46 The Neglected Duty

The structure of the Islamic State is based on seven pillars: the Khalifah; the Assistants; the Commander of Jihad; the Judiciary; the Wulaa’; the Administrative System; and the Majlis Al Ummah. The structure of the State would be complete if these seven elements were in place. If any of these elements were absent, the structure would be incomplete, though the State would still remain Islamic. Any defect or shortage would not upset its status as long as the Khalifah remained viable, since it is he who is the foundation of the State. As for the principles of the ruling system in the Islamic State, there are four:

1. The sovereignty belongs to the Shari’ah.

2. The authority belongs to the Ummah.

3. The appointment of one Khalifah.

4. The Khalifah alone reserves the right to adopt the Shari’ah rules, i.e. to enact them as laws.

If any of these principles were missing, the ruling system would become non-Islamic. Therefore, these four principles must be enforced. The basis of the Islamic State is the Khalifah and anyone other than him is a deputy to him or an advisor for him; the Islamic State is a Khalifah who implements Islam and the office of Khilafah or Imamah is to have full disposal over the affairs of Muslims. It is not part of the doctrines (‘Aqa’id) of Islam, but part of the Shari’ah rules because it is part of the branches related to a human’s actions.

The appointment of the Khalifah is an obligation upon the Muslims. They are forbidden from spending more than two nights without giving a Ba’yah to him. If the Muslims did not appoint a Khalifah within three days they would all be sinful until they had appointed a Khalifah. The sin would not fall until they had exhausted their efforts to appoint a Khalifah and continued to endeavor to appoint him.

The obligation of appointing a Khalifah has been confirmed by the Qu’ran, Sunnah and the general consensus of the Sahabah.

Allah (swt) ordered the Messenger (pbuh) conclusively to rule among the Muslims whatever was revealed to him. Allah (swt) says,

“So judge between them by what Allah has revealed, and follow not their vain desires.” [Al-Maidah 5:48]

“And so judge between them by what Allah has revealed and follow not their desires,” [Al-Maidah 5:49]

Any address to the Messenger (pbuh) is considered an address to the entire Ummah as long as there is no daleel restricting the order to the Messenger (pbuh). And there is no such daleel, therefore, Muslims are mandated to establish this ruling. Establishing the Khilafah is the establishment of this ruling.

As for the Sunnah, the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) said, “He who died not knowing the Imam of his time has died a death of Jahiliyyah.” Ahmed and al- Tabarani extracted from the Hadeeth of Mu’awiyah the following: The Messenger of Allah (pbuh) said, “Whoso dies while there was no Ba’yah on his neck dies a death of Jahiliyyah.” Muslim reported in his Sahih on the authority of Ibn ‘Umar that he said, I heard the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) say, “Whoso takes off his hand from allegiance to Allah will meet Him on the Day of Resurrection without having any proof for him, and whoso dies while there was no Ba’yah on his neck dies a death of Jahiliyyah.” Hisham reported on the authority of ‘Urwa, who reported on the authority of Abu Salih, who reported on the authority of Abu Hurayrah that the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) said, “Leaders will take charge of you after me, where the pious one will lead with his piety and the impious with his impiety, so listen to them and obey them in everything which conforms with the truth. If they acted rightly it is to your benefit, and if they acted wrongly it is counted for you and against them.”

As for the ‘Ijma’ of the Sahabah, they made the appointment of a Khalifah their top priority in the wake of the departure of the Messenger of Allah (pbuh). This is according to that which has been narrated in the two Sahih Ahadeeth about the events in the courtyard of Banu Sa’idah and also in the wake of the death of each subsequent Khalifah. The general consensus of the Sahabah concerning the obligation of appointing a Khalifah has been transmitted by way of Khabar Mutawatir (continuous report). The Sahabah agreed that it was the most important of all obligations. This is considered to be a conclusive evidence. It has also been confirmed by means of Tawatur that the Ummah should at no time remain without a Khalifah. It is obligatory upon the whole Ummah to appoint a Khalifah, i.e. to establish him in office or to govern her affairs. The command is addressed to the entire Ummah. This took effect from the moment of his (pbuh) departure and will continue to the Day of Judgment.

