, na iwe inatatua matatizo yaliyotokea au la, Shari‘ah imeiruhusu, na Qur’ani imeeleza hilo wazi. Kwa hiyo ni jambo zuri, na kuzuia ndoa ya wake wengi ni jambo baya, kwa sababu ni hukumu ya Ukafiri. Ni lazima ieleweke wazi kwamba Uislamu haukufanya ndoa ya wake wengi kuwa Fardh kwa Waislamu, wala Mandub (inayopendekezwa). Badala yake, uliifanya kuwa miongoni mwa mambo yaliyoruhusiwa, ambayo ni halali kwao kuyafanya iwapo watapenda kufanya hivyo. Kitendo cha Uislamu kuifanya ruhusa inamaanisha kwamba umewawekea watu suluhisho ambalo wanaweza kulitumia wakati wowote itakapokuwa lazima kufanya hivyo, na umewaruhusu wasijinyime wanawake wa chaguo lao iwapo wataona kwamba mioyo yao inawaelekea. Hivyo, kuruhusu ndoa ya wake wengi bila kuifanya kuwa ya lazima ndiko kunakoifanya kuwa mojawapo ya suluhisho madhubuti zaidi kwa binadamu katika jamii na jamii pana.
“Marry women of your choice, two or three, or four” [An- Nisa: 3] And He (swt) said: “of your choice”. He (swt) has made this general without restriction or condition. As for the restriction of marrying one wife, the Shari’ah has preferred this in only one situation, which is where there is a fear that one is not able to do justice between his wives. As for anything other than that, there is no expressed preference to marry only one in any of the texts. In spite of the fact that polygyny is a Shar’a ruling found in the clear text of the Qur'an, Capitalist culture and Western propaganda, particularly that against Islam as opposed to other religions, has portrayed marriage to more than one wife as a hideous and repugnant practice and depicted it as a deficiency and a source of shame in the Deen. The motive for this is not because a defect has been noticed in the laws of Allah (swt) but in order to disparage Islam, and there is no motive for it other than this. This propaganda has greatly affected Muslims, particularly the ruling faction and the educated youth. This drove those who were moved by Islamic emotions to stand for Islam. Such Muslims adopted false interpretations to forbid polygyny, thus they were actually influenced by the false propaganda circulated by the enemies of Islam. That is why we must warn the Muslims that pretty actions (Hasan) are what the Shar’a deems to be pretty (Hasan) and ugly actions (Qabeeh) are what the Shar’a deems to be ugly (Qabeeh), and whatever the Shar’a permits is pretty (Hasan) and whatever the Shar’a forbids is ugly (Qabeeh). Also we must warn the Muslims that polygyny, whether it has a tangible good effect or not, and whether it solves problems which have occurred or not, the Shari’ah has permitted it, and the Qur'an has stated that clearly. Therefore it is a pretty action and the prohibition of polygyny is ugly, because it is a Kufr rule. It must be made clear that Islam did not make polygyny Fard on the Muslims nor Mandub (preferred). Rather, it made it one of the permissible things, which is allowed for them to do if they wished to do so. The fact that Islam made it permissible means that it has placed before the people a solution that they can use whenever it is necessary to do so, and it has permitted them not to deprive themselves from the women of their choice if in their view they were to incline towards them. Thus, permitting polygyny and not making it obligatory is what makes it one of the most effective solutions for humans in the community and society.