1 Maana ya Ustaarabu (Hadhara)
1 The Meaning of Civilisation (Hadhara)
Ustaarabu (hadhara) ni mkusanyiko wa dhana kuhusu maisha.
A civilisation (hadhara) is a collection of concepts about life.
Ustaarabu unaweza kuwa wa kiroho wa kimungu (deeniyya ilahiyya) au wa kibinadamu (wadh'iyya bashariyya). Ustaarabu wa kiroho wa kimungu hutokana na itikadi ('aqeedah), kama vile ustaarabu wa Kiislamu unaotokana na 'aqeedah ya Kiislamu. Kuhusu ustaarabu wa kibinadamu, unaweza kutokana na itikadi, kama vile ustaarabu wa Kimagharibi wa Kibepari, ambao ni mkusanyiko wa dhana kuhusu maisha zinazotokana na itikadi ya kutenganisha dini na maisha. Au unaweza usitokane na itikadi, kama vile ustaarabu wa Kishinto, Kigiriki, Kibabiloni na Kiashuru. Ustaarabu huu ni mkusanyiko wa dhana ambazo watu fulani au kundi la watu wamekubaliana juu yake, hivyo ni ustaarabu wa kitaifa (sh'abiyya) au wa kibinadamu.
Civilisation could be a spiritual divine one (deeniyya ilahiyya) or man-made (wadh'iyya bashariyya). The spiritual divine civilisation emanates from a doctrine (‘’’aqeedah); like the Islamic civilisation that emanates from the Islamic ‘’aqeedah. As for the man-made civilisation, either it emanates from a doctrine like the Capitalist Western civilisation that is a collection of concepts about life emanating from the doctrine of separating religion from life. Or it does not emanate from a doctrine like the Shinto, Greek, Babylonian and Assyrian civilisations. This civilisation is a collection of concepts that a people or a group of peoples agreed upon so it is a national (sh'abiyya) or man-made civilisation.
Zaidi ya hayo, watu au makundi ya watu wanaweza kuwa na dini (deen) na itikadi yoyote, lakini dini hiyo haina mawazo kuhusu maisha kama ilivyo kwa Ukristo na Ubuddha. Hivyo watu hukubaliana juu ya mawazo ya maisha yanayowahusu wao wenyewe, na mawazo hayo ndiyo huunda ustaarabu wao, bila kuwa na uhusiano wowote na dini yao, kwa sababu hayatokani nayo. Kwa hiyo ustaarabu wao si wa kimungu, licha ya kwamba wana dini. Kwa msingi huo, inawezekana kwa watu mbalimbali kuwa pamoja katika ustaarabu mmoja, licha ya tofauti za dini zao, kama vile Wajapani, Wahindu, Masikh na Wafaransa; dini zao ni tofauti lakini ustaarabu wao ni mmoja, yaani Ubepari.
In addition, a people or peoples could have a religion (deen) and a doctrine whatsoever, but this religion has no concepts about life like Christianity and Buddhism. So people agree on concepts about life specific to them, where these concepts form their civilisation without this having any relationship with their religion, because it does not emanate from it. So their civilisation is not divine despite the fact that they have a religion. Hence, it is possible for various peoples to associate in one civilisation, despite the difference of their religions like the Japanese, Hindus and Sikhs and French; their religions are different but their civilisation is one, namely Capitalism.
Vitu vya kimaada vinavyotumika katika mambo ya maisha si sehemu ya ustaarabu, ingawa wakati mwingine vinatokana nao. Hakuna pingamizi la kuyaita vitu hivi vya kimaada vinavyoonekana kwa istilahi ya "madaniyya", ili kuvitofautisha na mkusanyiko wa dhana ambao kwa ajili yake tulitumia neno "hadhara" (ustaarabu). Ikiwa vitu hivi vya kimaada vimetokana na ustaarabu fulani mahsusi, kama vile sanamu, basi ni sehemu ya madaniyya mahsusi ya ustaarabu huo. Lakini ikiwa vimetokana na sayansi na viwanda, basi ni vya madaniyya ya kimataifa, kama vile televisheni, roketi, ndege, penisilini na mengineyo. Hivyo basi, madaniyya inaweza kuwa mahsusi na inaweza kuwa ya kimataifa. Hili linapingana na ustaarabu, ambao hauwezi kuwa isipokuwa mahsusi. Maana ya umahsusi (khususiyya) inahusiana na kupitishwa kwetu. Kwa hiyo kile kilicho mahsusi hairuhusiwi kwetu kukipitisha kutoka kwa wengine, ilhali kile kilicho cha kimataifa kinaruhusiwa kwetu kukipitisha.