The extent of the obligation to reestablish the Khalifah and awareness of this obligation among the Sahabah is clearly reflected in their actions following the death of the Messenger of Allah (pbuh). They delayed the burial of the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) until a Khalifah had been given the Ba’yah to head the State. It is also clearly reflected in the action of ‘Umar ibn al-Khattab, in the wake of his stabbing while the agony of death neared; when the Muslims asked him to nominate a successor. At first he refused, when they persisted he nominated six candidates from which a Khalifah was to be elected. He also set a deadline of three days for the six to reach an agreement. He gave instructions stating that in the case of the six not coming to an agreement within the three days, the one who opposed the decision should be killed. Indeed, he ordered the killing of the one who sat in opposition despite the fact that the six were all people of Shura and senior Sahabah. The six were in fact ‘Ali, ‘Uthman, ‘Abd al-Rahman ibn ‘Auf, al-Zubayr ibn al-’Awwam, Talhah ibn ‘Ubaydullah and Sa’d ibn Abi Waqqas. That one of these Sahabah could have been killed, should they have been unable to reach an agreement concerning the election of a Khalifah, serves as an overwhelmingly clear evidence that the appointment of a Khalifah is compulsory.

Besides, numerous Shari’ah duties depend on the presence of the Khalifah, such as the implementation of Islamic rules, the execution of the penal code, guarding the frontiers, educating the society, training and equipping the Armed Forces, settling disputes and keeping law and order, in addition to looking after other matters and regulating the economic and societal transactions which take place between individuals and collective entities. Thus the appointment of a Khalifah is compulsory.

Seeking the post of Khalifah and competing for it is not undesirable, the Sahabah competed for the post in the Saqeefah and the people of Shura also competed for the office. Nobody condemned or disowned this action. On the contrary, the general consensus of the Sahabah regarding the competition for the post of Khalifah, is clearly established, confirming that it is lawful and acceptable.

Muslims are forbidden from appointing more than one Khalifah. Imam Muslim reported on the authority of Abu Sa’id al-Khudry that the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) said, “If a bay’ah has been taken for two Khulafah, kill the latter of them.” In another Hadeeth, he (pbuh) is reported to have said, “Whoso pledged allegiance to an Imam giving him the clasp of his hand and the fruit of his heart shall obey him as long as he can, and if another comes to dispute with him you must strike the neck of that man.” In another narration, the wording was as follows, “...strike him with the sword whoever he may be.” The command to kill the other one would come into effect if he did not comply and retreat. If a group of people, who met all the requirements necessary for the post of Khilafah, were given the Ba’yah then it would be the one with the majority of votes who would become Khalifah, whoever opposed the majority would subsequently be considered a rebel. This would apply if the nominees were gathered together in person, but if the Khilafah had been contracted to one man who fulfilled the requirements of the Khilafah and the majority of the Muslims gave their Ba’yah to another, then the first man should become Khalifah and the second man should be turned down.

The requirements for the Khilafah office are Islam, manhood, freedom, competence, maturity, sanity and justice, i.e. the candidate should be Muslim, male, mature, sane, free, competent and just. As for the condition of being a Muslim, this follows because of Allah’s saying,

“And never will Allah grant to the disbelievers a way (triumph) over the believers.” [An-Nisa, 4:141]

As for the condition that the Khalifah must be a man, it is derived from the Hadeeth of the Messenger of Allah (pbuh), who said, “A nation (Ummah) will never be successful if they are headed by a woman?” The conditions of maturity and sanity must be met because the insane and the minor need tutors and guardians to look after their welfare. Therefore, if one cannot rule one’s own affairs, he is obviously unable to run other affairs beyond his own. As for justice, this must be fulfilled because the duty of the Khalifah is to implement the rules of the Deen, and if he could not implement them upon himself then he could not be trusted to implement them upon others; for one cannot give what one does not possess. Justice has been made a condition which the Khalifah must fulfill because if he were a Fasiq then he would be unfit for the Khilafah and he could not remain in office. Trustworthiness is a condition laid down in the contract and it must be observed throughout.

As for the freedom, since the slave does not have the authority upon himself, therefore, he would not have authority over others. As for the competence, it is a requirement since asking an incompetent person to do things beyond his capacity is invalid. This leads to the undermining the legislation and the rights of the people, which is not allowed.

These are the set conditions for the post of Khalifah, as for the other conditions which the scholars have mentioned, such as bravery, knowledge and belonging to the Quraysh or a descendant of Fatimah among others, these are not necessary conditions for the contract of the Khilafah and none of the evidences put forward to back such claims have proven to be reliable and therefore cannot be considered as conditions. Every male Muslim who is mature, sane, trustworthy, free and able is fit to be given the Ba’yah by the other Muslims in order to become their Khalifah and no other conditions are needed nor should be laid down.

Reestablishing the Islamic State is a duty upon all the Muslims because this has been confirmed by the Sunnah and the general consensus of the Sahabah. It is obligatory upon them to live in an Islamic homeland and to have possess Islamic citizenship, yet they cannot achieve this unless they establish the Islamic State. Thus, the Muslims would remain sinful until they began to work towards reestablishing the Islamic State so that they could give their Ba’yah to a Khaleefah who would implement Islam and carry its Message to the world.

Superior Economic Model : Islamic System

Download Original eBook (PDF) : The lslamic State.pdf