Material objects that are used in life's affairs are not part of civilisation even though they sometimes result from it. There is no objection to give the technical term of 'madaniyya' for these tangible material objects so as to distinguish them from the collection of concepts for which we used the term 'hadhara' (civilisation). If these material objects resulted from a specific civilisation like statues then they are part of specific madaniyya. However, if they resulted from science and industry, then they are of universal madaniyya, like the television, rockets, planes, penicillin etc. Thus madaniyya can be specific and it can be universal. This is contrary to civilisation that cannot be but specific. The meaning of specificity (khususiyya) is related to our adoption. So what is specific is not permitted for us to adopt from others, whereas what is universal is permitted for us to adopt.
Ni lazima kuzingatia tofauti kati ya hadhara (ustaarabu) na madaniyya (utamaduni wa kimaada) wakati wote, kama ilivyo lazima kuzingatia tofauti kati ya vitu vya kimaada vinavyotokana na hadhara na vitu vya kimaada vinavyotokana na sayansi na viwanda. Hii ni ili, wakati wa kuchukua madaniyya, tuzingatie tofauti kati ya vitu vyake, na tofauti kati yake na hadhara. Hakuna pingamizi katika kuchukua madaniyya ya Magharibi inayotokana na sayansi na viwanda. Kwa upande wa madaniyya ya Magharibi inayotokana na hadhara ya Magharibi, hairuhusiwi kuichukua kwa namna yoyote ile, kwa sababu inapingana na hadhara ya Kiislamu katika msingi unaojengwa juu yake, yaani itikadi (‘aqeedah). Itikadi yetu ni tofauti na itikadi yao, ambayo imejengwa juu ya suluhu ya maelewano na kutenganisha dini na maisha; katika taswira ya maisha ya dunia na kigezo cha matendo; ambacho kwetu ni halali na haramu, na kwao ni manufaa; na katika maana ya furaha, ambayo ni utulivu wa kudumu, ambao kwetu ni kupata radhi za Allah (SWT), na kwao ni starehe za kimwili.
The distinction between civilisation (hadhara) and madaniyya must be observed at all times, just as it is imperative to observe the distinction between the material objects derived from civilisation and the material objects derived from science and industry. That is in order to observe, when adopting madaniyya, the distinction between its objects, and the distinction between it and civilisation. There is no objection to adopting Western madaniyya derived from science and industry. As for Western madaniyya derived from Western civilisation, it is not permitted to adopt it in any case whatsoever due to its contradiction with the Islamic civilisation in the basis upon which it is built namely the doctrine (‘aqeedah). Our ‘aqeedah is different from their doctrine that is built upon the compromise solution and separating religion from life; in the depiction of worldly life or the criterion for actions; which is the halal and haram for us, and benefit for them; and in the meaning of happiness which is permanent tranquillity, which is - for us - attaining the pleasure of Allah, and for them the bodily pleasures.
Ili tuweze kufahamu kikamilifu kile tunachokubali kutoka kwa wengine na kile tunachokiacha, ni lazima tutofautishe kati ya ustaarabu (civilisation) na madaniyya, na ni lazima tutofautishe kati ya madaniyya inayotokana na dhana za kiustaarabu na madaniyya inayotokana na sayansi safi na viwanda.
In order that we become fully aware of what we adopt from others and what we leave, it is necessary to distinguish between civilisation and madaniyya, and it is necessary to distinguish between madaniyya resulting from civilisational concepts and madaniyya resulting from pure sciences and industry.
Swali linaweza kuulizwa hivi: Kwa nini ulichukua istilahi ya 'hadhara' kwa dhana, na istilahi ya 'madaniyya' kwa maumbo ya kimaada, badala ya kinyume chake? Kwa lugha, 'hadhara' ni makazi katika eneo lenye ustaarabu (kama miji), na 'al-hadhir' ni yule aliye wa miji na vijiji. Al-Qatami alisema: 'Mwenye kuridhika kuishi mijini. Ni wanaume gani wa Kibedui watatuona?' Ama 'madana' mahali maana yake ni kuishi humo, na 'madina' pia maana yake ni kufika mjini (madinah), hivyo maana hizo mbili zinakaribiana. Kwa swali hili (linalojielekeza lenyewe) kunajibiwa kwamba: 'hadhara' hutumika katika lugha kwa maana zinazohusiana na fikra, hivyo ni karibu zaidi kuitumia kwa dhana. Ilisemwa katika 'Al-Qamus': "Hadhura ni kama nadusa, ambaye ni mtu wa ufasaha (bayan) na ufahamu (fiqh)." Katika 'Al-Lisan' imesemwa: "mwanaume 'hadhr' maana yake ni mwenye ufasaha, na mwanaume 'hadhir' akileta kitu chema." Pia katika 'Al-Lisan' imekuja: "Na katika hadithi: 'Sema yale yaliyo yahdhurukum' yaani yale yaliyopo na yaliyopo ndani yenu, wala msijilemeze kwa kitu kingine." Kwa hiyo 'hadhara' ni karibu zaidi, ina mshikamano zaidi na inafaa zaidi kutumika kwa mkusanyiko wa dhana kuliko kutumia 'madaniyya', na 'madaniyya' ni karibu zaidi kutumika kwa vitu vya kimaada. Imesemwa kwamba hakuna ubishi katika istilahi, na muhimu ni kutofautisha kati ya dhana na vitu vya kimaada vinavyotokana nazo, na vitu vya kimaada vinavyotokana nazo, na vitu vinavyotokana na sayansi safi, uvumbuzi na viwanda. Ya kwanza inakataliwa na hairuhusiwi kuichukua, wakati ya pili inaruhusiwa kuichukua.
If it is said: Why did you adopt the technical term 'hadhara' for concepts and the term 'madaniyya' for material forms instead of the reverse? Hadhara in language, is residence in a civilised region (like towns), while 'al-hadhir' is the one who is of towns and villages. Al- Qatami said: 'Whoever is pleased with residing in towns. Which Bedouin men will see us?' While 'madana' in the place means to reside therein, and 'madina' means also to arrive to the town (madinah), so the two meanings are close to each other. It is said in response to this (self-directed) question: hadhara is used in the language for meanings related to thoughts, so it is closer to use it for concepts. It was said in 'Al-Qamus': "Hadhura is like nadusa which is the man of eloquence. (bayan) and understanding (fiqh)." In Al- Lisan, it is said: "a man 'hadhr' to mean eloquent, and a man 'hadhir' if he brought something good." It also came in 'Al-Lisan': "And in the hadith: 'Say that which yahdhurukum' i.e. that which is present and existing in you, and do not burden yourselves with something else." So hadhara is closer, more consistent and appropriate to use for the collection of concepts than using madaniyya, and madaniyya is closer to be used in material objects. It has been said that there is no contest in technical terminology (istilah), and what is important is distinguishing between concepts and material objects derived thereof, and material objects derived from them and material objects derived from pure sciences, inventions and industry. The first is rejected and it is not permitted to take them, while it is permitted to take the second.
Tulisema kwamba ustaarabu (hadhara) ni mkusanyiko wa dhana kuhusu maisha, na kwamba either ni ustaarabu wa kiroho wa kiungu (deeniyya) au wa kutengenezwa na binadamu. Mfano wa ustaarabu wa kiungu wa kiroho ni ustaarabu wa Kiislamu, na mifano ya ustaarabu wa kutengenezwa na binadamu ni ustaarabu wa Kihindi na ustaarabu wa Kimagharibi. Kuwepo kwa ustaarabu hizi ni jambo lisilo na shaka na ukweli uliothibitishwa usiopingika. Vivyo hivyo tofauti kati yao, kiasi kwamba hakuna awezaye kuikana isipokuwa mwongo. Chanzo cha ustaarabu wa kiungu, kwa mujibu wa watu wake, ni wahyi; chanzo cha ustaarabu wa kutengenezwa na binadamu ni watu waliokubaliana juu yake. Hili pekee linatosha kwa kutofautisha na kutenganisha. Hata kama inaonekana aina fulani ya mkutano katika baadhi ya dhana, hii si makubaliano wala jambo la pamoja. Hii ni kwa sababu ustaarabu, unapokubaliwa, lazima ukubaliwe pamoja na msingi uliotokana nao au msingi unaojengwa juu yake. Hivyo basi, ikiwa msingi kati ya ustaarabu mbili ni tofauti, makubaliano kati ya baadhi ya dhana zao, au kuwepo kwa mfanano kati ya baadhi ya dhana zao kuhusu maisha, hayastahili kuzingatiwa. Hii ni kwa sababu dhana ni tawi kutoka kwenye msingi wake (asl), na haiwezi kukubaliwa isipokuwa pamoja na msingi wake. Ustaarabu wa Kiislamu na ustaarabu wa Kimagharibi zote mbili zinaruhusu kula samaki, kuvaa sufi, umiliki binafsi, kumwakilisha mwanamke, kumhesabu mtawala na kutumia dawa. Hata hivyo, mambo haya na yanayofanana nayo hayazingatiwi kuwa ya ustaarabu wa Kiislamu isipokuwa yakikubaliwa kwa msingi wa kuwa ni wahyi kutoka kwa Allah kwenda kwa Muhammad ﷺ, yaani kwa msingi wa kuwa ni Shar'a, ilhali yanakubaliwa katika ustaarabu wa Kibepari kwa msingi wa kuwa ni maslahi (maslaha) au kwa kuboreshwa na akili zao. Ikiwa Mwislamu atayakubali kwa msingi wa maslahi yao (maslaha) au uboreshaji wa kiakili, haihesabiwi kuwa ni kuchukua kutoka kwa Uislamu.
We have said that the civilisation (hadhara) is a collection of concepts about life, and that either it is a spiritual divine one (deeniyya) or man- made. An example of the spiritual divine civilisation is the Islamic civilisation, and an example of the man-made are the Indian civilisation and Western civilisation. The existence of these civilisations is a definite matter and an incontestable established fact. Likewise is the difference between them, such that none but the liar can deny it. The source of the divine civilisation, according to its people, is revelation; the source of the man-made civilisation is the people who agreed on it. This alone suffices is enough for distinction and difference. Even if there appears a type of meeting in some of the concepts, this is not an agreement or a common matter. This is because civilisation, when it is adopted, must be adopted together with the basis from which it emanated or the basis it is built upon. So if the basis between two civilisations is different, the agreement between some of their concepts, or the existence of similarity between some of their concepts about life, is worth no attention. This is because the concept is a branch from its basis (asl), and it cannot be adopted except with its basis. Both the Islamic civilisation and the Western civilisation allow eating fish, wearing wool, private property, delegating the woman, accounting the ruler and taking medicine. However, these and their like are not considered of the Islamic civilisation unless they are adopted based upon being revelation from Allah to Muhammad i.e. upon their being Shar'a, whereas they are adopted in the Capitalist civilisation based upon their being of interest (maslaha) or their being ameliorated by their minds. If the Muslim adopts them based upon their interest (maslaha)or the rational amelioration, it is not considered adopting from Islam.
Tofauti kati ya ustaarabu ni jambo la ukweli lisilo na uwezekano wa kukanushwa. Kinachotuhusu ni tofauti kati ya ustaarabu wa Kiislamu na ustaarabu mwingine, hasa ustaarabu wa Kimagharibi, na yanayotokana na tofauti hii au yanayojengwa juu yake, kama vile masuala ya mazungumzo (al-hiwar), mgongano (as-sira'a), uwezekano wa kuanzisha ustaarabu mmoja wa kimataifa, aina na maumbo ya mgongano, je, mgongano utakoma, utajificha, au kutakuwa na ushindi wa ustaarabu mmoja juu ya mwingine? Nini maana ya mazungumzo ya kidini kati ya dini kwa mujibu wa wale wanaoyatolea wito, na msimamo sahihi kuhusu hilo ni upi? Tofauti kati ya dini na ustaarabu ni ipi, na kadhalika?
The difference between civilisations is a matter of fact without any possibility to deny it. What concerns us is the difference between the Islamic civilisation and others, in particular the Western civilisation, and what results from this difference or is built upon it, such as the issues of dialogue (al-hiwar), the clash (as-sira'a), the possibility of founding one universal civilisation, the forms and types of clash and will the clash cease, hide or will there be a victory for one civilisation over others? What is meant by religious dialogue between religions in view of those who call for it, and what is the correct position regarding it? What is the difference between religions and civilisations etc?
Dini zimegawanyika katika aina mbili: Dini ambayo kutokana nayo huibuka ustaarabu, yaani ina mkusanyiko wa dhana kuhusu maisha, kama dini ya Kiislamu, na dini ambayo kutokana nayo haibuki ustaarabu wowote, na ndani yake hakuna mkusanyiko wa dhana - kama dini ya Kikristo. Ingawa ina misingi ya kimaadili kama 'Usiibe na usifanye zinaa', haina hata hivyo mkusanyiko wa dhana unaofunika nyanja zote za maisha. Kwa hiyo, dini ya Kikristo ni mfano unaofaa wa dini ambayo kutokana nayo hakuna ustaarabu unaotokea.
Religions are of two types: A deen (religion) from which a civilisation emerges i.e. it has a collection of concepts about life, like the Islamic deen, and a religion from which no civilisation emerges - and there is no collection of concepts therein - like the Christian religion. Though it has ideals like 'Do not steal and do not commit zina', however, it has no collection of concepts covering all aspects of life. Hence, the Christian religion is an appropriate example of a religion from which no civilisation emanates.
Ustaarabu wa Kibepari hautokani na dini ya Kikristo, hata kama ulijitokeza katika nchi ambazo idadi kubwa ya wakazi wake ni Wakristo. Kwa hiyo mazungumzo, mgongano au ushirikiano kati ya Uislamu na Ukristo hutofautiana na mazungumzo au mgongano kati ya Uislamu na ustaarabu huo wa Kibepari.
The Capitalist civilisation does not emanate from the Christian religion; even if it came about in countries where the majority of their populations are Christians. So the dialogue or clash or partnership between Islam and Christianity differs from the dialogue or clash between it and the Capitalist civilisation.